-
Van der Waals heterostructures (VDWHs) exhibit rich properties and thus has
potential for applications, and charge transfer between different layers in a
heterostructure often dominates its properties and device performance. It is
thus critical to reveal and understand the charge transfer effects in VDWHs,
for which electronic structure measurements have proven to be effective. Using
angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy, we studied the electronic structures
of (PbSe)1.16(TiSe2)m(m=1, 2), which are naturally occurring VDWHs, and
discovered several striking charge transfer effects. When the thickness of the
TiSe2 layers is halved from m=2 to m=1, the amount of charge transferred
increases unexpectedly by more than 250%. This is accompanied by a dramatic
drop in the electron-phonon interaction strength far beyond the prediction by
first-principles calculations and, consequently, superconductivity only exists
in the m=2 compound with strong electron-phonon interaction, albeit with lower
carrier density. Furthermore, we found that the amount of charge transferred in
both compounds is nearly halved when warmed from below 10 K to room
temperature, due to the different thermal expansion coefficients of the
constituent layers of these misfit compounds. These unprecedentedly large
charge transfer effects might widely exist in VDWHs composed of
metal-semiconductor contacts; thus, our results provide important insights for
further understanding and applications of VDWHs.
-
Bismuthates were the first family of oxide high-temperature superconductors,
exhibiting superconducting transition temperatures (Tc) up to 32K, but the
superconducting mechanism remains under debate despite more than 30 years of
extensive research. Our angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy studies on
Ba$_{0.51}$K$_{0.49}$BiO$_3$ reveal an unexpectedly 34% larger bandwidth than
in conventional density functional theory calculations. This can be reproduced
by calculations that fully account for long-range Coulomb interactions --- the
first direct demonstration of bandwidth expansion due to the Fock exchange
term, a long-accepted and yet uncorroborated fundamental effect in many body
physics. Furthermore, we observe an isotropic superconducting gap with
2\Delta$_0$/k$_B$ T$_c$ = 3.51 $\pm$ 0.05, and strong electron-phonon
interactions with a coupling constant \lambda$\sim$ 1.3 $\pm$ 0.2. These
findings solve a long-standing mystery --- Ba$_{0.51}$K$_{0.49}$BiO$_3$ is an
extraordinary Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer (BCS) superconductor, where long-range
Coulomb interactions expand the bandwidth, enhance electron-phonon coupling,
and generate the high Tc. Such effects will also be critical for finding new
superconductors.
-
Crystal electric field states in rare earth intermetallics show an intricate
entanglement with the many-body physics that occurs in these systems and that
is known to lead to a plethora of electronic phases. Here, we attempt to trace
different contributions to the crystal electric field (CEF) splittings in
CeIrIn$_5$, a heavy-fermion compound and member of the Ce$M$In$_5$ ($M$= Co,
Rh, Ir) family. To this end, we utilize high-resolution resonant angle-resolved
photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) and present a spectroscopic study of the
electronic structure of this unconventional superconductor over a wide
temperature range. As a result, we show how ARPES can be used in combination
with thermodynamic measurements or neutron scattering to disentangle different
contributions to the CEF splitting in rare earth intermetallics. We also find
that the hybridization is stronger in CeIrIn$_5$ than CeCoIn$_5$ and the
effects of the hybridization on the Fermi volume increase is much smaller than
predicted. By providing the first experimental evidence for $4f_{7/2}^{1}$
splittings which, in CeIrIn$_5$, split the octet into four doublets, we clearly
demonstrate the many-body origin of the so-called $4f_{7/2}^{1}$ state.
-
A key issue in heavy fermion research is how subtle changes in the
hybridization between the 4$f$ (5$f$) and conduction electrons can result in
fundamentally different ground states. CeRhIn$_5$ stands out as a particularly
notable example: replacing Rh by either Co or Ir, located above or below Rh in
the periodic table, antiferromagnetism gives way to superconductivity. In this
photoemission study of CeRhIn$_5$, we demonstrate that the use of resonant
ARPES with polarized light allows to extract detailed information on the 4$f$
crystal field states and details on the 4$f$ and conduction electron
hybridization which together determine the ground state. We directly observe
weakly dispersive Kondo resonances of $f$-electrons and identify two of the
three Ce $4f_{5/2}^{1}$ crystal-electric-field levels and band-dependent
hybridization, which signals that the hybridization occurs primarily between
the Ce $4f$ states in the CeIn$_3$ layer and two more three-dimensional bands
composed of the Rh $4d$ and In $5p$ orbitals in the RhIn$_2$ layer. Our results
allow to connect the properties observed at elevated temperatures with the
unusual low-temperature properties of this enigmatic heavy fermion compound.
