
Recent AC susceptibility and polar Kerr effect measurements in the
skutterudite superconductor PrOs4Sb12 (POS) uncovered the nature of the
superconducting double transition from a high temperature, high field, time
reversal symmetric phase (or the A phase) to a low temperature, low field, time
reversal symmetry broken phase (or the B phase). Starting from a microscopic
model, we derive a GinzburgLandau expansion relevant to POS that describes
this entrance into the time reversal symmetry broken phase along the
temperature axis. We also provide a study of the low energy inelastic (Raman)
response in both the A and B phases of POS, and seek additional signatures
which could help reveal the exact form of the gap functions previously proposed
in these phases. By appropriately manipulating the incoming and scattered light
geometries, along with additional subtraction procedures and suitable
assumptions, we show that one can access the various irreducible
representations contained in the point group describing POS. We demonstrate how
to use this technique on example order parameters proposed in POS. Depending on
whether there exist nodes along the caxis, we find additional low energy
spectral weight within the superconducting gap in the Eg geometry, a feature
that could pin point the location of nodes on the Fermi surface.

We investigate the validity of Luttinger's theorem (or Luttinger sum rule) in
two scaleinvariant fermionic models. We find that, in general, Luttinger's
theorem does not hold in a system of fermions with powerlaw Green functions
which do not necessarily preserve particlehole symmetry. However, Ref.
\cite{Blagoev1997,Yamanaka1997} showed that Luttinger liquids, another
scaleinvariant fermionic model, respect Luttinger's theorem. To understand the
difference, we examine the spinless Luttinger liquid model. We find two
properties which make the Luttinger sum rule valid in this model: particlehole
symmetry and $\mathrm{Im} G(\omega=0,\infty)=0$. We conjecture that these two
properties represent sufficient, but not necessary, conditions for the validity
of the Luttinger sum rule in condensed matter systems.

We study an anisotropic holographic bottomup model displaying a quantum
phase transition (QPT) between a topologically trivial insulator and a
nontrivial Weyl semimetal phase. We analyze the properties of quantum chaos in
the quantum critical region. We find a violation of the recently conjectured
bound for the butterfly velocity across a QPT. In particular, the butterfly
velocity along the anisotropic direction does not display a maximum at the
quantum critical point. We observe that instead of the butterfly velocity, it
is the dimensionless information screening length that is always maximized at a
quantum critical point. We argue that the nullenergy condition (NEC) is the
underlying reason for the upper bound, which now is just a simple combination
of the number of spatial dimensions and the anisotropic scaling parameter.

We propose a theoretical framework for the detection of order parameter
fluctuations in three dimensions using ultrafast coherent phonon spectroscopy.
We focus our attention on long wavelength charge density fluctuations
(plasmons), and charged nematic fluctuations where the direction of the
propagation vector is fixed perpendicular to the plane of anisotropy. By
treating phonons and light classically and decoupling interactions to integrate
out the fermionic degrees of freedom, we arrive at an effective theory of order
parameter fluctuations about the spatially uniform saddlepoint solution. We
find that, due to the $(k_x^2k_y^2) (B_{1g})$ symmetry of the form factor
appearing in the vertex, nematic fluctuations couple to light only at fourth
order, unlike isotropic density fluctuations which couple at second order.
Hence, to lowest order, the interaction between electrons and the
electromagnetic field contributes a driving force for plasmon oscillations
while it provides a frequency shift for nematic fluctuations. From the
resulting coupled harmonic oscillator equations of motion, we argue that
ultrafast coherent phonon spectroscopy could be a useful tool to extract and
analyze various electronic properties of interest such as the frequency of the
collective mode and the coupling between electrons and phonons. Specific
experiments are proposed on the normal state of FeSe to observe the frequency
shift predicted here resulting directly from orbital ordering (nematic)
fluctuations.

