
This Report summarizes the results of the activities of the LHC Higgs Cross
Section Working Group in the period 20142016. The main goal of the working
group was to present the stateoftheart of Higgs physics at the LHC,
integrating all new results that have appeared in the last few years. The first
part compiles the most uptodate predictions of Higgs boson production cross
sections and decay branching ratios, parton distribution functions, and
offshell Higgs boson production and interference effects. The second part
discusses the recent progress in Higgs effective field theory predictions,
followed by the third part on pseudoobservables, simplified template cross
section and fiducial cross section measurements, which give the baseline
framework for Higgs boson property measurements. The fourth part deals with the
beyond the Standard Model predictions of various benchmark scenarios of Minimal
Supersymmetric Standard Model, extended scalar sector, NexttoMinimal
Supersymmetric Standard Model and exotic Higgs boson decays. This report
follows three previous workinggroup reports: Handbook of LHC Higgs Cross
Sections: 1. Inclusive Observables (CERN2011002), Handbook of LHC Higgs Cross
Sections: 2. Differential Distributions (CERN2012002), and Handbook of LHC
Higgs Cross Sections: 3. Higgs properties (CERN2013004). The current report
serves as the baseline reference for Higgs physics in LHC Run 2 and beyond.

We calculate the corrections to the Higgs mass in general theories restricted
to the case of massless gauge bosons (the gaugeless limit). We present analytic
expressions for the twoloop tadpole diagrams, and corresponding expressions
for the zeromomentum limit of the Higgs self energies, equivalent to the
second derivative of the twoloop effective potential. We describe the
implementation in SARAH, which allows an efficient, accurate and rapid
evaluation for generic theories. In the appendix, we provide the expressions
for tadpole diagrams in the case of massive gauge bosons.

Taking the supersymmetric inverse seesaw mechanism as the explanation for
neutrino oscillation data, we investigate charged lepton flavor violation in
radiative and 3body lepton decays as well as in neutrinoless $\mue$
conversion in muonic atoms. In contrast to former studies, we take into account
all possible contributions: supersymmetric as well as nonsupersymmetric. We
take CMSSMlike boundary conditions for the soft supersymmetry breaking
parameters. We find several regions where cancellations between various
contributions exist, reducing the lepton flavor violating rates by an order of
magnitude compared to the case where only the dominant contribution is taken
into account. This is in particular important for the correct interpretation of
existing data as well as for estimating the reach of near future experiments
where the sensitivity will be improved by one to two orders of magnitude.
Moreover, we demonstrate that ratios like BR($\tau\to 3 \mu$)/BR($\tau\to \mu
e^+ e^$) can be used to determine whether the supersymmetric contributions
dominate over the $W^\pm$ and $H^\pm$ contributions or vice versa.

In order to accommodate the observed Higgs boson mass in the CMSSM, the stops
must either be very heavy or the mixing in the stop sector must be very large.
Lower stop masses, possibly more accessible at the LHC, still give the correct
Higgs mass only if the trilinear stop mixing parameter $A_t$ is in the
multiTeV range. Recently it has been shown that such large stop mixing leads
to an unstable electroweak vacuum which spontaneously breaks charge or colour.
In this work we therefore go beyond the CMSSM and investigate the effects of
including baryon number violating operators $\lambda'' \bar{\bf U} \bar{\bf
D}\bar{\bf D}$ on the stop and Higgs sectors. We find that for $\lambda''
\simeq {\mathcal{O}}(0.3)$ light stop masses as low as 220 GeV are consistent
with the observed Higgs mass as well as flavour constraints while allowing for
a stable vacuum. The light stop in this scenario is often the lightest
supersymmetric particle. We furthermore discuss the importance of the oneloop
corrections involving Rparity violating couplings for a valid prediction of
the light stop masses.

We reevaluate the constraints on the parameter space of the minimal
supersymmetric standard model from tunneling to charge and/or colorbreaking
minima, taking into account thermal corrections. We pay particular attention to
the region known as the Natural MSSM, where the masses of the scalar partners
of the top quarks are within an order of magnitude or so of the electroweak
scale. These constraints arise from the interaction between these scalar tops
and the Higgs fields, which allows the possibility of parameter points having
deep charge and colorbreaking true vacua. In addition to requiring that our
electroweaksymmetrybreaking, yet QCD and electromagnetismpreserving vacuum
has a sufficiently long lifetime at zero temperature, also demanding stability
against thermal tunneling further restricts the allowed parameter space.

We examine the possibilities for constructing models with Dirac gaugino
masses and unification of gauge couplings. We identify one promising model, and
discuss to what extent it can have a "natural SUSY" spectrum. We then determine
the lowenergy constraints upon it, and propose a constrained set of boundary
conditions at the unification scale. We describe the implementation of these
boundary conditions in the spectrumgenerator generator \SARAH and we perform a
first exploration of the parameter space, specifically searching for points
where the spectrum is relatively light. It is shown that the pattern of the
masses of SUSY states is very different compared to any expectations from the
constrained MSSM.

