
Motivated by multiple phenomenological considerations, we perform the first
search for the existence of a $\bar{b}\bar{b}bb$ tetraquark bound state with a
mass below the lowest noninteracting bottomoniumpair threshold using the
firstprinciples lattice nonrelativistic QCD methodology. We use a full
$S$wave colour/spin basis for the $\bar{b}\bar{b}bb$ operators in the three
$0^{++}$, $1^{+}$ and $2^{++}$ channels. We employ four gluon field ensembles
at multiple lattice spacing values ranging from $a = 0.06  0.12$ fm, all of
which include $u$, $d$, $s$ and $c$ quarks in the sea, and one ensemble which
has physical lightquark masses. Additionally, we perform novel exploratory
work with the objective of highlighting any signal of a near threshold
tetraquark, if it existed, by adding an auxiliary potential into the QCD
interactions. With our results we find no evidence of a QCD bound tetraquark
below the lowest noninteracting thresholds in the channels studied.

There has been much theoretical speculation about the existence of a deeply
bounded tetrabottom state. Such a state would not be expected to be more than
a GeV below $\Upsilon\Upsilon$ threshold. If such a state exists below the
$\eta_b\eta_b$ threshold it would be narrow, as Zweig allowed strong decays are
kinematically forbidden. Given the observation of $\Upsilon$ pair production at
CMS, such a state with a large branching fraction into $\Upsilon \Upsilon^*$ is
likely discoverable at the LHC. The discovery mode is similar to the SM Higgs
decaying into four leptons through the $Z Z^*$ channel. The testable features
of both production and the four lepton decays of such a tetrabottom ground
state are presented. The assumptions required for each feature are identified,
allowing the application of our results more generally to a resonance decaying
into four charged leptons (through the $\Upsilon\Upsilon^*$ channel) in the
same mass region.

Part 2 of "Project X: Accelerator Reference Design, Physics Opportunities,
Broader Impacts". In this Part, we outline the particlephysics program that
can be achieved with Project X, a staged superconducting linac for
intensityfrontier particle physics. Topics include neutrino physics, kaon
physics, muon physics, electric dipole moments, neutronantineutron
oscillations, new light particles, hadron structure, hadron spectroscopy, and
latticeQCD calculations. Part 1 is available as arXiv:1306.5022
[physics.accph] and Part 3 is available as arXiv:1306.5024 [physics.accph].

Very recently, the Belle and BESIII experiments observed a new
charmoniumlike state $X(3823)$, which is a good candidate for the $D$wave
charmonium $\psi(1^3D_2)$. Because the $X(3823)$ is just near the $D\bar{D}^*$
threshold, the decay $X(3823)\to J/\psi\pi^+\pi^$ can be a golden channel to
test the significance of coupledchannel effects. In this work, this decay is
considered including both the hiddencharm dipion and the usual quantum
chromodynamics multipole expansion (QCDME) contributions. The partial decay
width, the dipion invariant mass spectrum distribution
$\mathrm{d}\Gamma[X(3823)\to J/\psi\pi^+\pi^]/\mathrm{d}m_{\pi^+\pi^}$, and
the corresponding $\mathrm{d}\Gamma[X(3823)\to
J/\psi\pi^+\pi^]/\mathrm{d}\cos\theta$ distribution are computed. Many
parameters are determined from existing experimental data, so the results
depend mainly only on one unknown phase between the QCDME and hiddencharm
dipion amplitudes.

Muonbased facilities offer unique potential to provide capabilities at both
the Intensity Frontier with Neutrino Factories and the Energy Frontier with
Muon Colliders. They rely on a novel technology with challenging parameters,
for which the feasibility is currently being evaluated by the Muon Accelerator
Program (MAP). A realistic scenario for a complementary series of staged
facilities with increasing complexity and significant physics potential at each
stage has been developed. It takes advantage of and leverages the capabilities
already planned for Fermilab, especially the strategy for longterm improvement
of the accelerator complex being initiated with the Proton Improvement Plan
(PIPII) and the Long Baseline Neutrino Facility (LBNF). Each stage is designed
to provide an R&D platform to validate the technologies required for subsequent
stages. The rationale and sequence of the staging process and the critical
issues to be addressed at each stage, are presented.

