-
Up to now both information and its connection to reality have not
scientifically conclusive definitions neither implicit origin. They emerge in
observing multiple impulses interactive yes-no actions modeling information
Bits. The observed information process connects reality, information, and
creates Observer. Interaction is fundamental reality building structure of
Universe from quantum physics up to brain neurons interactive actions. Merging
action and reaction joins probabilistic prior and posterior actions on edge of
the observed predictability and begins microprocess. Its time of entanglement
starts space interval composing two qubits or Bit of reversible logic in the
emerging information process. The impulse interacting action curves impulse
geometry creating asymmetrical logic Bit as logical Maxwell demon. With
approaching probability one, the attracting interaction captures energy
memorizing asymmetrical logic in information certain Bit. Such Bit is naturally
extracted at minimal quality energy equivalent ln2 working as Maxwell Demon.
The memorized impulse Bit and its free information self-organizes multiple Bits
in triplets sructuring macroprocess. Memorized information binds reversible
microprocess with irreversible information macroprocess along multidimensional
observing process. The macroprocess self-forming triplet units UP attract new
UP through free Information. Multiple UP adjoin hierarchical network whose free
information produces new UP at higher level node and encodes triplets in
multi-levels hierarchical organization. The interactive information dynamics
assemble geometrical and information structures of cognition and intelligence
in double spiral rotating code. Information Path Functional integrates multiple
interactive dynamics in finite bits which observe and measure reality. The time
and space of reality exists only as units of information as Wheeler predicted.
-
Finding observing path creating its observer is important problem in physics
and information science. In observing processes, each observation is act
changing the observing process that generates interactive observation. Each
interaction is discrete Yes-No impulse modeling Bit. Recurring inter-actions
independent of physical nature is phenomenon of information. Multiple
interactions generate random Markov chains covering multiple Bits. Impulse No
action cuts maximum entropy-uncertainty, Yes action transfers cut minimum to
next impulse creating maximin principle decreasing uncertainty. The cutoff
entropies reveal hidden information naturally observing interactive impulse as
elementary observer. Conversion impulse entropies to information integrates
path functional. The maxmin variation principle formalizes interactive
information equations. Merging Yes-No actions generate microprocess within
bordered impulses running superposition of conjugated entropies entangling
during time interval within forming space intervals. Interaction curves impulse
geometry creating asymmetry which logically erases entangled entropy removing
causal probabilistic entropy with symmetrical reversible logic and bringing
asymmetrical information logic. Entropy-information topological gap connects
asymmetrical logic with physical Markov diffusion whose energy memorizes
logical Bit. Moving Bits selfform unit of information macroprocess attracting
new UP through free Information. Multiple UP triples adjoin hierarchical
network (IN) whose free information produces new UP at higher level node and
encodes triple code logic. Each UP unique position in IN hierarchy defines
location of each code logical structure. The IN node hierarchical level
classifies quality of assembled Information. Ending IN node enfolds all IN
levels. Multiple INs enclose Observer cognition and intelligence with
consciousness.
-
Understanding the mechanisms responsible for the emergence and evolution of
oscillations in traffic flow has been subject to intensive research by the
traffic flow theory community. In our previous work, we proposed a new
mechanism to explain the generation of traffic oscillations: traffic
instability caused by the competition between speed adaptation and the
cumulative effect of stochastic factors. In this paper, by conducting a closer
examination of car following data obtained in a 25-car platoon experiment, we
discovered that the speed difference plays a more important role on
car-following dynamics than the spacing, and when its amplitude is small, the
growth of oscillations is mainly determined by the stochastic factors that
follow the mean reversion process; when its amplitude increases, the growth of
the oscillations is determined by the competition between the stochastic
factors and the speed difference. An explanation is then provided, based on the
above findings, to why the speed variance in the oscillatory traffic grows in a
concave way along the platoon. Finally, we proposed a mode-switching stochastic
car-following model that incorporates the speed adaptation and spacing
indifference behaviors of drivers, which captures the observed characteristics
of oscillation and discharge rate. Sensitivity analysis shows that reaction
delay only has slight effect but indifference region boundary has significant
on oscillation growth rate and discharge rate.
