
The last few years have been witness to a proliferation of new results
concerning heavy exotic hadrons. Experimentally, many new signals have been
discovered that could be pointing towards the existence of tetraquarks,
pentaquarks, and other exotic configurations of quarks and gluons.
Theoretically, advances in lattice field theory techniques place us at the cusp
of understanding complex coupledchannel phenomena, modelling grows more
sophisticated, and effective field theories are being applied to an ever
greater range of situations. It is thus an opportune time to evaluate the
status of the field. In the following, a series of high priority experimental
and theoretical issues concerning heavy exotic hadrons is presented.

We highlight the progress, current status, and open challenges of QCDdriven
physics, in theory and in experiment. We discuss how the strong interaction is
intimately connected to a broad sweep of physical problems, in settings ranging
from astrophysics and cosmology to stronglycoupled, complex systems in
particle and condensedmatter physics, as well as to searches for physics
beyond the Standard Model. We also discuss how success in describing the strong
interaction impacts other fields, and, in turn, how such subjects can impact
studies of the strong interaction. In the course of the work we offer a
perspective on the many research streams which flow into and out of QCD, as
well as a vision for future developments.

We describe a new exact relation for large $N_c$ QCD for the longdistance
behavior of baryon form factors in the chiral limit, satisfied by all 4D
semiclassical chiral soliton models. We use this relation to test the
consistency of the structure of two different holographic models of baryons.

An analysis of the baryonbaryon potential from the point of view of
largeN(c) QCD is performed. A comparison is made between the N(c)scaling
behavior directly obtained from an analysis at the quarkgluon level to the
N(c)scaling of the potential for a generic hadronic field theory in which it
arises via meson exchanges and for which the parameters of the theory are given
by their canonical largeN(c) scaling behavior. The purpose of this comparison
is to use largeN(c) consistency to test the widespread view that the
interaction between nuclei arises from QCD through the exchange of mesons.
Although at the one and twomeson exchange level the scaling rules for the
potential derived from the hadronic theory matches the quarkgluon level
prediction, at the three and highermeson exchange level a generic hadronic
theory yields a potential which scales with N(c) faster than that of the
quarkgluon theory.

It has recently been suggested that the parity doublet structure seen in the
spectrum of highly excited baryons may be due to effective chiral symmetry
restoration for these states. We review the recent developments in this field.
We demonstrate with a simple quantummechanical example that it is a very
natural property of quantum systems that a symmetry breaking effect which is
important for the lowlying spectrum of the system, can become unimportant for
the highlylying states; the highly lying states reveal a multiplet structure
of nearly degenerate states. Using the well established concepts of
quarkhadron duality, asymptotic freedom in QCD and validity of the operator
product expansion in QCD we show that the spectral densities obtained with the
local currents that are connected to each other via chiral transformations,
very high in the spectrum must coincide. Hence effects of spontaneous breaking
of chiral symmetry in QCD vacuum that are crucially important for the lowlying
spectra, become irrelevant for the highlylying states. Then to the extent that
identifiable hadronic resonances still exist in the continuum spectrum at high
excitations this implies that the highly excited hadrons must fall into
multiplets associated with the representations of the chiral group. We
demonstrate that this is indeed the case for meson spectra in the large $N_c$
limit. All possible paritychiral multiplets are classified for baryons and it
is demonstrated that the existing data on highly excited $N$ and $\Delta$
states at masses of 2 GeV and higher is consistent with approximate chiral
symmetry restoration. However new experimental studies are needed to achieve
any definitive conclusions.

