
In a recent Letter [EPL, 118 (2017) 40003], Polettini and Esposito claimed
that it is theoretically possible for a thermodynamic machine to achieve Carnot
efficiency at divergent power output through the use of infinitelyfast
processes. It appears however that this assertion is misleading as it is not
supported by their derivations as demonstrated below. In this Comment, we first
show that there is a confusion regarding the notion of optimal efficiency. We
then analyze the quantum dot engine described in Ref. [EPL, 118 (2017) 40003]
and demonstrate that Carnot efficiency is recovered only for vanishing output
power. Moreover, a discussion on the use of infinite thermodynamical forces to
reach Carnot efficiency is also presented in the appendix.

In a recent article [Phys. Rev. Applied 5, 024005 (2016)], Gibelli and
coworkers proposed a method to determine the thermopower, i.e. the Seebeck
coefficient, using photoluminescence measurements. The photoluminescence
spectra are used to obtain the local gradients of both the electrochemical
potential difference between electron and holes and the temperature of the
electronhole plasma. However, the definition of the thermopower given in that
article seems erroneous due to a confusion between the different physical
quantities needed to derive this parameter.

We show how smallsignal analysis, a standard method in electrical
engineering, may be applied to thermoelectric device performance measurement by
extending a dc model to the dynamical regime. We thus provide a physical ground
to \textit{adhoc} models used to interpret impedance spectroscopy of
thermoelectric elements from an electrical circuit equivalent for
thermoelectric systems in the frequency domain. We particularly stress the
importance of the finite thermal impedance of the thermal contacts between the
thermoelectric system and the thermal reservoirs in the derivation of such
models. The expression for the characteristic angular frequency of the
thermoelectric system we obtain is a generalization of the expressions derived
in previous studies. In particular, it allows to envisage impedance
spectroscopy measurements beyond the restrictive case of adiabatic boundary
conditions often difficult to achieve experimentally, and hence \emph{insitu}
characterization of thermoelectric generators.

While Carnot's model engines demonstrate ideal performances regarding
conversion efficiency, they cannot be actually used as energy converters since
they are non causal systems. Such an unphysical behavior indeed restrains the
working conditions to a single point where, in the case of a refrigerator
(generator), the cooling power (output power) vanishes. Focusing on the example
of a thermoelectric refrigerator, we study the impact of different dissipation
sources on the causality of such systems. Basing our analysis on the block
diagram description of this system, we discuss particularly the fact that heat
conduction cannot ensure causality.

While thermoelectric transport theory is well established and widely applied,
there remains some degree of confusion on the proper thermodynamic definition
of the Seebeck coefficient (or thermoelectric power) which is a measure of the
strength of the mutual interaction between electric charge transport and heat
transport. Indeed, as one considers a thermoelectric system, it is not always
clear whether the Seebeck coefficient is to be related to the gradient of the
system's chemical potential or to the gradient of its electrochemical
potential. This pedagogical article aims to shed light on this confusion and
clarify the thermodynamic definition of the thermoelectric coupling. First, we
recall how the Seebeck coefficient is experimentally determined. We then turn
to the analysis of the relationship between the thermoelectric power and the
relevant potentials in the thermoelectric system: As the definitions of the
chemical and electrochemical potentials are clarified, we show that, with a
proper consideration of each potential, one may derive the Seebeck coefficient
of a nondegenerate semiconductor without the need to introduce a contact
potential as seen sometimes in the literature. Furthermore, we demonstrate that
the phenomenological expression of the electrical current resulting from
thermoelectric effects may be directly obtained from the driftdiffusion
equation.

Kelvin's relations may be considered as cornerstones in the theory of
thermoelectricity. Indeed, they gather together the three thermoelectric
effects, associated respectively with Seebeck, Peltier and Thomson, to get a
unique and consistent description of thermoelectric phenomena. However, their
physical status in literature are quite different. On the one hand, the second
Kelvin's relation is associated with the microscopic reversibility, considered
as a fundamental thermodynamical property. On the other hand, the first
Kelvin's relation is traditionally introduced only as a convenient mathematical
relation between Seebeck and Thomson coefficients. In the present article, we
stress that, contrary to common believes, this relation may demonstrates deeper
insights than a bold mathematical expression between thermoelectric
coefficients. It actually reflects the coexistence of two different mechanisms
taking place inside thermoelectric systems: Energy conversion and
reorganization of heat flow when Seebeck coefficient varies.