A lepton collider in the multiTeV range has the potential to measure the
trilinear Higgs selfcoupling constant $\lambda_{hhh}$ via the Wfusion mode
$\ell^+\ell^ \rightarrow \nu_\ell \bar{\nu}_\ell h h$. In this paper we do a
generatorlevel study to explore how centerofmass energy spread, cone size,
tracking resolution, and collision energy range affect how precisely a muon
collider can measure $\lambda_{hhh}$ in comparison to an $e^+e^$ collider. The
smaller spread in centerofmass energy and higher energy range of a muon
collider improve cross section while the larger cone required to reduce
beaminduced background hinders detection of doubleHiggs events. Our results
motivate a more detailed study of a multiTeV muon collider and innovative
detector and analysis technologies required for background rejection and
precision measurement.

In this Snowmass White Paper, we discuss physics opportunities involving
heavy quarkonia at the intensity and energy frontiers of high energy physics.
We focus primarily on two specific aspects of quarkonium physics for which
significant advances can be expected from experiments at both frontiers. The
first aspect is the spectroscopy of charmonium and bottomonium states above the
openheavyflavor thresholds. Experiments at e^+ e^ colliders and at hadron
colliders have discovered many new, unexpected quarkonium states in the last 10
years. Many of these states are surprisingly narrow, and some have electric
charge. The observations of these charged quarkonium states are the first
definitive discoveries of manifestly exotic hadrons. These results challenge
our understanding of the QCD spectrum. The second aspect is the production of
heavy quarkonium states with large transverse momentum. Experiments at the LHC
are measuring quarkonium production with high statistics at unprecedented
values of p_T. Recent theoretical developments may provide a rigorous
theoretical framework for inclusive production of quarkonia at large p_T.
Experiments at the energy frontier will provide definitive tests of this
framework. Experiments at the intensity frontier also provide an opportunity to
understand the exclusive production of quarkonium states.

We propose the construction of, and describe in detail, a compact Muon
Collider schannel Higgs Factory.

We propose the construction of a compact Muon Collider Higgs Factory. Such a
machine can produce up to \sim 14,000 at 8\times 10^{31} cm^2 sec^1 clean
Higgs events per year, enabling the most precise possible measurement of the
mass, width and HiggsYukawa coupling constants.

We show that a muon collider is ideally suited for the study of heavy H/A
scalars, cousins of the Higgs boson found in twoHiggs doublet models and
required in supersymmetric models. The key aspects of H/A are: (1) they are
narrow, yet have a widthtomass ratio far larger than the expected muon
collider beamenergy resolution, and (2) the larger muon Yukawa allows
efficient schannel production. We study in detail a representative Natural
Supersymmetry model which has a 1.5 Tev H/A with $m_H$ $m_A$ = 10 Gev. The
large event rates at resonant peak allow the determination of the individual H
and A resonance parameters (including CP) and the decays into electroweakinos
provides a wealth of information unavailable to any other present or planned
collider.