Recent photoemission spectroscopy measurements (T. J. Reber et al.,
arXiv:1509.01611) of cuprate superconductors have inferred that the selfenergy
exhibits critical scaling over an extended doping regime, thereby calling into
question the conventional wisdom that critical scaling exists only at isolated
points. In paticular, this new state of matter, dubbed a powerlaw liquid, has
a selfenergy whose imaginary part scales as
$\Sigma^{\prime\prime}\sim(\omega^{2}+\pi^{2}T^{2})^{\alpha}$, with $\alpha=1$
in the overdoped Fermiliquid state and $\alpha\leq0.5$ in the optimal to
underdoped regime. Taking this as a given, we first reconstruct the real part
of the selfenergy. We find that the resultant quasiparticle weight vanishes
for any doping level less than optimal, implying an absence of particlelike
excitations in the underdoped regime. Consequently, the Fermi velocity vanishes
and the effective mass diverges for $\alpha\leq\frac{1}{2}$, in agreement with
earlier experimental observations. We then use the selfenergy to reconstruct
the spectral function and compute the superconducting $T_c$ within the BCS
formalism. We find that the $T_c$ has a domelike structure, implying that
broad scale invariance manifested in the form of a powerlaw liquid is the
likely cause of the superconducting dome in the cuprates.

Twisted bilayer graphene (TBG) exhibits dispersionless bands at a particular
set of twist values called magic angles. This dispersionless behavior can be
understood from an effective description of the bilayer system in terms of a
triangular superlattice formed by the so called Moir\'e patterns. The kinetic
energy of the quasifree electrons in this superlattice is heavily quenched,
causing the interactions to dominate, and thus rendering TBG a playground of
strong correlation physics. Although it has been argued [15] that the novel
insulating state arising from such twist angles is of the Motttype, we show
here that the the insulating state in the vicinity of the magic angles is
actually a Wigner crystal. The Mott state obtains at a density four orders of
magnitude larger that in the experimental systems, thereby rendering it
irrelevant to the physics of TBG near the magic angles. Superconductivity then
arises from melting (doping) a Wigner crystal which has been argued previously
[6] to exhibit superconducting correlations. Defectmediated melting in a
Wigner crystal should exhibit strong BerezinskiiKosterlitzThouless behaviour
and hence should serve as a guide to the experiments.

We address the question of the mismatch between the zero momentum limits of
the transverse and longitudinal dielectric functions for a fixed direction of
the driving field observed in the cuprates. This question translates to whether
or not the order in which the longitudinal and transverse momentum transfers
are taken to zero commute. While the two limits commute for both isotropic and
anisotropic Drude metals, we argue that a scaleless vertex interaction that
depends solely on the angle between scattered electron momenta is sufficient to
achieve noncommutativity of the two limits even for a system that is
inherently isotropic. We demonstrate this claim for a simple case of the Drude
conductivity modified by electronboson interactions through appropriate vertex
corrections, and outline possible consequences of our result to optical and
electron energy loss spectroscopy (EELS) measurements close to zero momentum
transfer

We study fermions in an electricallyprobed and asymptotically antide Sitter
Schwarzschild spacetime which interact via novel chiral symmetrypreserving
interactions. Computing the dual fermion twopoint correlator, we show that
these bulk interactions anisotropically gap Fermi surfaces of the boundary
spectrum. Consequently, the interactions we devise provide holographic models
for Fermi arcs seen ubiquitously in the pseudogap regime of the cuprates. Our
interactions are modifications of the chiral symmetrybreaking Pauli coupling,
which has previously been proposed as the holographic realization of Mott
physics. The onset of Mott insulation and pseudogap physics are respectively
discussed in the context of bulk chiral and boundary parity symmetry breaking,
and the Mott transition is interpreted as a deconfinement transition of
nonFermi liquid excitations.

