We solve the open question of the existence of four-qubit entangled symmetric
states with positive partial transpositions (PPT states). We reach this goal
with two different approaches. First, we propose a
half-analytical-half-numerical method that allows to construct multipartite PPT
entangled symmetric states (PPTESS) from the qubit-qudit PPT entangled states.
Second, we adapt the algorithm allowing to search for extremal elements in the
convex set of bipartite PPT states [J. M. Leinaas, J. Myrheim, and E. Ovrum,
Phys. Rev. A 76, 034304 (2007)] to the multipartite scenario. With its aid we
search for extremal four-qubit PPTESS and show that generically they have ranks
(5,7,8). Finally, we provide an exhaustive characterization of these states
with respect to their separability properties.
From both theoretical and experimental points of view symmetric states
constitute an important class of multipartite states. Still, entanglement
properties of these states, in particular those with positive partial
transposition (PPT), lack a systematic study. Aiming at filling in this gap, we
have recently affirmatively answered the open question of existence of
four-qubit entangled symmetric states with positive partial transposition and
thoroughly characterized entanglement properties of such states [J. Tura et
al., Phys. Rev. A 85, 060302(R) (2012)] With the present contribution we
continue on characterizing PPT entangled symmetric states. On the one hand, we
present all the results of our previous work in a detailed way. On the other
hand, we generalize them to systems consisting of arbitrary number of qubits.
In particular, we provide criteria for separability of such states formulated
in terms of their ranks. Interestingly, for most of the cases, the symmetric
states are either separable or typically separable. Then, edge states in these
systems are studied, showing in particular that to characterize generic PPT
entangled states with four and five qubits, it is enough to study only those
that assume few (respectively, two and three) specific configurations of ranks.
Finally, we numerically search for extremal PPT entangled states in such
systems consisting of up to 23 qubits. One can clearly notice regularity behind
the ranks of such extremal states, and, in particular, for systems composed of
odd number of qubits we find a single configuration of ranks for which there
are extremal states.
Quantum mechanics is already 100 years old, but remains alive and full of
challenging open problems. On one hand, the problems encountered at the
frontiers of modern theoretical physics like Quantum Gravity, String Theories,
etc. concern Quantum Theory, and are at the same time related to open problems
of modern mathematics. But even within non-relativistic quantum mechanics
itself there are fundamental unresolved problems that can be formulated in
elementary terms. These problems are also related to challenging open questions
of modern mathematics; linear algebra and functional analysis in particular.
Two of these problems will be discussed in this article: a) the separability
problem, i.e. the question when the state of a composite quantum system does
not contain any quantum correlations or entanglement and b) the distillability
problem, i.e. the question when the state of a composite quantum system can be
transformed to an entangled pure state using local operations (local refers
here to component subsystems of a given system).
Although many results concerning the above mentioned problems have been
obtained (in particular in the last few years in the framework of Quantum
Information Theory), both problems remain until now essentially open. We will
present a primer on the current state of knowledge concerning these problems,
and discuss the relation of these problems to one of the most challenging
questions of linear algebra: the classification and characterization of
positive operator maps.