We propose a "Higgs impostor" model for the 125 GeV boson, $X$, recently
discovered at the LHC. It is a technipion, $\eta_T$, with $I^G J^{PC} = 0^
0^{+}$ expected in this mass region in lowscale technicolor. Its coupling to
pairs of standardmodel gauge bosons are dimensionfive operators whose
strengths are determined within the model. It is easy for the gluon fusion rate
$\sigma B(gg \to \eta_T \to \gamma\gamma)$ to agree with the measured one, but
$\eta_T \to ZZ^*,\,WW^*$ are greatly suppressed relative to the standardmodel
Higgs rates. This is a crucial test of our proposal. In this regard, we assess
the most recent data on $X$ decay modes, with a critical discussion of $X \to
ZZ^* \to 4\ell$. In our model the $\eta_T$ mixes almost completely with the
isovector $\pi^0_T$, giving two similar states, $\eta_L$ at 125 Gev and
$\eta_H$ higher, possibly in the range 170190 Gev. Important consequences of
this mixing are (1) the only associated production of et al is via $\to \to W
\eta_L$, and this could be sizable; (2) $\eta_H$ may soon be accessible in $gg
\to \eta_H \to \gamma\gamma$; and (3) LSTC phenomenology at the LHC is
substantially modified.

Under the assumption that the dijet excess seen by the CDF Collaboration near
150 Gev in Wjj production is due to the lightest technipion of the lowscale
technicolor process $\rho_T \rightarrow W \pi_T$, we study its observability in
LHC detectors for 8 TeV collisions and 20 inverse femtobarns of integrated
luminosity. We describe interesting new kinematic tests that can provide
independent confirmation of this LSTC hypothesis. We show that cuts similar to
those employed by CDF, and recently by ATLAS, cannot confirm the dijet signal.
We propose cuts tailored to the LSTC hypothesis and its backgrounds at the LHC
that may reveal $\rho_T \rightarrow \ell\nu jj$. Observation of the
isospinrelated channel $\rho^{\pm}_T \rightarrow Z \pi^{\pm}_T \rightarrow
\ell^+\ell^ jj$ and of $\rho^{\pm}_T \rightarrow WZ$ in the
$\ell^+\ell^\ell^{pm}\nu_\ell$ and $\ell^+\ell^ jj$ modes will be important
confirmations of the LSTC interpretation of the CDF signal. The $Z\pi_T$
channel is experimentally cleaner than $W\pi_T$ and its rate is known from
$W\pi_T$ by phase space. It can be discovered or excluded with the collider
data expected by the end of 2012. The $WZ \rightarrow 3\ell\nu$ channel is
cleanest of all and its rate is determined from $W\pi_T$ and the LSTC parameter
$\sin\chi$. This channel and $WZ \to \ell^+\ell^ jj$ are discussed as a
function of $\sin\chi$.

Under the assumption that the dijet excess seen by the CDF Collaboration near
150 Gev in Wjj production is due to the lightest technipion of the lowscale
technicolor process $\rho_T \rightarrow W \pi_T$, we study its observability in
LHC detectors with 120 inverse femtobarns of data. We describe interesting
new kinematic tests that can provide independent confirmation of this LSTC
hypothesis. We find that cuts similar to those employed by CDF, and recently by
ATLAS, cannot confirm the dijet signal. We propose cuts tailored to the LSTC
hypothesis and its backgrounds at the LHC that may reveal $\rho_T \rightarrow
\ell\nu jj$. Observation of the isospinrelated channel $\rho^{pm}_T
\rightarrow Z \pi^{pm}_T \rightarrow \ell^+ \ell^ jj$ and of $\rho^{pm}_T
\rightarrow WZ$ in the three lepton plus neutrino and dilepton plus dijet modes
will be important confirmations of the LSTC interpretation of the CDF signal.
The $Z\pi_T$ channel is experimentally cleaner than $W\pi_T$ and its rate is
known from $W\pi_T$ by phase space. It can be discovered or excluded with the
collider data expected in 2012. The $WZ \rightarrow 3\ell\nu$ channel is
cleanest of all and its rate is determined from $W\pi_T$ and the LSTC parameter
$\sin\chi$. This channel and $WZ \rightarrow \ell^+\ell^ jj$ are discussed as
a function of $\sin\chi$.