Plants are sensitive to thermal and electrical effects; yet the coupling of
both, known as thermoelectricity, and its quantitative measurement in vegetal
systems never were reported. We recorded the thermoelectric response of bean
sprouts under various thermal conditions and stress. The obtained experimental
data unambiguously demonstrate that a temperature difference between the roots
and the leaves of a bean sprout induces a thermoelectric voltage between these
two points. Basing our analysis of the data on the forceflux formalism of
linear response theory, we found that the strength of the vegetal equivalent to
the thermoelectric coupling is one order of magnitude larger than that in the
best thermoelectric materials. Experimental data also show the importance of
the thermal stress variation rate in the plant's electrophysiological response.
Therefore, thermoelectric effects are sufficiently important to partake in the
complex and intertwined processes of energy and matter transport within plants.

We study the physical processes at work at the interface of two
thermoelectric generators (TEGs) thermally and electrically connected in
series. We show and explain how these processes impact on the system's
performance: the derivation of the equivalent electrical series resistance
yields a term whose physical meaning is thoroughly discussed. We demonstrate
that this term must exist as a consequence of thermal continuity at the
interface, since it is related to the variation of the junction temperature
between the two TEGs associated in series as the electrical current varies. We
then derive an expression for the equivalent series figure of merit. Finally we
highlight the strong thermal/electrical symmetry between the parallel and
series configurations and we compare our derivation with recent published
results for the parallel configuration.

Optimization analyses of thermoelectric generators operation is of importance
both for practical applications and theoretical considerations. Depending on
the desired goal, two different strategies are possible to achieve high
performance: through optimization one may seek either power output maximization
or conversion efficiency maximization. Recent literature reveals the persistent
flawed notion that these two optimal working conditions may be achieved
simultaneously. In this article, we lift all source of confusion by correctly
posing the problem and solving it. We assume and discuss two possibilities for
the environment of the generator to govern its operation: constant incoming
heat flux, and constant temperature difference between the heat reservoirs. We
demonstrate that, while power and efficiency are maximized simultaneously if
the first assumption is considered, this is not possible with the second
assumption. This latter corresponds to the seminal analyses of Ioffe who put
forth and stressed the importance of the thermoelectric figure of merit $ZT$.
We also provide a simple procedure to determine the different optimal design
parameters of a thermoelectric generator connected to heat reservoirs through
thermal contacts with a finite and fixed thermal conductance.

We show how the formalism used for thermoelectric transport may be adapted to
Smoluchowski's seminal thought experiment also known as Feynman's ratchet and
pawl system. Our analysis rests on the notion of useful flux, which for a
thermoelectric system is the electrical current and for Feynman's ratchet is
the effective jump frequency. Our approach yields original insight into the
derivation and analysis of the system's properties. In particular we define an
entropy per tooth in analogy with the entropy per carrier or Seebeck
coefficient, and we derive the analogue to Kelvin's second relation for
Feynman's ratchet. Owing to the formal similarity between the heat fluxes
balance equations for a thermoelectric generator (TEG) and those for Feynman's
ratchet, we introduce a distribution parameter that quantifies the amount of
heat that flows through the cold and hot sides of both heat engines. While it
is well established that $\gamma$ = 1/2 for a TEG, it is equal to 1 for
Feynman's ratchet. This implies that no heat may be rejected in the cold
reservoir for the latter case. Further, the analysis of the efficiency at
maximum power shows that the socalled Feynman efficiency corresponds to that
of an exoreversible engine, with $\gamma$ = 1. Then, turning to the nonlinear
regime, we generalize the approach based on the convection picture and
introduce two different types of resistance to distinguish the dynamical
behavior of the considered system from its ability to dissipate energy. We
finally put forth the strong similarity between the original Feynman ratchet
and a mesoscopic thermoelectric generator with a single conducting channel.

In a recent article, Baranowski et al. [J. Appl. Phys. 113, 204904 (2013)]
proposed a model that allegedly facilitates optimization of thermoelectric
generators operation as these latter are in contact with hot and cold
temperature baths through finite conductance heat exchangers. In this Comment,
we argue that the results and analyses presented by these authors are
misleading since their model is incomplete and rests on an inappropriate
assumption derived from thermoelectric compatibility theory.

We discuss the recent results of Lee et al. [Nature 498, 209 (2013)] using
the notion of thermoelectric convection. In particular, we highlight the fact
that this contribution to the thermal flux is not a dissipative process.

Improvement of thermoelectric systems in terms of performance and range of
applications relies on progress in materials science and optimization of device
operation. In this chapter, we focuse on optimization by taking into account
the interaction of the system with its environment. For this purpose, we
consider the illustrative case of a thermoelectric generator coupled to two
temperature baths via heat exchangers characterized by a thermal resistance,
and we analyze its working conditions. Our main message is that both electrical
and thermal impedance matching conditions must be met for optimal device
performance. Our analysis is fundamentally based on linear nonequilibrium
thermodynamics using the forceflux formalism. An outlook on mesoscopic systems
is also given.