-
Bulk FeSe is superconducting with a critical temperature $T_c$ $\cong$ 8 K
and SrTiO$_3$ is insulating in nature, yet high-temperature superconductivity
has been reported at the interface between a single-layer FeSe and SrTiO$_3$.
Angle resolved photoemission spectroscopy and scanning tunneling microscopy
measurements observe a gap opening at the Fermi surface below $\approx$ 60 K.
Elucidating the microscopic properties and understanding the pairing mechanism
of single-layer FeSe is of utmost importance as it is a basic building block of
iron-based superconductors. Here, we use the low-energy muon spin
rotation/relaxation technique (LE-$\mu$SR) to detect and quantify the
supercarrier density and determine the gap symmetry in FeSe grown on SrTiO$_3$
(100). Measurements in applied field show a temperature dependent broadening of
the field distribution below $\sim$ 60 K, reflecting the superconducting
transition and formation of a vortex state. Zero field measurements rule out
the presence of magnetism of static or fluctuating origin. From the
inhomogeneous field distribution, we determine an effective sheet supercarrier
density $n_s^{2D} \simeq 6 \times 10^{14}$ cm$^{-2}$ at $T \rightarrow 0$ K,
which is a factor of 4 larger than expected from ARPES measurements of the
excess electron count per Fe of 1 monolayer (ML) FeSe. The temperature
dependence of the superfluid density $n_s(T)$ can be well described down to
$\sim$ 10 K by simple s-wave BCS, indicating a rather clean superconducting
phase with a gap of 10.2(1.1) meV. The result is a clear indication of the
gradual formation of a two dimensional vortex lattice existing over the entire
large FeSe/STO interface and provides unambiguous evidence for robust
superconductivity below 60 K in ultrathin FeSe.
-
The dream of room temperature superconductors has inspired intense research
effort to find routes for enhancing the superconducting transition temperature
(Tc). Therefore, single-layer FeSe on a SrTiO3 substrate, with its
extraordinarily high Tc amongst all interfacial superconductors and iron based
superconductors, is particularly interesting, but the mechanism underlying its
high Tc has remained mysterious. Here we show through isotope effects that
electrons in FeSe couple with the oxygen phonons in the substrate, and the
superconductivity is enhanced linearly with the coupling strength atop the
intrinsic superconductivity of heavily-electron-doped FeSe. Our observations
solve the enigma of FeSe/SrTiO3, and experimentally establish the critical role
and unique behavior of electron-phonon forward scattering in a correlated
high-Tc superconductor. The effective cooperation between interlayer
electron-phonon interactions and correlations suggests a path forward in
developing more high-Tc interfacial superconductors, and may shed light on
understanding the high Tc of bulk high temperature superconductors with layered
structures.
-
In the iron-based superconductors, understanding the relation between
superconductivity and electronic structure upon doping is crucial for exploring
the pairing mechanism. Recently it was found that in iron selenide (FeSe),
enhanced superconductivity (Tc over 40K) can be achieved via electron doping,
with the Fermi surface only comprising M-centered electron pockets. Here by
utilizing surface potassium dosing, scanning tunneling microscopy/spectroscopy
(STM/STS) and angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES), we studied the
electronic structure and superconductivity of (Li0.8Fe0.2OH)FeSe in the deep
electron-doped regime. We find that a {\Gamma}-centered electron band, which
originally lies above the Fermi level (EF), can be continuously tuned to cross
EF and contribute a new electron pocket at {\Gamma}. When this Lifshitz
transition occurs, the superconductivity in the M-centered electron pocket is
slightly suppressed; while a possible superconducting gap with small size (up
to ~5 meV) and a dome-like doping dependence is observed on the new {\Gamma}
electron pocket. Upon further K dosing, the system eventually evolves into an
insulating state. Our findings provide new clues to understand
superconductivity versus Fermi surface topology and the correlation effect in
FeSe-based superconductors.
