Particle physics has an ambitious and broad experimental programme for the
coming decades. This programme requires large investments in detector hardware,
either to build new facilities and experiments, or to upgrade existing ones.
Similarly, it requires commensurate investment in the R&D of software to
acquire, manage, process, and analyse the shear amounts of data to be recorded.
In planning for the HL-LHC in particular, it is critical that all of the
collaborating stakeholders agree on the software goals and priorities, and that
the efforts complement each other. In this spirit, this white paper describes
the R&D activities required to prepare for this software upgrade.
Through the last three decades, accurate simulation of the interactions of
particles with matter and modeling of detector geometries has proven to be of
critical importance to the success of the international high-energy physics
(HEP) experimental programs. For example, the detailed detector modeling and
accurate physics of the Geant4-based simulation software of the CMS and ATLAS
particle physics experiments at the European Center of Nuclear Research (CERN)
Large Hadron Collider (LHC) was a determinant factor for these collaborations
to deliver physics results of outstanding quality faster than any hadron
collider experiment ever before.
This review article highlights the impact of detector simulation on particle
physics collider experiments. It presents numerous examples of the use of
simulation, from detector design and optimization, through software and
computing development and testing, to cases where the use of simulation samples
made a difference in the precision of the physics results and publication
turnaround, from data-taking to submission. It also presents estimates of the
cost and economic impact of simulation in the CMS experiment.
Future experiments will collect orders of magnitude more data with
increasingly complex detectors, taxing heavily the performance of simulation
and reconstruction software. Consequently, exploring solutions to speed up
simulation and reconstruction software to satisfy the growing demand of
computing resources in a time of flat budgets is a matter that deserves
immediate attention. The article ends with a short discussion on the potential
solutions that are being considered, based on leveraging core count growth in
multicore machines, using new generation coprocessors, and re-engineering HEP
code for concurrency and parallel computing.
Report of the Snowmass CpF-I4 subgroup on Software Development, Staffing and
We present a summary of the most recent measurements relevant to Quantum
Chromodynamics (QCD) delivered by the D0 and CDF Tevatron experiments by May
2008. CDF and D0 are moving toward precision measurements of QCD based on data
samples in excess of 1 fb-1. The inclusive jet cross sections have been
extended to forward rapidity regions and measured with unprecedented precision
following improvements in the jet energy calibration. Results on dijet mass
distributions, bbbar dijet production using tracker based triggers, underlying
event in dijet and Drell-Yan samples, inclusive photon and diphoton cross
sections complete the list of measurements included in this paper. Good
agreement with pQCD within errors is observed for jet production measurements.
An improved and consistent theoretical description is needed for photon+jets
processes. Collisions at the LHC are scheduled for early fall 2008, opening an
era of discoveries at the new energy frontier, 5-7 times higher than that of
The Run II jet physics group includes the Jet Algorithms, Jet Shape/Energy
Flow, and Jet Measurements/Correlations subgroups. The main goal of the jet
algorithm subgroup was to explore and define standard Run II jet finding
procedures for CDF and DO. The focus of the jet shape/energy flow group was the
study of jets as objects and the energy flows around these objects. The jet
measurements/correlations subgroup discussed measurements at different beam
energies; strong coupling constant measurements; and LO, NLO, NNLO, and
threshold jet calculations. As a practical matter the algorithm and
shape/energy flow groups merged to concentrate on the development of Run II jet
algorithms that are both free of theoretical and experimental difficulties and
able to reproduce Run I measurements.
Starting from a review of the experience gained during Run I, the group
considered a variety of cone algorithms and KT algorithms. The current
understanding of both types of algorithms, including calibration issues, are
discussed in this report along with some preliminary experimental results. The
jet algorithms group recommends that CDF and DO employ the same version of both
a cone algorithm and a KT algorithm during Run II. Proposed versions of each
type of algorithm are discussed. The group also recommends the use of full
4-vector kinematic variables whenever possible. The recommended algorithms
attempt to minimize the impact of seeds in the case of the cone algorithm and
preclustering in the case of the KT algorithm. Issues regarding precluster
definitions and merge/split criteria require further study.