-
An imperative condition for the functioning of a power-grid network is that
its power generators remain synchronized. Disturbances can prompt
desynchronization, which is a process that has been involved in large power
outages. Here we derive a condition under which the desired synchronous state
of a power grid is stable, and use this condition to identify tunable
parameters of the generators that are determinants of spontaneous
synchronization. Our analysis gives rise to an approach to specify parameter
assignments that can enhance synchronization of any given network, which we
demonstrate for a selection of both test systems and real power grids. Because
our results concern spontaneous synchronization, they are relevant both for
reducing dependence on conventional control devices, thus offering an
additional layer of protection given that most power outages involve equipment
or operational errors, and for contributing to the development of "smart grids"
that can recover from failures in real time.
-
To well understand crowd behavior, microscopic models have been developed in
recent decades, in which an individual's behavioral/psychological status can be
modeled and simulated. A well-known model is the social-force model innovated
by physical scientists (Helbing and Molnar, 1995; Helbing, Farkas and Vicsek,
2000; Helbing et al., 2002). This model has been widely accepted and mainly
used in simulation of crowd evacuation in the past decade. A problem, however,
is that the testing results of the model were not explained in consistency with
the psychological findings, resulting in misunderstanding of the model by
psychologists. This paper will bridge the gap between psychological studies and
physical explanation about this model. We reinterpret this physics-based model
from a psychological perspective, clarifying that the model is consistent with
psychological theories on stress, including time-related stress and
interpersonal stress. Based on the conception of stress, we renew the model at
both micro-and-macro level, referring to multi-agent simulation in a
microscopic sense and fluid-based analysis in a macroscopic sense. The
cognition and behavior of individual agents are critically modeled as response
to environmental stimuli. Existing simulation results such as faster-is-slower
effect will be reinterpreted by Yerkes-Dodson law, and herding and grouping
effect are further discussed by integrating attraction into the social force.
In brief the social-force model exhibits a bridge between the physics laws and
psychological principles regarding crowd motion, and this paper will renew and
reinterpret the model on the foundation of psychological studies.
-
The spread of opinions, memes, diseases, and "alternative facts" in a
population depends both on the details of the spreading process and on the
structure of the social and communication networks on which they spread. In
this paper, we explore how \textit{anti-establishment} nodes (e.g.,
\textit{hipsters}) influence the spreading dynamics of two competing products.
We consider a model in which spreading follows a deterministic rule for
updating node states (which describe which product has been adopted) in which
an adjustable fraction $p_{\rm Hip}$ of the nodes in a network are hipsters,
who choose to adopt the product that they believe is the less popular of the
two. The remaining nodes are conformists, who choose which product to adopt by
considering which products their immediate neighbors have adopted. We simulate
our model on both synthetic and real networks, and we show that the hipsters
have a major effect on the final fraction of people who adopt each product:
even when only one of the two products exists at the beginning of the
simulations, a very small fraction of hipsters in a network can still cause the
other product to eventually become the more popular one. To account for this
behavior, we construct an approximation for the steady-state adoption fraction
on $k$-regular trees in the limit of few hipsters. Additionally, our
simulations demonstrate that a time delay $\tau$ in the knowledge of the
product distribution in a population, as compared to immediate knowledge of
product adoption among nearest neighbors, can have a large effect on the final
distribution of product adoptions. Our simple model and analysis may help shed
light on the road to success for anti-establishment choices in elections, as
such success can arise rather generically in our model from a small number of
anti-establishment individuals and ordinary processes of social influence on
normal individuals.
-
We represent the functioning of the housing market and study the relation
between income segregation, income inequality and house prices by introducing a
spatial Agent-Based Model (ABM). Differently from traditional models in urban
economics, we explicitly specify the behavior of buyers and sellers and the
price formation mechanism. Buyers who differ by income select among
heterogeneous neighborhoods using a probabilistic model of residential choice;
sellers employ an aspiration level heuristic to set their reservation offer
price; prices are determined through a continuous double auction. We first
provide an approximate analytical solution of the ABM, shedding light on the
structure of the model and on the effect of the parameters. We then simulate
the ABM and find that: (i) a more unequal income distribution lowers the prices
globally, but implies stronger segregation; (ii) a spike of the demand in one
part of the city increases the prices all over the city; (iii) subsidies are
more efficient than taxes in fostering social mixing.