We study a singlechannel Kondo effect using a recently developed holographic
large$N$ technique. In order to obtain resistivity of this model, we introduce
a probe field. The gravity dual of a localized fermionic impurity in
1+1dimensional host matter is constructed by embedding a localized
2dimensional Antide Sitter (\ads{2})brane in the bulk of \ads{3}. This helps
us construct an impurity charge density which acts as a source to the bulk
equation of motion of the probe gauge field. The functional form of the charge
density is obtained independently by solving the equations of motion for the
fields confined to the \ads{2}brane. The asymptotic solution of the probe
field is dictated by the impurity charge density, which in turn, affects the
currentcurrent correlation functions, and hence the resistivity. Our choice of
parameters tunes the nearboundary impurity current to be marginal, resulting
in a $\log T$ behavior in the UV resistivity, as is expected for the Kondo
problem. The resistivity at the IR fixed point turns out to be zero, signaling
a complete screening of the impurity.

Destruction of superconductivity in thin films was thought to be a simple
instance of BerezinskiiKosterlitzThouless physics in which only two phases
exist: a superconductor with algebraic long range order in which the vortices
condense and an insulator where the vortexantivortex pairs proliferate.
However, since 1989 this view has been challenged as now a preponderance of
experiments indicate that an intervening bosonic metallic state obtains upon
the destruction of superconductivity. We review here a glassy model which is
capable of capturing both of these features. The finite resistance arises from
three features. First, the disordered insulatorsuperconductor transition in
the absence of fermionic degrees of freedom (Cooper pairs only), is controlled
by a diffusive fixed point\cite{CN} rather than the critical point of the clean
system. Hence, the relevant physics that generates the Bose metal should arise
from a term in the action in which different replicas are mixed. We show
explicitly how such physics arises in the phase glass. Second, in 2D (not in
3D) the phase stiffness of the glass phase vanishes explicitly as has been
shown in extensive numerical simulations\cite{ky,kosterlitz1,kosterlitz2}.
Third, bosons moving in such a glassy environment fail to localize as a result
of the false minima in the landscape. We calculate the conductivity explicitly
using Kubo response and show that it turns on as a power law and has a
vanishing Hall response as a result of underlying particlehole symmetry. We
show that when particlehole symmetry is broken, the Hall conductance turns on
with the same power law as does the longitudinal conductance.

We demonstrate quite generally how a conserved current can have an anomalous
dimension. We show here that if the current in the normal state of the cuprates
has an anomalous dimension, then the AharonovBohm flux through a ring does not
have the standard $eBA/\hbar$ form, where $A$ is the area and $B$ the external
magnetic field, but instead is modified by a geometrical factor that depends
directly on the anomalous dimension of the current. We calculate the signal in
square and disk geometries. In both cases, the deviation from the standard
result is striking and offers a fingerprint about what precisely is strange
about the strange metal.

Motivated in part by the numerical simulations [ky,kosterlitz1,kosterlitz2]
which reveal that the energy to create a defect in a gauge or phase glass
scales as $L^{\theta}$ with $\theta<0$ for 2D, thereby implying a vanishing
stiffness, we reexamine the relevance of these kinds of models to the Bose
metal in light of the new experiments [kapsym,armitage] which reveal that the
Hall conductance is zero in the metallic state that disrupts the transition
from the superconductor to the insulator in 2D samples. Because of the
particlehole symmetry in the phase glass model, we find that bosonic
excitations in a phase glass background generate no Hall conductance at the
Gaussian level. Furthermore, this result persists to any order in perturbation
theory in the interactions. We show that when particlehole symmetry is broken,
the Hall conductance turns on with the same power law as does the longitudinal
conductance. This prediction can be verified experimentally by applying a
ground plane to the 2D samples.