-
Hexagonal FeSe thin films were grown on SrTiO3 substrates and the temperature
and thickness dependence of their electronic structures were studied. The
hexagonal FeSe is found to be metallic and electron doped, whose Fermi surface
consists of six elliptical electron pockets. With decreased temperature, parts
of the bands shift downward to high binding energy while some bands shift
upwards to EF. The shifts of these bands begin around 300 K and saturate at low
temperature, indicating a magnetic phase transition temperature of about 300 K.
With increased film thickness, the Fermi surface topology and band structure
show no obvious change except some minor quantum size effect. Our paper reports
the first electronic structure of hexagonal FeSe, and shows that the possible
magnetic transition is driven by large scale electronic structure
reconstruction.
-
Recently, superconductivity in potassium (K) doped p-terphenyl (C18H14) has
been suggested by the possible observation of the Meissner effect and
subsequent photoemission spectroscopy measurements, but the detailed lattice
structure and more-direct evidence are still lacking. Here we report a low
temperature scanning tunneling microscopy/spectroscopy (STM/STS) study on
K-doped single layer p-terphenyl films grown on Au (111). We observe several
ordered phases with different morphologies and electronic behaviors, in two of
which a sharp and symmetric low-energy gap of about 11 meV opens below 50 K. In
particular, the gap shows no obvious response to a magnetic field up to 11
Tesla, which would caution against superconductivity as an interpretation in
previous reports of K-doped p-terphenyl materials. Such gapped phases are
rarely (if ever) observed in single layer hydrocarbon molecular crystals. Our
work also paves the way for fabricating doped two-dimensional (2D) hydrocarbon
materials, which will provide a platform to search for novel emergent
phenomena.
-
Here we report the electronic structure of FeS, a recently identified
iron-based superconductor. Our high-resolution angle-resolved photoemission
spectroscopy studies show two hole-like ($\alpha$ and $\beta$) and two
electron-like ($\eta$ and $\delta$) Fermi pockets around the Brillouin zone
center and corner, respectively, all of which exhibit moderate dispersion along
$k_z$. However, a third hole-like band ($\gamma$) is not observed, which is
expected around the zone center from band calculations and is common in
iron-based superconductors. Since this band has the highest renormalization
factor and is known to be the most vulnerable to defects, its absence in our
data is likely due to defect scattering --- and yet superconductivity can exist
without coherent quasiparticles in the $\gamma$ band. This may help resolve the
current controversy on the superconducting gap structure of FeS. Moreover, by
comparing the $\beta$ bandwidths of various iron chalcogenides, including FeS,
FeSe$_{1-x}$S$_x$, FeSe, and FeSe$_{1-x}$ Te$_x$, we find that the $\beta$
bandwidth of FeS is the broadest. However, the band renormalization factor of
FeS is still quite large, when compared with the band calculations, which
indicates sizable electron correlations. This explains why the unconventional
superconductivity can persist over such a broad range of isovalent substitution
in FeSe$_{1-x}$Te$_{x}$ and FeSe$_{1-x}$S$_{x}$.
-
Pairing in the cuprate high-temperature superconductors and its origin remain
among the most enduring mysteries in condensed matter physics. With
cross-sectional scanning tunneling microscopy/ spectroscopy, we clearly reveal
the spatial-dependence or inhomogeneity of the superconducting gap structure of
Bi$_2$Sr$_2$CaCu$_2$O$_{8+\delta}$ (Bi2212) and YBa$_2$Cu$_3$O$_{7-x}$ (YBCO)
along their $c$-axes on a scale shorter than the interlayer spacing. By
tunneling into the (100) plane of a Bi2212 single crystal and a YBCO film, we
observe both U-shaped tunneling spectra with extended flat zero-conductance
bottoms, and V-shaped gap structures, in different regions of each sample. On
the YBCO film, tunneling into a (110) surface only reveals a U-shaped gap
without any zero-bias peak. Our analysis suggests that the U-shaped gap is
likely a nodeless superconducting gap. The V-shaped gap has a very small
amplitude, and is likely proximity-induced by regions having the larger
U-shaped gap.
