-
Precision cosmology requires accurate galaxy redshifts, but next generation
optical surveys will observe unprecedented numbers of resolved galaxies,
placing strain on the amount of spectroscopic follow-up required. We show how
useful information can be gained on the redshift distributions of optical
galaxy samples from spatial cross-correlations with intensity maps of
unresolved HI (21cm) spectral line emission. We construct a redshift
distribution estimator, which we test using simulations. We utilise the S3-SAX
catalogue which includes HI emission information for each galaxy, which we use
to construct HI intensity maps. We also make use of simulated LSST and
Euclid-like photometry enabling us to apply the HI clustering calibration to
realistic simulated photometric redshifts. While taking into account important
limitations to HI intensity mapping such as lost k-modes from foreground
cleaning and poor angular resolution due to large receiver beams, we show that
excellent constraints on redshift distributions can be provided for an optical
photometric sample.
-
We introduce a new Bayesian HI spectral line fitting technique capable of
obtaining spectroscopic redshifts for millions of galaxies in radio surveys
with the Square Kilometere Array (SKA). This technique is especially
well-suited to the low signal-to-noise regime that the redshifted 21-cm HI
emission line is expected to be observed in, especially with SKA Phase 1,
allowing for robust source detection. After selecting a set of continuum
objects relevant to large, cosmological-scale surveys with the first phase of
the SKA dish array (SKA1-MID), we simulate data corresponding to their HI line
emission as observed by the same telescope. We then use the MultiNest nested
sampling code to find the best-fitting parametrised line profile, providing us
with a full joint posterior probability distribution for the galaxy properties,
including redshift. This provides high quality redshifts, with redshift errors
$\Delta z / z <10^{-5}$, from radio data alone for some 1.8 million galaxies in
a representative 5000 square degree survey with the SKA1-MID instrument with
up-to-date sensitivity profiles. Interestingly, we find that the SNR definition
commonly used in forecast papers does not correlate well with the actual
detectability of an HI line using our method. We further detail how our method
could be improved with per-object priors and how it may be also used to give
robust constraints on other observables such as the HI mass function. We also
make our line fitting code publicly available for application to other data
sets.
-
We consider methods with which to answer the question "is any observed galaxy
cluster too unusual for Lambda-CDM?" After emphasising that many previous
attempts to answer this question will overestimate the confidence level at
which Lambda-CDM can be ruled out, we outline a consistent approach to these
rare clusters, which allows the question to be answered. We define three
statistical measures, each of which are sensitive to changes in cluster
populations arising from different modifications to the cosmological model. We
also use these properties to define the 'equivalent mass at redshift zero' for
a cluster --- the mass of an equally unusual cluster today. This quantity is
independent of the observational survey in which the cluster was found, which
makes it an ideal proxy for ranking the relative unusualness of clusters
detected by different surveys. These methods are then used on a comprehensive
sample of observed galaxy clusters and we confirm that all are less than
2-sigma deviations from the Lambda-CDM expectation. Whereas we have only
applied our method to galaxy clusters, it is applicable to any isolated,
collapsed, halo. As motivation for future surveys, we also calculate where in
the mass redshift plane the rarest halo is most likely to be found, giving
information as to which objects might be the most fruitful in the search for
new physics.
-
We investigate the correlations in galaxy shapes between optical and radio
wavelengths using archival observations of the COSMOS field. Cross-correlation
studies between different wavebands will become increasingly important for
precision cosmology as future large surveys may be dominated by systematic
rather than statistical errors. In the case of weak lensing, galaxy shapes must
be measured to extraordinary accuracy (shear systematics of $< 0.01\%$) in
order to achieve good constraints on dark energy parameters. By using shape
information from overlapping surveys in optical and radio bands, robustness to
systematics may be significantly improved without loss of constraining power.
Here we use HST-ACS optical data, VLA radio data, and extensive simulations to
investigate both our ability to make precision measurements of source shapes
from realistic radio data, and to constrain the intrinsic astrophysical scatter
between the shapes of galaxies as measured in the optical and radio wavebands.
By producing a new image from the VLA-COSMOS L-band radio visibility data that
is well suited to galaxy shape measurements, we are able to extract precise
measurements of galaxy position angles. Comparing to corresponding measurements
from the HST optical image, we set a lower limit on the intrinsic astrophysical
scatter in position angles, between the optical and radio bands, of
$\sigma_\alpha > 0.212\pi$ radians (or $38.2^{\circ}$) at a $95\%$ confidence
level.
-
In this third paper of a series on radio weak lensing for cosmology with the
Square Kilometre Array, we scrutinise synergies between cosmic shear
measurements in the radio and optical/near-IR bands for mitigating systematic
effects. We focus on three main classes of systematics: (i) experimental
systematic errors in the observed shear; (ii) signal contamination by intrinsic
alignments; and (iii) systematic effects due to an incorrect modelling of
non-linear scales. First, we show that a comprehensive, multi-wavelength
analysis provides a self-calibration method for experimental systematic
effects, only implying <50% increment on the errors on cosmological parameters.
We also illustrate how the cross-correlation between radio and optical/near-IR
surveys alone is able to remove residual systematics with variance as large as
0.00001, i.e. the same order of magnitude of the cosmological signal. This also
opens the possibility of using such a cross-correlation as a means to detect
unknown experimental systematics. Secondly, we demonstrate that, thanks to
polarisation information, radio weak lensing surveys will be able to mitigate
contamination by intrinsic alignments, in a way similar but fully complementary
to available self-calibration methods based on position-shear correlations.