-
We explore a new mechanism to explain polarization phenomena in opinion
dynamics in which agents evaluate alternative views on the basis of the social
feedback obtained on expressing them. High support of the favored opinion in
the social environment, is treated as a positive feedback which reinforces the
value associated to this opinion. In connected networks of sufficiently high
modularity, different groups of agents can form strong convictions of competing
opinions. Linking the social feedback process to standard equilibrium concepts
we analytically characterize sufficient conditions for the stability of
bi-polarization. While previous models have emphasized the polarization effects
of deliberative argument-based communication, our model highlights an affective
experience-based route to polarization, without assumptions about negative
influence or bounded confidence.
-
The synchronization of self-propelled particles (SPPs) is a fascinating
instance of emergent behavior in living and man-made systems, such as colonies
of bacteria, flocks of birds, robot ensembles, and many others. The recent
discovery of chimera states in coupled oscillators opens up new perspectives
and indicates that other emergent behaviors may exist for SPPs. Indeed, for a
minimal extension of the classical Vicsek model we show the existence of
chimera states for SPPs, i.e., one group of particles synchronizes while others
wander around chaotically. Compared to chimeras in coupled oscillators where
the site position is fixed, SPPs give rise to new distinctive forms of chimeric
behavior. We emphasize that the found behavior is directly implied by the
structure of the deterministic equation of motion and is not caused by
exogenous stochastic excitation. In the scaling limit of infinitely many
particles, we show that the chimeric state persists. Our findings provide the
starting point for the search or elicitation of chimeric states in real world
SPP systems.
-
Gene regulatory network (GRN)-based morphogenetic models have recently gained
an increasing attention. However, the relationship between microscopic
properties of intracellular GRNs and macroscopic properties of morphogenetic
systems has not been fully understood yet. Here we propose a theoretical
morphogenetic model representing an aggregation of cells, and reveal the
relationship between criticality of GRNs and morphogenetic pattern formation.
In our model, the positions of the cells are determined by spring-mass-damper
kinetics. Each cell has an identical Kauffman's $NK$ random Boolean network
(RBN) as its GRN. We varied the properties of GRNs from ordered, through
critical, to chaotic by adjusting node in-degree $K$. We randomly assigned four
cell fates to the attractors of RBNs for cellular behaviors. By comparing
diverse morphologies generated in our morphogenetic systems, we investigated
what the role of the criticality of GRNs is in forming morphologies. We found
that nontrivial spatial patterns were generated most frequently when GRNs were
at criticality. Our finding indicates that the criticality of GRNs facilitates
the formation of nontrivial morphologies in GRN-based morphogenetic systems.
-
This study deals with the evolution of the so called 'intelligent' networks
(insect society without leader, cells of an organism, brain,...) during their
learning period. First we summarize briefly the Version 2 (published in
French), whose the main characteristics are: 1) A network connected to its
environment is considered as immersed into an information field created by this
environment which so dictates to it the learning constraints. 2) The used
formalism draws one's inspiration from the one of the Quantum field theory
(Principle of stationary action, gauge fields, invariance by symmetry
transformations,...). 3) We obtain Lagrange equations whose solutions describe
the network evolution during the whole learning period. 4) Then, while
proceeding with the same formalism inspiration, we suggest other study ways
capable of evolving the knowledge in the considered scope. In a second part,
after a reminder of the points to be improved, we exhibit the Version 5 which
brings, we think, relevant improvements. Indeed: 5) We consider the weighted
averages of the variables; this introduces probabilities. 6) We define two
observables (L average of information flux and A activity of the network) which
could be measured and so be compared with experimental results. 7) We find that
L , weighted average of information flows, is an invariant. 8) Finally, we
propose two expressions for the conactance, from which we deduce the
corresponding Lagrange equations which have to be solved to know the evolution
of the considered weighted averages. But, at the present stage, we think that
we can progress only by carrying out experiments (see projects like Human brain
project) and discovering invariants, symmetries which would allow us, like in
Physics, to classify networks and above all to understand better the
connections between them. Indeed, and that is what we propose among the future
research ways, the underlying problem is to understand how, after their
learning period, several networks can connect together to produce, in the brain
case for instance, what we call mental states.