-
Extremely high magnetoresistance (XMR) in the lanthanum monopnictides La$X$
($X$ = Sb, Bi) has recently attracted interest in these compounds as candidate
topological materials. However, their perfect electron-hole compensation
provides an alternative explanation, so the possible role of topological
surface states requires verification through direct observation. Our
angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) data reveal multiple
Dirac-like surface states near the Fermi level in both materials. Intriguingly,
we have observed circular dichroism in both surface and near-surface bulk
bands. Thus the spin-orbit coupling-induced orbital and spin angular momentum
textures may provide a mechanism to forbid backscattering in zero field,
suggesting that surface and near-surface bulk bands may contribute strongly to
XMR in La$X$. The extremely simple rock salt structure of these materials and
the ease with which high-quality crystals can be prepared suggests that they
may be an ideal platform for further investigation of topological matter.
-
Heavy fermion materials gain high electronic masses and expand Fermi surfaces
when the high-temperature localized f electrons become itinerant and hybridize
with the conduction band at low temperatures. However, despite the common
application of this model, direct microscopic verification remains lacking.
Here we report high-resolution angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy
measurements on CeCoIn5, a prototypical heavy fermion compound, and reveal the
long-sought band hybridization and Fermi surface expansion. Unexpectedly, the
localized-to-itinerant transition occurs at surprisingly high temperatures, yet
f electrons are still largely localized at the lowest temperature. Moreover,
crystal field excitations likely play an important role in the anomalous
temperature dependence. Our results paint an comprehensive unanticipated
experimental picture of the heavy fermion formation in a periodic multi-level
Anderson/Kondo lattice, and set the stage for understanding the emergent
properties in related materials.
-
(Li0.8Fe0.2)OHFeSe is a newly-discovered intercalated iron-selenide
superconductor with a Tc above 40 K, which is much higher than the Tc of bulk
FeSe (8 K). Here we report a systematic study of (Li0.8Fe0.2)OHFeSe by low
temperature scanning tunneling microscopy (STM). We observed two kinds of
surface terminations, namely FeSe and (Li0.8Fe0.2)OH surfaces. On the FeSe
surface, the superconducting state is fully gapped with double coherence peaks,
and a vortex core state with split peaks near EF is observed. Through
quasi-particle interference (QPI) measurements, we clearly observed intra- and
inter-pocket scatterings in between the electron pockets at the M point, as
well as some evidence of scattering that connects gamma and M points. Upon
applying magnetic field, the QPI intensity of all the scattering channels are
found to behave similarly. Furthermore, we studied impurity effects on the
superconductivity by investigating intentionally introduced impurities and
intrinsic defects. We observed that magnetic impurities such as Cr adatoms can
induce in-gap states and suppress superconductivity. However, nonmagnetic
impurities such as Zn adatoms do not induce visible in-gap states. Meanwhile,
we show that Zn adatoms can induce in-gap states in thick FeSe films, which is
believed to have an (s+-)wave pairing symmetry. Our experimental results
suggest it is likely that (Li0.8Fe0.2)OHFeSe is a plain s-wave superconductor,
whose order parameter has the same sign on all Fermi surface sections.
-
In iron-based superconductors, a spin-density-wave (SDW) magnetic order is
suppressed with doping and unconventional superconductivity appears in close
proximity to the SDW instability. The optical response of the SDW order shows
clear gap features: substantial suppression in the low-frequency optical
conductivity, alongside a spectral weight transfer from low to high
frequencies. Here, we study the detailed temperature dependence of the optical
response in three different series of the Ba122 system
[Ba$_{1-x}$K$_{x}$Fe$_{2}$As$_{2}$, Ba(Fe$_{1-x}$Co$_{x}$)$_{2}$As$_{2}$ and
BaFe$_{2}$(As$_{1-x}$P$_{x}$)$_{2}$]. Intriguingly, we found that the
suppression of the low-frequency optical conductivity and spectral weight
transfer appear at a temperature $T^{\ast}$ much higher than the SDW transition
temperature $T_{SDW}$. Since this behavior has the same optical feature and
energy scale as the SDW order, we attribute it to SDW fluctuations.
Furthermore, $T^{\ast}$ is suppressed with doping, closely following the doping
dependence of the nematic fluctuations detected by other techniques. These
results suggest that the magnetic and nematic orders have an intimate
relationship, in favor of the magnetic-fluctuation-driven nematicity scenario
in iron-based superconductors.