Lastly, we illustrate how radio weak lensing experiments, reaching higher
redshifts than those accessible to optical surveys, will probe dark energy and
the growth of cosmic structures in regimes less contaminated by non-linearities
in the matter perturbations. For instance, the higher-redshift bins of radio
catalogues peak at z~0.8-1, whereas their optical/near-IR counterparts are
limited to z<0.5-0.7. This translates into having a cosmological signal 2 to 5
times less contaminated by non-linear perturbations.
-
We construct forecasts for cosmological parameter constraints from weak
gravitational lensing surveys involving the Square Kilometre Array (SKA).
Considering matter content, dark energy and modified gravity parameters, we
show that the first phase of the SKA (SKA1) can be competitive with other Stage
III experiments such as the Dark Energy Survey (DES) and that the full SKA
(SKA2) can potentially form tighter constraints than Stage IV optical weak
lensing experiments, such as those that will be conducted with LSST,
WFIRST-AFTA or Euclid-like facilities. Using weak lensing alone, going from
SKA1 to SKA2 represents improvements by factors of $\sim10$ in matter, $\sim10$
in dark energy and $\sim5$ in modified gravity parameters. We also show, for
the first time, the powerful result that comparably tight constraints (within
$\sim5\%$) for both Stage III and Stage IV experiments, can be gained from
cross-correlating shear maps between the optical and radio wavebands, a process
which can also eliminate a number of potential sources of systematic errors
which can otherwise limit the utility of weak lensing cosmology.
-
We construct a pipeline for simulating weak lensing cosmology surveys with
the Square Kilometre Array (SKA), taking as inputs telescope sensitivity
curves; correlated source flux, size and redshift distributions; a simple
ionospheric model; source redshift and ellipticity measurement errors. We then
use this simulation pipeline to optimise a 2-year weak lensing survey performed
with the first deployment of the SKA (SKA1). Our assessments are based on the
total signal-to-noise of the recovered shear power spectra, a metric that we
find to correlate very well with a standard dark energy figure of merit. We
first consider the choice of frequency band, trading off increases in number
counts at lower frequencies against poorer resolution; our analysis strongly
prefers the higher frequency Band 2 (950-1760 MHz) channel of the SKA-MID
telescope to the lower frequency Band 1 (350-1050 MHz). Best results would be
obtained by allowing the centre of Band 2 to shift towards lower frequency,
around 1.1 GHz. We then move on to consider survey size, finding that an area
of 5,000 square degrees is optimal for most SKA1 instrumental configurations.
Finally, we forecast the performance of a weak lensing survey with the second
deployment of the SKA. The increased survey size (3$\pi$\,steradian) and
sensitivity improves both the signal-to-noise and the dark energy metrics by
two orders of magnitude.
-
This document was submitted as supporting material to an Engineering Change
Proposal (ECP) for the Square Kilometre Array (SKA). This ECP requests gridded
visibilities as an extra imaging data product from the SKA, in order to enable
bespoke analysis techniques to measure source morphologies to the accuracy
necessary for precision cosmology with radio weak lensing. We also discuss the
properties of an SKA weak lensing data set and potential overlaps with other
cosmology science goals.
-
Weak gravitational lensing measurements are traditionally made at optical
wavelengths where many highly resolved galaxy images are readily available.
However, the Square Kilometre Array (SKA) holds great promise for this type of
measurement at radio wavelengths owing to its greatly increased sensitivity and
resolution over typical radio surveys. The key to successful weak lensing
experiments is in measuring the shapes of detected sources to high accuracy. In
this document we describe a simulation pipeline designed to simulate radio
images of the quality required for weak lensing, and will be typical of SKA
observations. We provide as input, images with realistic galaxy shapes which
are then simulated to produce images as they would have been observed with a
given radio interferometer. We exploit this pipeline to investigate various
stages of a weak lensing experiment in order to better understand the effects
that may impact shape measurement. We first show how the proposed SKA1-Mid
array configurations perform when we compare the (known) input and output
ellipticities. We then investigate how making small changes to these array
configurations impact on this input-outut ellipticity comparison. We also
demonstrate how alternative configurations for SKA1-Mid that are smaller in
extent, and with a faster survey speeds produce similar performance to those
originally proposed. We then show how a notional SKA configuration performs in
the same shape measurement challenge. Finally, we describe ongoing efforts to
utilise our simulation pipeline to address questions relating to how applicable
current (mostly originating from optical data) shape measurement techniques are
to future radio surveys. As an alternative to such image plane techniques, we
lastly discuss a shape measurement technique based on the shapelets formalism
that reconstructs the source shapes directly from the visibility data.
-
Motivated by recent suggestions that a number of observed galaxy clusters
have masses which are too high for their given redshift to occur naturally in a
standard model cosmology, we use Extreme Value Statistics to construct
confidence regions in the mass-redshift plane for the most extreme objects
expected in the universe. We show how such a diagram not only provides a way of
potentially ruling out the concordance cosmology, but also allows us to
differentiate between alternative models of enhanced structure formation. We
compare our theoretical prediction with observations, placing currently
observed high and low redshift clusters on a mass-redshift diagram and find --
provided we consider the full sky to avoid a posteriori selection effects --
that none are in significant tension with concordance cosmology.
-
Motivated by observations that suggest the presence of extremely massive
clusters at uncomfortably high redshifts for the standard cosmological model to
explain, we develop a theoretical framework for the study of the most massive
haloes, e.g. the most massive cluster found in a given volume, based on Extreme
Value Statistics (EVS). We proceed from the exact distribution of the extreme
values drawn from a known underlying distribution, rather than relying on
asymptotic theory (which is independent of the underlying form), arguing that
the former is much more likely to furnish robust statistical results. We
illustrate this argument with a discussion of the use of extreme value
statistics as a probe of primordial non-Gaussianity.