We reply to the comment made by Su et al. on "Optimal working conditions for
thermoelectric generators with realistic thermal coupling". In particular we
justify the efficiency definition used in the main paper.

Coupling between heat and electrical currents is at the heart of
thermoelectric processes. From a thermal viewpoint this may be seen as an
additional thermal flux linked to the appearance of electrical current in a
given thermoelectric system. Since this additional flux is associated to the
global displacement of charge carriers in the system, it can be qualified as
convective in opposition to the conductive part associated with both phonons
transport and heat transport by electrons under open circuit condition, as,
e.g., in the WiedemannFranz relation. In this article we demonstrate that
considering the convective part of the thermal flux allows both new insight
into the thermoelectric energy conversion and the derivation of the maximum
power condition for generators with realistic thermal coupling.

We study the efficiency at maximum power of two coupled heat engines, using
thermoelectric generators (TEGs) as engines. Assuming that the heat and
electric charge fluxes in the TEGs are strongly coupled, we simulate
numerically the dependence of the behavior of the global system on the
electrical load resistance of each generator in order to obtain the working
condition that permits maximization of the output power. It turns out that this
condition is not unique. We derive a simple analytic expression giving the
relation between the electrical load resistance of each generator permitting
output power maximization. We then focuse on the efficiency at maximum power
(EMP) of the whole system to demonstrate that the CurzonAhlborn efficiency may
not always be recovered: the EMP varies with the specific working conditions of
each generator but remains in the range predicted by irreversible
thermodynamics theory. We finally discuss our results in light of nonideal
Carnot engine behavior.

Thermoelectric generators are particularly suitable to investigate the
irreversible processes which govern the coupled transport of matter and heat in
solidstate systems. We study the efficiency at maximum power in the strong
coupling regime, where the thermal flux is proportionnal to the electrical
current inside the generator. We demonstrate that depending on the source of
irreversibility we obtain either the CurzonAhlborn efficiency for external
dissipation or a universal efficiency at maximum power for internal
dissipation. A continuous change between these two extremes is evidenced.
Effects of dissymetry of thermal contact conductance are also investigated.

Considering a system composed of two different thermoelectric modules
electrically and thermally connected in parallel, we demonstrate that the
inhomogeneities of the thermoelectric properties of the materials may cause the
appearance of an electrical current, which develops inside the system. We show
that this current increases the effective thermal conductance of the whole
system. We also discuss the significance of a recent finding concerning a
reported new electrothermal effect in inhomogeneous bipolar semiconductors, in
light of our results.

We study how maximum output power can be obtained from a thermoelectric
generator(TEG) with nonideal heat exchangers. We demonstrate with an analytic
approach based on a forceflux formalism that the sole improvement of the
intrinsic characteristics of thermoelectric modules including the enhancement
of the figure of merit is of limited interest: the constraints imposed by the
working conditions of the TEG must be considered on the same footing.
Introducing an effective thermal conductance we derive the conditions which
permit maximization of both efficiency and power production of the TEG
dissipatively coupled to heat reservoirs. Thermal impedance matching must be
accounted for as well as electrical impedance matching in order to maximize the
output power. Our calculations also show that the thermal impedance does not
only depend on the thermal conductivity at zero electrical current: it also
depends on the TEG figure of merit. Our analysis thus yields both electrical
and thermal conditions permitting optimal use of a thermoelectric generator.

Similar to silicon that is the basis of conventional electronics, strontium
titanate (SrTiO3) is the bedrock of the emerging field of oxide electronics.
SrTiO3 is the preferred template to create exotic twodimensional (2D) phases
of electron matter at oxide interfaces, exhibiting metalinsulator transitions,
superconductivity, or large negative magnetoresistance. However, the physical
nature of the electronic structure underlying these 2D electron gases (2DEGs)
remains elusive, although its determination is crucial to understand their
remarkable properties. Here we show, using angleresolved photoemission
spectroscopy (ARPES), that there is a highly metallic universal 2DEG at the
vacuumcleaved surface of SrTiO3, independent of bulk carrier densities over
more than seven decades, including the undoped insulating material. This 2DEG
is confined within a region of ~5 unit cells with a sheet carrier density of
~0.35 electrons per a^2 (a is the cubic lattice parameter). We unveil a
remarkable electronic structure consisting on multiple subbands of heavy and
light electrons. The similarity of this 2DEG with those reported in
SrTiO3based heterostructures and fieldeffect transistors suggests that
different forms of electron confinement at the surface of SrTiO3 lead to
essentially the same 2DEG. Our discovery provides a model system for the study
of the electronic structure of 2DEGs in SrTiO3based devices, and a novel route
to generate 2DEGs at surfaces of transitionmetal oxides.