By measuring the substructure of a jet, one can assign it a "quark" or
"gluon" tag. In the eikonal (double-logarithmic) limit, quark/gluon
discrimination is determined solely by the color factor of the initiating
parton (C_F versus C_A). In this paper, we confront the challenges faced when
going beyond this leading-order understanding, using both parton-shower
generators and first-principles calculations to assess the impact of
higher-order perturbative and nonperturbative physics. Working in the idealized
context of electron-positron collisions, where one can define a proxy for quark
and gluon jets based on the Lorentz structure of the production vertex, we find
a fascinating interplay between perturbative shower effects and nonperturbative
hadronization effects. Turning to proton-proton collisions, we highlight a core
set of measurements that would constrain current uncertainties in quark/gluon
tagging and improve the overall modeling of jets at the Large Hadron Collider.
The properties of quark and gluon jets, and the differences between them, are
increasingly important at the LHC. However, Monte Carlo event generators are
normally tuned to data from $e^+e^-$ collisions which are primarily sensitive
to quark-initiated jets. In order to improve the description of gluon jets we
make improvements to the perturbative and the non-perturbative modelling of
gluon jets and include data with gluon-initiated jets in the tuning for the
first time. The resultant tunes significantly improve the description of gluon
jets and are now the default in Herwig 7.1.
A new release of the Monte Carlo event generator Herwig (version 7.1) is now
available. This version introduces a number of improvements, notably: multi-jet
merging with the dipole shower at LO and NLO QCD; a new model for soft
interactions and diffraction; improvements to mass effects and top decays in
the dipole shower, as well as a new tune of the hadronisation parameters.
We report on the possibility of reweighting parton-shower Monte Carlo
predictions for scale variations in the parton-shower algorithm. The method is
based on a generalization of the Sudakov veto algorithm. We demonstrate the
feasibility of this approach using example physical distributions.
Implementations are available for both the parton-shower modules in the Herwig
7 event generator.
We perform a detailed study of the sources of perturbative uncertainty in
parton shower predictions within the Herwig 7 event generator. We benchmark two
rather different parton shower algorithms, based on angular-ordered and
dipole-type evolution, against each other. We deliberately choose leading order
plus parton shower as the benchmark setting to identify a controllable set of
uncertainties. This will enable us to reliably assess improvements by
higher-order contributions in a follow-up work.
With the advent and recent extension of the BLHA standard to interface Monte
Carlo event generators and one-loop matrix element providers, the Herwig++
event generator has expanded its range of applicability to a multitude of
underlying hard processes at NLO QCD. The new NLO development is centered
around the Matchbox framework, which turns fixed NLO QCD calculations into
parton shower matched calculations - to be matched to the two parton shower
variants of Herwig++. Matchbox provides thereby for the automated setup of the
underlying fixed NLO QCD calculations and the interface to the one-loop matrix
element providers, as well as for an efficient and automated multi-channel
phase space sampling, and forms the basis for the NLO capabilities of the new
release of Herwig++. Along with several other new features and developments,
the new release marks the end of distinguishing Herwig++ and (Fortran) HERWIG,
and constitutes the first major release of version 7 of the Herwig event
A major new release of the Monte Carlo event generator Herwig++ (version 3.0)
is now available. This release marks the end of distinguishing Herwig++ and
HERWIG development and therefore constitutes the first major release of version
7 of the Herwig event generator family. The new version features a number of
significant improvements to the event simulation, including: built-in NLO hard
process calculation for all Standard Model processes, with matching to both
angular-ordered and dipole shower modules via both subtractive (MC@NLO-type)
and multiplicative (Powheg-type) algorithms; QED radiation and spin
correlations in the angular ordered shower; a consistent treatment of
perturbative uncertainties within the hard process and parton showering.
Several of the new features will be covered in detail in accompanying
publications, and an update of the manual will follow in due course.
We carry out simple analytical calculations and Monte Carlo studies to better
understand the impact of QCD radiation on some well-known jet substructure
methods for jets arising from the decay of boosted Higgs bosons. Understanding
differences between taggers for these signal jets assumes particular
significance in situations where they perform similarly on QCD background jets.