-
This work aimed, to determine the characteristics of activity series from
fractal geometry concepts application, in addition to evaluate the possibility
of identifying individuals with fibromyalgia. Activity level data were
collected from 27 healthy subjects and 27 fibromyalgia patients, with the use
of clock-like devices equipped with accelerometers, for about four weeks, all
day long. The activity series were evaluated through fractal and multifractal
methods. Hurst exponent analysis exhibited values according to other studies
($H>0.5$) for both groups ($H=0.98\pm0.04$ for healthy subjects and
$H=0.97\pm0.03$ for fibromyalgia patients), however, it is not possible to
distinguish between the two groups by such analysis. Activity time series also
exhibited a multifractal pattern. A paired analysis of the spectra indices for
the sleep and awake states revealed differences between healthy subjects and
fibromyalgia patients. The individuals feature differences between awake and
sleep states, having statistically significant differences for $\alpha_{q-} -
\alpha_{0}$ in healthy subjects ($p = 0.014$) and $D_{0}$ for patients with
fibromyalgia ($p = 0.013$). The approach has proven to be an option on the
characterisation of such kind of signals and was able to differ between both
healthy and fibromyalgia groups. This outcome suggests changes in the
physiologic mechanisms of movement control.
-
The self-oscillatory dynamics is considered as motion of a particle in a
potential field in the presence of dissipation. Described mechanism of
self-oscillation excitation is not associated with peculiarities of a
dissipation function, but results from properties of a potential, whose shape
depends on a system state. Moreover, features of a potential function allow to
realize the self-oscillation excitation in a case of the dissipation function
being positive at each point of the phase space. The phenomenon is explored
both numerically and experimentally on the example of a double-well oscillator
with a state-dependent potential and dissipation. After that a simplified
single-well model is studied.
-
Game theory is widely used as a behavioral model for strategic interactions
in biology and social science. It is common practice to assume that players
quickly converge to an equilibrium, e.g. a Nash equilibrium. This can be
studied in terms of best reply dynamics, in which each player myopically uses
the best response to her opponent's last move. Existing research shows that
convergence can be problematic when there are best reply cycles. Here we
calculate how typical this is by studying the space of all possible two-player
normal form games and counting the frequency of best reply cycles. The two key
parameters are the number of moves, which defines how complicated the game is,
and the anti-correlation of the payoffs, which determines how competitive it
is. We find that as games get more complicated and more competitive, best reply
cycles become dominant. The existence of best reply cycles predicts
non-convergence of six different learning algorithms that have support from
human experiments. Our results imply that for complicated and competitive games
equilibrium is typically an unrealistic assumption. Alternatively, if for some
reason "real" games are special and do not possess cycles, we raise the
interesting question of why this should be so.
-
We introduce a model called Host-Pathogen game for studying biological
competitions. Notably, we focus on the invasive dynamics of external agents,
like bacteria, within a host organism. The former are mapped to a population of
defectors that aim to spread in the extracellular medium of the host. In turn,
the latter is composed of cells, mapped to a population of cooperators, that
aim to kill pathogens. The cooperative behavior of cells is fundamental for the
emergence of the living functions of the whole organism, since each one
contributes to a specific set of tasks. So, broadly speaking, their
contribution can be viewed as a form of energy. When bacteria are spatially
close to a cell, the latter can use a fraction of its energy to remove them. On
the other hand, when bacteria survive an attack, they absorb the received
energy, becoming stronger and more resistant to further attacks. In addition,
since bacteria play as defectors, their unique target is to increase their
wealth, without supporting their own kind. As in many living organisms, the
host temperature plays a relevant role in the host-pathogen equilibrium. For
instance, in animals like human beings, a neural mechanism triggers the
increasing of the body temperature in order to activate the immune system.
Here, cooperators succeed once bacteria are completely removed while, in the
opposite scenario, the host undergoes a deep invasive process, like a blood
poisoning. Results of numerical simulations show that the dynamics of the
proposed model allow to reach a variety of states. At a very high level of
abstraction, some of these states seem to be similar to those that can be
observed in some living systems. Therefore, to conclude, we deem that our model
might be exploited for studying further biological phenomena.
-
Experimental study on noise-induced synchronization of crystal oscillators is
presented. Two types of circuits were constructed: one consists of two Pierce
oscillators that were isolated from each other and received a common noise
input, while the other is based on a single Pierce oscillator that received a
same sequence of noise signal repeatedly. Due to frequency detuning between the
two Pierce oscillators, the first circuit showed no clear sign of noise-induced
synchronization. The second circuit, on the other hand, generated coherent
waveforms between different trials of the same noise injection. The waveform
coherence was, however, broken immediately after the noise injection was
terminated. Stronger modulation such as the voltage resetting was finally shown
to be effective to induce phase shifts, leading to phase-synchronization of the
Pierce oscillator. Our study presents a guideline for synchronizing clocks of
multiple CPU systems, distributed sensor networks, and other engineering
devices.