Recent photoemission spectroscopy measurements [arXiv:1509.01611] on cuprate
superconductors have inferred that over a wide range of doping, the imaginary
part of the electron selfenergy scales as
$\Sigma^{\prime\prime}\sim(\omega^2+\pi^2T^2)^a$ with $a=1$ in the overdoped
Fermiliquid state and $a<0.5$ in the optimal to underdoped regime. We show
that this nonFermiliquid scaling behavior can naturally be explained by the
presence of a scaleinvariant state of matter known as unparticles. We evaluate
analytically the electron selfenergy due to interactions with fermionic
unparticles. We find that, in agreement with experiments, the imaginary part of
the selfenergy scales with respect to temperature and energy as
$\Sigma^{\prime\prime}\sim T^{2+2\alpha}$ and $\omega^{2+2\alpha}$, where
$\alpha$ is the anomalous dimension of the unparticle propagator. In addition,
the calculated occupancy and susceptibility of fermionic unparticles, unlike
those of normal fermions, have significant spectral weights even at high
energies. This unconventional behavior is attributed to the branch cut in the
unparticle propagator which broadens the unparticle spectral function over a
wide energy range and nontrivially alters the scattering phase space by
enhancing (suppressing) the intrinsic susceptibility at low energies for
negative (positive) $\alpha$. Our work presents new evidence suggesting that
unparticles might be important lowenergy degrees of freedom in strongly
coupled systems such as the cuprate superconductors.

We study impurity scattering in the normal and dwave superconducting states
of line nodal semimetals and show that, due to additional scattering phase
space available for impurities on the surface, the quasiparticle interference
pattern acquires an extended character instead of a discrete collection of
delta function peaks. Moreover, using the Tmatrix formalism, we demonstrate
that the conventional behavior of a scalar impurity in a dwave superconductor
breaks down on the surface of a line nodal semimetal in the quasi flat band
limit.

We show explicitly that the full structure of IIB string theory is needed to
remove the nonlocalities that arise in boundary conformal theories that border
hyperbolic spaces on AdS$_5$. Specifically, using the
Caffarelli/Silvestri\cite{caffarelli}, Graham/Zworski\cite{graham}, and
Chang/Gonzalez\cite{chang:2010} extension theorems, we prove that the boundary
operator conjugate to bulk pforms with negative mass in geodesically complete
metrics is inherently a nonlocal operator, specifically the fractional
conformal Laplacian. The nonlocality, which arises even in compact spaces,
applies to any degree pform such as a gauge field. We show that the boundary
theory contains fractional derivatives of the longitudinal components of the
gauge field if the gauge field in the bulk along the holographic direction
acquires a mass via the Higgs mechanism. The nonlocality is shown to vanish
once the metric becomes incomplete, for example, either 1) asymptotically by
adding N transversely stacked Ddbranes or 2) exactly by giving the boundary a
brane structure and including a single transverse Ddbrane in the bulk. The
original Maldacena conjecture within IIB string theory corresponds to the
former. In either of these proposals, the location of the Ddbranes places an
upper bound on the entanglement entropy because the minimal bulk surface in the
AdS reduction is illdefined at a brane interface. Since the brane
singularities can be circumvented in the full 10dimensional spacetime, we
conjecture that the true entanglement entropy must be computed from the minimal
surface in 10dimensions, which is of course not minimal in the AdS$_5$
reduction.

Motivated by the normal state of the cuprates in which the fsum rule
increases faster than a linear function of the particle density, we derive a
conductivity sum rule for a system in which the kinetic energy operator in the
Hamiltonian is a general function of the momentum squared. Such a kinetic
energy arises in scale invariant theories and can be derived within the context
of holography. Our derivation of the fsum rule is based on the gauge couplings
of a nonlocal Lagrangian in which the kinetic operator is a fractional
Laplacian of order $\alpha$. We find that the fsum rule in this case deviates
from the standard linear dependence on the particle density. We find two
regimes. At high temperatures and low densities, the sum rule is proportional
to $nT^{\frac{\alpha1}{\alpha}}$ where $T$ is the temperature. At low
temperatures and high densities, the sum rule is proportional to
$n^{1+\frac{2(\alpha1)}{d}}$ with $d$ being the number of spatial dimensions.
The result in the low temperature and high density limit, when $\alpha < 1$,
can be used to qualitatively explain the behavior of the effective number of
charge carriers in the cuprates at various doping concentrations.