Under the assumption that the dijet excess seen by the CDF Collaboration near
150 Gev in Wjj production is due to the lightest technipion of the lowscale
technicolor process $\rho_T \rightarrow W \pi_T$, we study its observability in
LHC detectors with 15 fb^{1} of data. We find that cuts similar to those
employed by CDF are unlikely to confirm its signal. We propose cuts tailored to
the LSTC hypothesis and its backgrounds at the LHC that can reveal $\pi_T
\rightarrow jj$. We also stress the importance at the LHC of the
isospinrelated channel $\rho^{\pm}_T \rightarrow Z\pi^{\pm}_T \rightarrow
\ell\ell jj$ and the alllepton mode $\rho^{pm}_T \rightarrow WZ \rightarrow
3\ell + \nu$.

The Tevatron experiments CDF and DO are close to making definitive statements
about the technicolor discovery mode rho_T > W pi_T for M(rho_T) <~ 230 GeV
and M(pi_T) <~ 125 GeV. We propose new incisive tests for this mode and
searches for others that may be feasible at the Tevatron and certainly are at
the LHC. The other searches include two long discussed, namely, omega_T >
gamma pi_T and l+l, and a new one  for the I^G J^{PC} = 1^ 1^{++} partner,
a_T, of the rho_T. Adopting the argument that the technicolor contribution to S
is reduced if M(a_T) is near M(rho_T), we enumerate important a_T decays and
estimate production rates at the colliders.

Valuable data on quarkonia (the bound states of a heavy quark Q=c,b and the
corresponding antiquark) have recently been provided by a variety of sources,
mainly e+ e collisions, but also hadronic interactions. This permits a
thorough updating of the experimental and theoretical status of electromagnetic
and strong transitions in quarkonia. We discuss QQbar transitions to other
QQbar states, with some reference to processes involving QQbar annihilation.

A detailed study of orbital and radial excited states in D, Ds, B and B_s
systems is performed. The chiral quark model provides the framework for the
calculation of pseudoscalar meson (pi, K, ...) hadronic transitions among
heavylight excited and ground states. To calculate the excited states masses
and wavefunctions, we must resort to a relativistic quark model. Our model
includes the leading order corrections in 1/m_(c,b) (e.g. mixing). Numerical
results for masses and light hadronic transition rates are compared to existing
experimental data. The effective coupling of the chiral quark model can be
determined by comparing with independent results from lattice simulations
(g^8_A = 0.53 +/ 0.11) or fitting to known widths (g^8_A = 0.82 +/ 0.09).

We studied the hadronic decays of excited states of heavy mesons (D, D_s, B
and B_s) to lighter states by emission of pi, eta or K. Wavefunctions and
energy levels of these excited states are determined using a Dirac equation for
the light quark in the potential generated by the heavy quark (including first
order corrections in the heavy quark expansion). Transition amplitudes are
computed in the context of the Heavy Chiral Quark Model.

We have carried out numerical studies of vacuum alignment in technicolor
models of electroweak and flavor symmetry breaking. The goal is to understand
alignment's implications for strong and weak CP nonconservation in quark
interactions. In this first part, we restrict our attention to the
technifermion sector of simple models. We find several interesting phenomena,
including (1) the possibility that all observable phases in the technifermions'
unitary vacuumalignment matrix are integer multiples of \pi/N' where N' \le N,
the number of technifermion doublets, and (2) the possibility of exceptionally
light pseudoGoldstone technipions.

New strong dynamics at the energy scale ~ 1 TeV is an attractive and elegant
theoretical ansatz for the origin of electroweak symmetry breaking. We review
here the theoretical models for strong dynamics, particularly, technicolor
theories and their low energy signatures. We emphasize that the fantastic beam
energy resolution (sigma_E/E ~10^{4}) expected at the first muon collider
(sqrt{s} = 100500 GeV) allows the possibility of resolving some
extraordinarily narrow technihadron resonances and, Higgslike techniscalars
produced in the schannel. Investigating indirect probes for strong dynamics
such as search for muon compositeness, we find that the muon colliders provide
unparallel reaches. A big muon collider (sqrt{s} =34 TeV) would be a
remarkable facility to study heavy technicolor particles such as the topcolor
Z', to probe the dynamics underlying fermion masses and mixings and to fully
explore the strongly interacting electroweak sector.