-
Many problems in industry --- and in the social, natural, information, and
medical sciences --- involve discrete data and benefit from approaches from
subjects such as network science, information theory, optimization,
probability, and statistics. The study of networks is concerned explicitly with
connectivity between different entities, and it has become very prominent in
industrial settings, an importance that has intensified amidst the modern data
deluge. In this commentary, we discuss the role of network analysis in
industrial and applied mathematics, and we give several examples of network
science in industry. We focus, in particular, on discussing a
physical-applied-mathematics approach to the study of networks. We also discuss
several of our own collaborations with industry on projects in network
analysis.
-
The motion of social insects is often used a paradigmatic example of complex
adaptive dynamics arising from decentralized individual behavior. In this paper
we revisit the topic of the ruling laws behind burst of activity in ants. The
analysis, done over previously reported data, reconsider the causation arrows,
proposed at individual level, not finding any link between the duration of the
ants' activity and its moving speed. Secondly, synthetic trajectories created
from steps of different ants, demonstrate that a Markov process can explain the
previously reported speed shape profile. Finally we show that as more ants
enter the nest, the faster they move, which implies a collective property.
Overall these results provides a mechanistic explanation for the reported
behavioral laws, and suggest a formal way to further study the collective
properties in these scenarios.
-
We model the formation of multi-layer transportation networks as a
multi-objective optimization process, where service providers compete for
passengers, and the creation of routes is determined by a multi-objective cost
function encoding a trade-off between efficiency and competition. The resulting
model reproduces well real-world systems as diverse as airplane, train and bus
networks, thus suggesting that such systems are indeed compatible with the
proposed local optimization mechanisms. In the specific case of airline
transportation systems, we show that the networks of routes operated by each
company are placed very close to the theoretical Pareto front in the
efficiency-competition plane, and that most of the largest carriers of a
continent belong to the corresponding Pareto front. Our results shed light on
the fundamental role played by multi-objective optimization principles in
shaping the structure of large-scale multilayer transportation systems, and
provide novel insights to service providers on the strategies for the smart
selection of novel routes.
-
Synchronization is a universal phenomenon, seen in systems as diverse as
superconducting Josephson junctions and discharging pacemaker cells. Here the
elements have rhythmic state variables whose mutual influence promotes temporal
order. A parallel form of order is seen in swarming systems, such as schools of
fish or flocks of birds. Now the degrees of freedom are the individuals'
positions, which get redistributed through interactions to form spatial
structures. Systems capable of both swarming and synchronizing, dubbed
swarmalators, have recently been proposed [O'Keeffe, Kevin P., and Steven H.
Strogatz. "Swarmalators: Oscillators that sync and swarm." arXiv preprint
arXiv:1701.05670 (2017)] and analyzed in the continuum limit. Here we extend
this work by studying finite populations of swarmalators, whose phase
similarity affects both their spatial attraction and repulsion. We find ring
states, and compute criteria for their existence and stability. Larger
populations can form annular distributions, whose density and inner and outer
radii we calculate explicitly. These states may be observable in groups of
Japanese tree frogs, magnetic colloids, and other systems with an interplay
between swarming and synchronization.
-
We have previously presented a critique of the standard Marshallian theory of
the firm, and developed an alternative formulation that better agreed with the
results of simulation. An incorrect mathematical fact was used in our previous
presentation. This paper deals with correcting the derivation of the Keen
equilibrium, and generalising the result to the asymmetric case. As well, we
discuss the notion of rationality employed, and how this plays out in a two
player version of the game.