The recent discovery of a Higgs boson by the LHC experiments has profound
implications for supersymmetric models. In particular, in the context of
restricted models, such as the supergravityinspired constrained minimal
supersymmetric standard model, one finds that preferred regions in parameter
space have large soft supersymmetrybreaking trilinear couplings. This
potentially gives rise to charge and/or colorbreaking minima besides those
with the correct breaking of $SU(2)_L \times U(1)_Y$. We investigate the
stability of parameter points in this model against tunneling to possible
deeper color and/or chargebreaking minima of the oneloop effective
potential. We find that allowed regions of the parameter space with light staus
or with light stops are seriously constrained by the requirement that the
tunneling time out of the normal electroweaksymmetrybreaking vacuum is more
than a fifth of the age of the known Universe. We also find that "thumb rule"
conditions on Lagrangian parameters based on specific directions in the
treelevel potential are of limited use.

The existence of multiple nonequivalent minima of the scalar potential in
SUSY models both raises technical challenges and introduces interesting
physics. The technical challenges are now that one has to find several minima
and evaluate which is the deepest, as well as calculate the tunneling time from
a false vacuum to the true vacuum. We present here studies on the vacuum
stability and color/charge breaking minima in the CMSSM and R parity violating
minima in a BL extended MSSM.

Several extensions of the Standard Model of particle physics contain
additional scalars implying a more complex scalar potential compared to that of
the Standard Model. In general these potentials allow for charge and/or color
breaking minima besides the desired one with correctly broken SU(2)_L times
U(1)_Y . Even if one assumes that a metastable local minimum is realized, one
has to ensure that its lifetime exceeds that of our universe. We introduce a
new program called Vevacious which takes a generic expression for a oneloop
effective potential energy function and finds all the treelevel extrema, which
are then used as the starting points for gradientbased minimization of the
oneloop effective potential. The tunneling time from a given input vacuum to
the deepest minimum, if different from the input vacuum, can be calculated. The
parameter points are given as files in the SLHA format (though is not
restricted to supersymmetric models), and new model files can be easily
generated automatically by the Mathematica package SARAH. This code uses
HOM4PS2 to find all the minima of the treelevel potential, PyMinuit to follow
gradients to the minima of the oneloop potential, and CosmoTransitions to
calculate tunneling times.

The recent measurements of $B_s^0 \to \mu\bar{\mu}$ decay candidates at the
LHC consistent with the standard model rate, and the improving upper limits for
$B_d^0 \to \mu\bar{\mu}$ can strongly constrain beyond the standard model
physics. For example, in supersymmetric models with broken Rparity (RpV), they
restrict the size of the new couplings. We use the combination of the public
software packages SARAH and SPheno to derive new bounds on several combinations
of Rparity violating couplings. We improve existing limits for the couplings
which open treelevel decay channels and state new limits for combinations
which induce loop contributions. This is the first study which performs a full
oneloop analysis of these observables in the context of Rparity violation. It
turns out that at oneloop despite the strong experimental limits only
combinations of Rparity violating couplings are constrained which include
third generation fermions. We compare our limits with those obtained via $B\to
X_s\gamma$ and discuss the differences.

We perform a study of the stability of Rparityconserving vacua of a
constrained version of the minimal supersymmetric model with a gauged
U(1)_{BL} which can conserve Rparity, using homotopy continuation to find all
the extrema of the treelevel potential, for which we also calculated the
oneloop corrections. While we find that a majority of the points in the
parameter space preserve Rparity, we find that a significant portion of points
which naively have phenomenologically acceptable vacua which conserve Rparity
actually have deeper vacua which break Rparity through sneutrino VEVs. We
investigate under what conditions the deeper Rparityviolating vacua appear.
We find that while previous exploratory work was broadly correct in some of its
qualitative conclusions, we disagree in detail.

We present the possibility of calculating the quark flavor changing neutral
current decays $B_{s}^0\to \ell \bar \ell$ and $B_{d}^0\to \ell \bar \ell$ for
a large variety of supersymmetric models. For this purpose, the complete
oneloop calculation has been implemented in a generic form in the Mathematica
package SARAH. This information is used by SARAH to generate Fortran source
code for SPheno for a numerical evaluation of these processes in a given model.
We comment also on the possibility to use this setup for nonsupersymmetric
models.

