Microwave parametric amplifiers based on Josephson junctions have become a key component of many quantum information experiments. One key limitation which has not been well predicted by theory is the gain saturation behavior which determines its ability to process large amplitude signals. The typical explanation for this behavior in phase-preserving amplifiers based on three-wave mixing is pump depletion, in which the consumption of pump photons to produce amplification results in a reduction in gain. However, in this work we present experimental data and theoretical calculations showing that the fourth-order Kerr nonlinearities inherent in the Josephson junctions are the dominant factor in the Josephson Parametric Converter (JPC). The Kerr-based theory has the unusual property of causing saturation to both lower and higher gains, depending on bias conditions. This work presents a new methodology for optimizing device performance in the presence of Kerr nonlinearities while retaining device tunability, and points to the necessity of controlling higher-order Hamiltonian terms to make further improvements in parametric devices.