Recent neutron scattering observations by Plumb et al. [1] reveal that the
ground state of $FeSc_2S_4$ is magnetic with two distinct Fe environments,
instead of a quantum spin liquid as had been previously thought. Starting with
the relevant O(N)symmetric vector model of $FeSc_2S_4$, we study how the
discrete ($Z_2$) and continuous rotational symmetries are successively broken,
yielding nematic and ordered phases. At high temperatures, we find that the
nematic order parameter falls as $T^{\gamma}$ ($\gamma>0$), and therefore,
$FeSc_2S_4$ lacks any distinct nematic ordering temperature. This feature
indicates that the threedimensional diamond lattice of $FeSc_2S_4$ is highly
susceptible to the breaking of Ising symmetries, and explains the two distinct
Fe environments that is present even at high temperatures, as seen by
M\"ossbauer and far infrared optical spectroscopy.

Recent photoemission experiments \cite{dessau} reveal that the excitations
along the nodal region in the strange metal of the cuprates, rather than
corresponding to poles in the singleparticle Green function, exhibit powerlaw
scaling as a function of frequency and temperature. Because such powerlaw
scaling is indicative of a scaleinvariant sector, as a first step, we
perturbatively evaluate the electron selfenergy due to interactions with
scaleinvariant unparticles. We focus on a $G_0W$ type diagram with an
interaction $W$ mediated by a bosonic scalar unparticle. We find that, in the
hightemperature limit, the imaginary part of the selfenergy
$\mathrm{Im}\Sigma$ is linear in temperature. In the lowtemperature limit,
$\mathrm{Im}\Sigma$ exhibits the same power law in both temperature and
frequency, with an exponent that depends on the scaling dimension of an
unparticle operator. Such behavior is qualitatively consistent with the
experimental observations. We then expand the unparticle propagator into
coherent and incoherent contributions, and study how the incoherent part
violates the density of states (DOS) and densitydensity correlation function
sum rules (fsum rule). Such violations can, in principle, be observed
experimentally. Our work indicates that the physical mechanism for the origin
of the powerlaw scaling is the incoherent background, which is generated from
the Mottscale physics.

I analyze the recent observation of a Bose metal in NbSe$_2$ and place these
results in the wider context of the first sighting of such a phase in amorphous
Bi and MoGe thin films.

Partial nesting between two connected or disconnected regions of the Fermi
surface leads to fractional powers of the Coulomb scattering lifetime as a
function of temperature and frequency. This result is first demonstrated for a
toy band structure where partial nesting occurs within a single band and
between different regions of the Brillouin zone. A comparison is then made to a
multiband scenario by studying the scattering rate of an effective two orbital
model that was proposed in the context of multiorbital superconductors. In the
process, various model independent factors affecting the temperature exponent,
n, are identified. The logarithmically divergent contributions of the lowest
order vertex correction to the multiorbital susceptibility, and the role
played by nesting in suppressing these divergences is analyzed. The relevance
of these results is discussed keeping the recently observed anomalous
resistivity in the Co doped Iron superconductor LiFeAs as a backdrop.

Motivated by the overwhelming evidence some type of quantum criticality
underlies the powerlaw for the optical conductivity and $T$linear resistivity
in the cuprates, we demonstrate here how a scaleinvariant or unparticle sector
can lead to a unifying description of the observed scaling forms. We adopt the
continuous mass formalism or multi band (flavor) formalism of the unparticle
sector by letting various microscopic parameters be massdependent. In
particular, we show that an effective mass that varies with the flavor index as
well as a running band edge and lifetime capture the AC and DC transport
phenomenology of the cuprates. A key consequence of the running mass is that
the effective dynamical exponent can differ from the underlying bare critical
exponent, thereby providing a mechanism for realizing the fractional values of
the dynamical exponent required in a previous analysis\cite{ Hartnoll:2015sea}.
We also predict that regardless of the bare dynamical exponent, $z$, a nonzero
anomalous dimension for the current is required. Physically, the anomalous
dimension arises because the charge depends on the flavor, mass or energy. The
equivalent phenomenon in a $d+1$ gravitational construction is the running of
the charge along the radial direction. The nature of the superconducting
instability in the presence of scale invariant stuff shows that the transition
temperature is not necessarily a monotonic function of the pairing interaction.