-
PtBi2 with a layered trigonal crystal structure was recently reported to
exhibit an unconventional large linear magnetoresistance, while the mechanism
involved is still elusive. Using high resolution angle-resolved photoemission
spectroscopy, we present a systematic study on its bulk and surface electronic
structure. Through careful comparison with first-principle calculations, our
experiment distinguishes the low-lying bulk bands from entangled surface
states, allowing the estimation of the real stoichiometry of samples. We find
significant electron doping in PtBi2, implying a substantial Bi deficiency
induced disorder therein. We discover a Dirac-cone-like surface state on the
boundary of the Brillouin zone, which is identified as an accidental Dirac band
without topological protection. Our findings exclude quantum-limit-induced
linear band dispersion as the cause of the unconventional large linear
magnetoresistance.
-
Iron chalcogenide superconductors are multi-band systems with strong electron
correlations. Here we use angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy to study
band dependent correlation effects in single-layer FeSe/Nb:BaTiO3/KTaO3, a new
iron chalcogenide superconductor with non-degenerate electron pockets and
interface-enhanced superconductivity. The non-degeneracy of the electron bands
helps to resolve the temperature dependent evolution of different bands. With
increasing temperature, the single layer FeSe undergoes a band-selective
localization, in which the coherent spectral weight of one electron band is
completely depleted while that of the other one remains finite. In addition,
the spectral weight of the incoherent background is enhanced with increasing
temperature, indicating a coherent-incoherent crossover. Signatures of
polaronic behavior are observed, suggesting electron-boson interactions. These
phenomena help to construct a more complete picture of electron correlations in
the FeSe family.
-
FeSe exhibits a novel ground state in which superconductivity coexists with a
nematic order in the absence of any long-range magnetic order. Here we report
an angle-resolved photoemission study on the superconducting gap structure in
the nematic state of FeSe$_{0.93}$S$_{0.07}$, without the complication caused
by Fermi surface reconstruction induced by magnetic order. We found that the
superconducting gap shows a pronounced 2-fold anisotropy around the elliptical
hole pocket near the Z point of the Brillouin zone, with gap minima at the
endpoints of its major axis, while no detectable gap was observed around the
zone center and zone corner. The large anisotropy and nodal gap distribution
demonstrate the substantial effects of the nematicity on the superconductivity,
and thus put strong constraints on the current theories.
-
The 122$^{*}$ series of iron-chalcogenide superconductors, for example
K$_x$Fe$_{2-y}$Se$_{2}$, only possesses electron Fermi pockets. Their
distinctive electronic structure challenges the picture built upon iron
pnictide superconductors, where both electron and hole Fermi pockets coexist.
However, partly due to the intrinsic phase separation in this family of
compounds, many aspects of their behavior remain elusive. In particular, the
evolution of the 122$^{*}$ series of iron-chalcogenides with chemical
substitution still lacks a microscopic and unified interpretation. Using
angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy, we studied a major fraction of
122$^{*}$ iron-chalcogenides, including the isovalently `doped'
K$_x$Fe$_{2-y}$Se$_{2-z}$S$_z$, Rb$_x$Fe$_{2-y}$Se$_{2-z}$Te$_z$ and
(Tl,K)$_x$Fe$_{2-y}$Se$_{2-z}$S$_z$. We found that the bandwidths of the low
energy Fe \textit{3d} bands in these materials depend on doping; and more
crucially, as the bandwidth decreases, the ground state evolves from a metal to
a superconductor, and eventually to an insulator, yet the Fermi surface in the
metallic phases is unaffected by the isovalent dopants. Moreover, the
correlation-driven insulator found here with small band filling may be a novel
insulating phase. Our study shows that almost all the known 122$^{*}$-series
iron chalcogenides can be understood {\it via} one unifying phase diagram which
implies that moderate correlation strength is beneficial for the
superconductivity.
-
Various Fe-vacancy orders have been reported in tetragonal Fe1-xSe single
crystals and nanowires/nanosheets, which are similar to those found in alkali
metal intercalated A1-xFe2-ySe2 superconductors. Here we report the in-situ
angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy study of Fe-vacancy disordered and
ordered phases in FeSe multi-layer thin films grown by molecular beam epitaxy.