-
Cooperation is a persistent behavioral pattern of entities pooling and
sharing resources. Its ubiquity in nature poses a conundrum. Whenever two
entities cooperate, one must willingly relinquish something of value to the
other. Why is this apparent altruism favored in evolution? Classical solutions
assume a net fitness gain in a cooperative transaction which, through
reciprocity or relatedness, finds its way back from recipient to donor. We seek
the source of this fitness gain. Our analysis rests on the insight that
evolutionary processes are typically multiplicative and noisy. Fluctuations
have a net negative effect on the long-time growth rate of resources but no
effect on the growth rate of their expectation value. This is an example of
non-ergodicity. By reducing the amplitude of fluctuations, pooling and sharing
increases the long-time growth rate for cooperating entities, meaning that
cooperators outgrow similar non-cooperators. We identify this increase in
growth rate as the net fitness gain, consistent with the concept of geometric
mean fitness in the biological literature. This constitutes a fundamental
mechanism for the evolution of cooperation. Its minimal assumptions make it a
candidate explanation of cooperation in settings too simple for other fitness
gains, such as emergent function and specialization, to be probable. One such
example is the transition from single cells to early multicellular life.
-
Spontaneous cortical population activity exhibits a multitude of oscillatory
patterns, which often display synchrony during slow-wave sleep or under certain
anesthetics and stay asynchronous during quiet wakefulness. The mechanisms
behind these cortical states and transitions among them are not completely
understood. Here we study spontaneous population activity patterns in random
networks of spiking neurons of mixed types modeled by Izhikevich equations.
Neurons are coupled by conductance-based synapses subject to synaptic noise. We
localize the population activity patterns on the parameter diagram spanned by
the relative inhibitory synaptic strength and the magnitude of synaptic noise.
In absence of noise, networks display transient activity patterns, either
oscillatory or at constant level. The effect of noise is to turn transient
patterns into persistent ones: for weak noise, all activity patterns are
asynchronous non-oscillatory independently of synaptic strengths; for stronger
noise, patterns have oscillatory and synchrony characteristics that depend on
the relative inhibitory synaptic strength. In the region of parameter space
where inhibitory synaptic strength exceeds the excitatory synaptic strength and
for moderate noise magnitudes networks feature intermittent switches between
oscillatory and quiescent states with characteristics similar to those of
synchronous and asynchronous cortical states, respectively. We explain these
oscillatory and quiescent patterns by combining a phenomenological global
description of the network state with local descriptions of individual neurons
in their partial phase spaces. Our results point to a bridge from events at the
molecular scale of synapses to the cellular scale of individual neurons to the
collective scale of neuronal populations.
-
Many animal groups are heterogeneous and may even consist of individuals of
different species, called mixed-species flocks. Mathematical and computational
models of collective animal movement behaviour, however, typically assume that
groups and populations consist of identical individuals. In this paper, using
the mathematical framework of the coagulation-fragmentation process, we develop
and analyse a model of merge and split group dynamics, also called
fission-fusion dynamics, for heterogeneous populations that contain two types
(or species) of individuals. We assume that more heterogeneous groups
experience higher split rates than homogeneous groups, forming two daughter
groups whose compositions are drawn uniformly from all possible partitions. We
analytically derive a master equation for group size and compositions and find
mean-field steady-state solutions. We predict that there is a critical group
size below which groups are more likely to be homogeneous and contain the
abundant type/species. Despite the propensity of heterogeneous groups to split
at higher rates, we find that groups are more likely to be heterogeneous but
only above the critical group size. Monte-Carlo simulation of the model show
excellent agreement with these analytical model results. Thus, our model makes
a testable prediction that composition of flocks are group-size dependent and
do not merely reflect the population level heterogeneity. We discuss the
implications of our results to empirical studies on flocking systems.
-
The theory of cointegration has been a leading theory in econometrics with
powerful applications to macroeconomics during the last decades. On the other
hand the theory of phase synchronization for weakly coupled complex oscillators
has been one of the leading theories in physics for many years with many
applications to different areas of science. For example, in neuroscience phase
synchronization is regarded as essential for functional coupling of different
brain regions. In an abstract sense both theories describe the dynamic
fluctuation around some equilibrium. In this paper, we point out that there
exists a very close connection between both theories. Apart from phase jumps, a
stochastic version of the Kuramoto equations can be approximated by a
cointegrated system of difference equations. As one consequence, the rich
theory on statistical inference for cointegrated systems can immediately be
applied for statistical inference on phase synchronization based on empirical
data. This includes tests for phase synchronization, tests for unidirectional
coupling and the identification of the equilibrium from data including phase
shifts. We study two examples on a unidirectionally coupled R\"ossler-Lorenz
system and on electrochemical oscillators. The methods from cointegration may
also be used to investigate phase synchronization in complex networks.
Conversely, there are many interesting results on phase synchronization which
may inspire new research on cointegration.