It has recently been suggested that the parity doublet structure seen in the
spectrum of highly excited baryons may be due to effective chiral restoration
for these states. We argue how the idea of chiral symmetry restoration high in
the spectrum is consistent with the concept of quarkhadron duality. If chiral
symmetry is effectively restored for highlylying states, then the baryons
should fall into representations of $SU(2)_L\times SU(2)_R$ that are compatible
with the given parity of the states  the paritychiral multiplets. We classify
all possible paritychiral multiplets: (i) $(1/2,0)\oplus(0, 1/2)$ that contain
parity doublet for nucleon spectrum;(ii) $(3/2,0) \oplus (0, 3/2)$ consists of
the parity doublet for delta spectrum; (iii) $(1/2,1) \oplus (1, 1/2)$ contains
one parity doublet in the nucleon spectrum and one parity doublet in the delta
spectrum of the same spin that are degenerate in mass. Here we show that the
available spectroscopic data for nonstrange baryons in the $\sim$ 2 GeV range
is consistent with all possibilities, but the approximate degeneracy of parity
doublets in nucleon and delta spectra support the latter possibility with
excited baryons approximately falling into $(1/2,1) \oplus (1, 1/2)$
representation of $SU(2)_L\timesSU(2)_R$ with approximate degeneracy between
positive and negative parity $N$ and $\Delta$ resonances of the same spin.

Some form of nonperturbative regularization is necessary if effective field
theory treatments of the NN interaction are to yield finite answers. We discuss
various regularization schemes used in the literature. Two of these methods
involve formally iterating the divergent interaction and then regularizing and
renormalizing the resultant amplitude. Either a (sharp or smooth) cutoff can be
introduced, or dimensional regularization can be applied. We show that these
two methods yield different results after renormalization. Furthermore, if a
cutoff is used, the NN phase shift data cannot be reproduced if the cutoff is
taken to infinity. We also argue that the assumptions which allow the use of
dimensional regularization in perturbative EFT calculations are violated in
this problem. Another possibility is to introduce a regulator into the
potential before iteration and then keep the cutoff parameter finite. We argue
that this does not lead to a systematicallyimprovable NN interaction.

We study an effective field theory of interacting nucleons at distances much
greater than the pion's Compton wavelength. In this regime the NN potential is
conjectured to be the sum of a delta function and its derivatives. The question
we address is whether this sum can be consistently truncated at a given order
in the derivative expansion, and systematically improved by going to higher
orders. Regularizing the LippmannSchwinger equation using a cutoff we find
that the cutoff can be taken to infinity only if the effective range is
negative. A positive effective rangewhich occurs in naturerequires that
the cutoff be kept finite and below the scale of the physics which has been
integrated out, i.e. O(m_\pi). Comparison of cutoff schemes and dimensional
regularization reveals that the physical scattering amplitude is sensitive to
the choice of regulator. Moreover, we show that the presence of some regulator
scale, a feature absent in dimensional regularization, is essential if the
effective field theory of NN scattering is to be useful. We also show that one
can define a procedure where finite cutoff dependence in the scattering
amplitude is removed order by order in the effective potential. However, the
characteristic momentum in the problem is given by the cutoff, and not by the
external momentum. It follows that in the presence of a finite cutoff there is
no small parameter in the effective potential, and consequently no systematic
truncation of the derivative expansion can be made. We conclude that there is
no effective field theory of NN scattering with nucleons alone.

We use powercounting arguments as an organizing principle to apply chiral
perturbation theory, including an explicit $\Delta$, to the $p p \rightarrow p
p \pi^0$ reaction near threshold. There are two lowestorder leading mechanisms
expected to contribute to the amplitude with similar magnitudes: an impulse
term, and a $\Delta$excitation mechanism. We examine formally subleading but
potentially large mechanisms, including pionrescattering and shortranged
contributions. We show that the pionrescattering contribution is enhanced by
offshell effects and has a sign opposite to that of a recent estimate based on
a PCAC pion interpolating field. Our result is that the impulse term interferes
destructively with the pion rescattering and $\Delta$excitation terms. In
addition, we have modeled the shortranged interaction using $\sigma$ and
$\omega$ exchange mechanisms. A recoil correction to the impulse approximation
is small. The total amplitude obtained including all of these processes is
found to yield cross sections substantially smaller than the measured ones.