We show explicitly how a strongly coupled fixed point can be constructed in
scalar $g\varphi^4$ theory from the solutions to a nonlinear eigenvalue
problem. The fixed point exists only for $d< 4$, is unstable and characterized
by $\nu=2/d$ (correlation length exponent), $\eta=1/2d/8$ (anomalous
dimension). For $d=2$, these exponents reproduce to those of the Ising model
which can be understood from the codimension of the critical point. At this
fixed point, $\varphi^{2i}$ terms with $i>2$ are all irrelevant. The testable
prediction of this fixed point is that the specific heat exponent vanishes. 2d
critical Mott systems are well described by this new fixed point.

We compute conductivities of stronglyinteracting and nonuniform charge
densities dual to inhomogeneous antide Sitterblack hole spacetimes.
Backreacting bulk scalars with periodic boundary profiles, we construct
generalizations of ReissnerNordstr\"omAdS that interpolate between those used
in two previous studies  one that reports powerlaw scaling for the boundary
optical conductivity and one that does not. We find no evidence for powerlaw
scaling of the conductivity, thereby corroborating the previous negative result
that gravitational crystals are insufficient to generate the powerlaw
midinfrared conductivity observed in cuprate superconductors.

I am concerned in these lectures with the breakdown of the particle concept
in strongly correlated electron matter. I first show that the standard
procedure for counting particles, namely Luttinger's theorem, breaks down
anytime polelike excitations are replaced by ones that have a divergent
selfenergy. Such a breakdown obtains in electronic systems whose polelike
excitations do not extend to the edge of the Brillouin zone, as in Fermi arcs
in the cuprates. Since any nontrivial infrared dynamics in strongly correlated
electron matter must be controlled by a critical fixed point, unparticles are
the natural candidate to explain the presence of charged degrees of freedom
that have no particle content. The continuous mass formulation of unparticles
is recast as an action in anti de Sitter space. Such an action serves as the
generating functional for the propagator. This mapping fixes the scaling
dimension of the unparticle to be $d_U=d/2+\sqrt{d^2+4}/2$ and ensures that the
corresponding propagator has zeros with $d$ the spacetime dimension of the
unparticle field. The general {\it dynamical} mechanism by which bulk
operators, such as the Pauli term, couple to the scaling dimension of the
boundary operator and thereby lead to a vanishing of the spectral weight at
zero energy is reviewed in the context of unparticles and zeros. The analogue
of the BCS gap equations with unparticles indicates that the transition
temperature increases as the attractive interaction strength decreases,
indicating that unparticles are highly susceptible to a superconducting
instability.

We develop a microscopic theory for the pointcontact conductance between a
metalic electrode and a strongly correlated material using the nonequilibrium
SchwingerKadanoffBaymKeldysh formalism. We explicitly show that in the
classical limit, contact size shorter than the scattering length of the system,
the microscopic model can be reduced to an effective model with transfer matrix
elements that conserve inplane momentum. We find that the conductance $dI/dV$
is proportional to the {\it effective density of states}, that is, the
integrated singleparticle spectral function $A(\omega=eV)$ over the whole
Brillouin zone. From this conclusion, we are able to establish the conditions
under which a nonFermi liquid metal exhibits a zerobias peak in the
conductance. This finding is discussed in the context of recent pointcontact
spectroscopy on the iron pnictides and chalcogenides which has exhibited a
zerobias conductance peak.