Low temperature annealed FeSe films are identified to be Fe-vacancy disordered
phase and electron doped. Further long-time low temperature anneal can change
the Fe-vacancy disordered phase to ordered phase, which is found to be
semiconductor/insulator with (root 5) x (root 5) superstructure and can be
reversely changed to disordered phase with high temperature anneal. Our results
reveal that the disorder-order transition in FeSe thin films can be simply
tuned by vacuum anneal and the (root 5) x (root 5) Fe-vacancy ordered phase is
more likely the parent phase of FeSe.
-
We report the surface electronic structure of niobium phosphide NbP single
crystal on (001) surface by vacuum ultraviolet angle-resolved photoemission
spectroscopy. Combining with our first principle calculations, we identify the
existence of the Fermi arcs originated from topological surface states.
Furthermore, the surface states exhibit circular dichroism pattern, which may
correlate with its non-trivial spin texture. Our results provide critical
evidence for the existence of the Weyl Fermions in NbP, which lays the
foundation for further investigations.
-
The electronic structure of FeSe thin films grown on SrTiO3 substrate is
studied by angle-resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES). We reveal the
existence of Dirac cone band dispersions in FeSe thin films thicker than 1 Unit
Cell below the nematic transition temperature, whose apex are located -10 meV
below Fermi energy. The evolution of Dirac cone electronic structure for FeSe
thin films as function of temperature, thickness and cobalt doping is
systematically studied. The Dirac cones are found to be coexisted with the
nematicity in FeSe, disappear when nematicity is suppressed. Our results
provide some indication that the spin degrees of freedom may play some kind of
role in the nematicity of FeSe.
-
In FeSe-derived superconductors, the lack of a systematic and clean control
on the carrier concentration prevents the comprehensive understanding on the
phase diagram and the interplay between different phases. Here by K dosing and
angle resolved photoemission study on thick FeSe films and
FeSe$_{0.93}$S$_{0.07}$ bulk crystals, the phase diagram of FeSe as a function
of electron doping is established, which is extraordinarily different from
other Fe-based superconductors. The correlation strength remarkably increases
with increasing doping, while an insulting phase emerges in the heavily
overdoped regime. Between the nematic phase and the insulating phase, a dome of
enhanced superconductivity is observed, with the maximum superconducting
transition temperature of 44$\pm$2~K. The enhanced superconductivity is
independent of the thickness of FeSe, indicating that it is intrinsic to FeSe.
Our findings provide an ideal system with variable doping for understanding the
different phases and rich physics in the FeSe family.
-
Temperature and fluence dependence of the 1.55-eV optical transient
reflectivity in BaFe$_{2}$(As$_{1-x}$P$_{x}$)$_{2}$ was measured and analysed
in the low and high excitation density limit. The effective magnitude of the
superconducting gap of $\sim 5$ meV obtained from the low-fluence-data
bottleneck model fit is consistent with the ARPES results for the $\gamma$-hole
Fermi surface. The superconducting-state nonthermal optical destruction energy
was determined from the fluence dependent data. The in-plane optical
destruction energy scales well with T$_{\mathrm{c}}^{2}$ and is found to be
similar in a number of different layered superconductors.
-
Sr2IrO4 was predicted to be a high temperature superconductor upon electron
doping since it highly resembles the cuprates in crystal structure, electronic
structure and magnetic coupling constants. Here we report a scanning tunneling
microscopy/spectroscopy (STM/STS) study of Sr2IrO4 with surface electron doping
by depositing potassium (K) atoms. At the 0.5-0.7 monolayer (ML) K coverage, we
observed a sharp, V-shaped gap with about 95% loss of density of state (DOS) at
EFand visible coherence peaks. The gap magnitude is 25-30 meV for 0.5-0.6 ML K
coverage and it closes around 50 K. These behaviors exhibit clear signature of
superconductivity. Furthermore, we found that with increased electron doping,
the system gradually evolves from an insulating state to a normal metallic
state, via a pseudogap-like state and possible superconducting state. Our data
suggest possible high temperature superconductivity in electron doped Sr2IrO4,
and its remarkable analogy to the cuprates.