Quantum optical amplification that beats the noise addition limit for
deterministic amplifiers has been realized experimentally using several
different nondeterministic protocols. These schemes either require
single-photon sources, or operate by noise addition and photon subtraction.
Here we present an experimental demonstration of a protocol that allows
nondeterministic amplification of known sets of coherent states with high gain
and high fidelity. The experimental system employs the two mature quantum
optical technologies of state comparison and photon subtraction and does not
rely on elaborate quantum resources such as single-photon sources. The use of
coherent states rather than single photons allows for an increased rate of
amplification and a less complex photon source. Furthermore it means that the
amplification is not restricted to low amplitude states. With respect to the
two key parameters, fidelity and amplified state production rate, we
demonstrate, without the use of quantum resources, significant improvements
over previous experimental implementations.