As an explicit example of this we compare the Y-splitter method to the more
recently proposed Y-pruning technique. We demonstrate how the insight we gain
can be used to significantly improve the performance of Y-splitter by combining
it with trimming and show that this combination outperforms the other taggers
studied here, at high $p_T$. We also make analytical estimates for optimal
parameter values, for a range of methods and compare to results from Monte
An overview of theoretical and experimental progress in double parton
scattering (DPS) is presented. The theoretical topics cover factorization in
DPS, models for double parton distributions and DPS in charm production and
nuclear collisions. On the experimental side, CMS results for dijet and double
J/\psi\ production, in light of DPS, as well as first results for the 4-jet
channel are presented. ALICE reports on a study of open charm and J/\psi\
We review the modelling of multiple interactions in the event generator
Herwig++ and study implications of recent tuning efforts to Tevatron and LHC
data. It is often said that measurements of the effective cross section for
double-parton scattering, sigma_effective, are in contradiction with models of
the final state of multi-parton interactions, but we show that the Herwig++
model is consistent with both and gives stable predictions for underlying event
observables at 14 TeV.
We discuss various issues related to the definition of single and double open
charm cross sections. We conclude that LHCb's extraction of sigma_effective,
the effective cross section for double-parton scattering, is too large by a
factor of two. This correction brings the data from open-charm pairs closer to
that from J/psi plus open charm and jet production.
We review the implementation of a model for multiple partonic interactions in
Herwig++. Moreover, we show how recent studies on the colour structure of
events in Herwig++ led to a significant improvement in the description of soft
inclusive observables in pp interactions at the LHC.
In their 1997 paper, CDF measured sigma_effective, the normalization factor
that relates the cross section for double parton scattering to the product of
the inclusive cross sections of the two individual scatters, in a model in
which they are assumed to be independent. In his 2007 paper, Treleani pointed
out that CDF used a non-standard definition, in which the double parton
scattering cross section corresponds to exactly two scatters, rather than the
more conventional one in which it is the inclusive two-scatter cross section.
He also estimated the correction from one definition to the other, to give a
corrected value of sigma_effective. Treleani's form would be correct under the
assumption that CDF were able to uniquely identify and count the number of
scatters in an event, which is certainly not the case. In this publication we
consider CDF's event definition in more detail to provide an improved
We describe the implementation details of the colour reconnection model in
the event generator Herwig++. We study the impact on final-state observables in
detail and confirm the model idea from colour preconfinement on the basis of
studies within the cluster hadronization model. Moreover, we show that the
description of minimum bias and underlying event data at the LHC is improved
with this model and present results of a tune to available data.
We review the modelling of multiple interactions in the event generator
Herwig++ and study implications of recent tuning efforts to LHC data. A crucial
ingredient to a successful description of minimum-bias and underlying-event
observables is a model for colour reconnection. Improvements to this model,
inspired by statistical physics, are presented.
The claim that the W boson mass might be measured at the LHC with a precision
of O(10 MeV) is critically reviewed. It is argued that such a precision cannot
be achieved, unless a dedicated measurement program, specific to the LHC is
pursued. We propose such a program. Its main target is to significantly improve
the experimental control of the relative polarisation of the W+, W- and Z
bosons. We propose to achieve this goal either by running dedicated isoscalar
beams at the LHC or by running, in parallel to the standard p-p collision
program, a dedicated muon scattering "LHC-support-experiment" at the CERN SPS.
One of these auxiliary measurements is necessary for the "precision measurement
program" at the LHC, but not sufficient. It must be followed by dedicated
measurement strategies which are robust with respect to both the systematic
measurement uncertainties and to the perturbative and non-perturbative QCD
effects. We propose such strategies and evaluate their precision. At the LHC,
contrary to the Tevatron case, both the masses of the W+ and of the W- bosons
must be measured with high precision. In this context, we propose and evaluate
LHC dedicated strategies to measure the difference of the masses of the W+ and
W- bosons and of the absolute mass of the W boson assuming both masses are
equal. We show how one can overcome the obstacles in measuring the masses of W+
and W- to a precision of 10 MeV. We present a detailed evaluation of the
precision of the proposed methods based on the studies of a large, O(10^11),
sample of simulated W and Z production events.
The transverse momentum of electroweak bosons in a Drell-Yan process is an
important quantity for the experimental program at the LHC. The new model of
non-perturbative gluon emission in an initial state parton shower presented in
this note gives a good description of this quantity for the data taken in
previous experiments over a wide range of CM energy. The model's prediction for
the transverse momentum distribution of Z bosons for the LHC is presented and
used for a comparison with other approaches.
We consider a model of transverse momentum production in which
non-perturbative smearing takes place throughout the perturbative evolution, by
a simple modification to an initial state parton shower algorithm. Using this
as the important non-perturbative ingredient, we get a good fit to data over a
wide range of energy. Combining it with the non-perturbative masses and cutoffs
that are a feature of conventional parton showers also leads to a reasonable
fit. We discuss the extrapolation to the LHC.