In modern technicolor models, there exist very narrow spinzero and spinone
neutral technihadrons$pi^0_T$, $rho^0_T$ and $omega_T$with masses of a
few 100 GeV. The large coupling of $\pi^0_T$ to $\mu^+\mu^$, the direct
coupling of $rho^0_T$ and $omega_T$ to the photon and $Z^0$, and the superb
energy resolution of the First Muon Collider may make it possible to resolve
these technihadrons and produce them at extraordinarily large rates.

In multiscale and topcolorassisted models of walking technicolor, relatively
light spinone technihadrons $\rho_T$ and $\omega_T$ exist and are expected to
decay as $\rho_T \to W \pi_T, Z \pi_T$ and $\omega_T \to \gamma \pi_T$. For
$M_{\rho_T} \simeq 200 GeV$ and $M_{\pi_T} \simeq 100 GeV$, these processes
have cross sections in the picobarn range in $\bar p p$ colisions at the
Tevatron and about 10 times larger at the Large Hadron Collider. We demonstrate
their detectability with simulations appropriate to Run II conditions at the
Tevatron.

This is the first of two reports cataloging the principal signatures of
electroweak and flavor dynamics at $\pbarp$ and $pp$ colliders. Here, we
discuss some of the signatures of dynamical elecroweak and flavor symmetry
breaking. The framework for dynamical symmetry breaking we assume is
technicolor, with a walking coupling $\alpha_{TC}$, and extended technicolor.
The reactions discussed occur mainly at subprocess energies $\sqrt{\hat s}
\simle 1 TeV$. They include production of colorsinglet and octet technirhos
and their decay into pairs of technipions, longitudinal weak bosons, or jets.
Technipions, in turn, decay predominantly into heavy fermions. This report will
appear in the Proceedings of the 1996 DPF/DPB Summer Study on New Directions
for High Energy Physics (Snowmass 96).

This is the second of two reports cataloging the principal signatures of
electroweak and flavor dynamics at $\pbarp$ and $pp$ colliders. Here, we
complete our overview of technicolor with a discussion of signatures specific
to topcolorassisted technicolor. We also review signatures of flavor dynamics
associated with quark and lepton substructure. These occur in excess production
rates for dijets and dileptons with high $E_T$ and high invariant mass. An
important feature of these processes is that they exhibit fairly central
angular and rapidity distributions. This report will appear in the Proceedings
of the 1996 DPF/DPB Summer Study on New Directions for High Energy Physics
(Snowmass 96).

In multiscale models of walking technicolor, relatively light colorsinglet
technipions are produced in $q \ol q$ annihilation in association with
longitudinal $W$ and $Z$ bosons and with each other. The technipions decay as
$\tpiz \ra b \ol b$ and $\tpip \ra c \ol b$. Their production rates are
resonantly enhanced by isovector technirho vector mesons with mass $M_W +
M_{\tpi} \simle M_{\tro} \simle 2 M_{\tpi}$. At the Tevatron, these associated
production rates are 110 picobarns for $M_{\tpi} \simeq 100\,\gev$. Such a
low mass technipion requires topcolorassisted technicolor to suppress the
decay $t \ra \tpip b$. Searches for $\tpi\tpi$ production will also be
rewarding. Sizable rates are expected if $M_{\tro} \simge 2M_{\tpi} +
10\,\gev$. The isoscalar $\omega_T$ is nearly degenerate with $\tro$ and is
expected to be produced at roughly the same rate. The $\omega_T$ should have
the distinctive decay modes $\omega_T \ra \gamma \tpiz$ and $Z \tpiz$.