We study the possible LHC collider signatures in the nexttominimal
supersymmetric Standard Model (NMSSM). The general NMSSM consists of 29
supersymmetric (SUSY) particles which can be mass ordered in $29! \simeq 9
\cdot 10^{30}$ ways. To reduce the number of hierarchies to a more manageable
amount we assume a degeneracy of the sfermions of the first two generations
with the same quantum numbers. Further assumptions about the neutralino and
chargino masses leave 15 unrelated parameters. We check all $15! \approx
10^{12}$ relevant mass orderings for the dominant decay chains and the
corresponding collider signatures at the LHC. As preferred signatures, we
consider charged leptons, missing transverse momentum, jets, and W, Z or Higgs
bosons. We present the results for three different choices of the singlet to
Higgs coupling $\lambda$: (a) small: $O(\lambda)< O(Y_{\tau})$, (b) large:
$O(\lambda)\simeq O(Y_{top},Y_b, Y_\tau)$ and (c) dominant:
$O(\lambda)>O(Y_{top})$. We compare these three scenarios with the MSSM
expectations as well as among each other. We also mention a possible mass
hierarchy leading to 7 jets plus 1 lepton signatures at the LHC and comment
briefly on the consequence of possible Rparity violation.

SARAH is a Mathematica package for building and analyzing supersymmetric
models. SARAH just needs the gauge structure, particle content and
superpotential to produce all information about the gauge eigenstates of a
model. Breaking of gauge symmetries and mixings of particles can easily be in a
second step and entire Lagrangian is derived automatically. Also the gauge
fixing terms are derived by SARAH in R_Xi gauge, and the corresponding ghost
interactions are calculated. Using this information, SARAH can calculate the
all mass matrices, tadpole equations and vertices at treelevel for the given
model. In addition, the expressions for the 1 and 2loop renormalization group
equations of all parameters can be calculated and an automatic calculation for
the 1loop corrections to self energies and the tadpoles are possible.
SARAH can write all information about the model to LaTeX files, or create a
model files for FeynArts/FormCalc, WHIZARD/OMEGA and CalcHep/CompHep, which can
also be used for dark matter studies using MicrOmegas, and in the UFO format
which is supported by MadGraph 5. Beginning with version 3, SARAH is also the
first available spectrumgeneratorgenerator: based on the derived, analytical
expression it creates source code for SPheno to calculate the mass spectrum as
well the SUSY decays with high precision. In that way, it is possible to
implement new models in SPheno without the need to write any Fortran code by
hand. Already many models beyond the MSSM are included in the public version of
SARAH and the implementation of new models is easy and straightforward.

We present the possible signatures appearing in general realizations of the
MSSM based on 14 unrelated mass parameters at the SUSY scale. The parameters of
the general MSSM are reduced by assuming a degeneracy of the sfermions of the
first two generations with the same quantum numbers. We also assume no
masssplitting between neutral and charged Higgsinos. We do allow for separate
soft breaking terms for the third generation sfermons. We consider all possible
resulting $14! \approx 9 \cdot10^{10}$ relevant mass orderings and check for
the dominant decay cascades and the corresponding collider signatures. In
determining the dominant decay modes we assume that mixing between sparticles
is subdominant. As preferred signatures, we consider charged leptons, missing
transverse momentum, jets, and $W, Z$ or Higgs bosons. We include also the
cases of bi and trilinear Rparity violation and show that specific signatures
can be used to distinguish the different scenarios.

Lepton flavor violation (LFV) has been observed in neutrino oscillations. For
charged lepton FV decays only upper limits are known, but sizable branching
ratios are expected in many neutrino mass models. High scale models, such as
the classical supersymmetric seesaw, usually predict that decays $l_i \to 3
l_j$ are roughly a factor $\alpha$ maller than the corresponding decays $l_i
\to l_j \gamma$. Here we demonstrate that the $Z^0$penguin diagram can give an
enhancement for decays $l_i \to 3 l_j$ in many extensions of the MSSM. We first
discuss why the $Z^0$penguin is not dominant in the MSSM with seesaw and show
that much larger contributions from the $Z^0$penguin are expected in general.
We then demonstrate the effect numerically in two example models, namely, the
supersymmetric inverse seesaw and Rparity violating supersymmetry.

The SUSY Les Houches Accord (SLHA) 2 extended the first SLHA to include
various generalisations of the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM) as
well as its simplest nexttominimal version. Here, we propose further
extensions to it, to include the most general and wellestablished seesaw
descriptions (types I/II/III, inverse, and linear) in both an effective and a
simple gauged extension of the MSSM framework. In addition, we generalise the
PDG numbering scheme to reflect the properties of the particles.

Many extensions of the leptonic sector of the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard
Model (MSSM) are known, most of them leading to observable flavor violating
effects. It has been recently shown that the 1loop contributions to lepton
flavor violating threebody decays $l_i \to 3 l_j$ involving the $Z^0$ boson
may be dominant, that is, much more important than the usual photonic penguins.
Other processes like $\mu$$e$ conversion in nuclei and flavor violating $\tau$
decays into mesons are also enhanced by the same effect. This is for instance
also the case in the MSSM with trilinear Rparity violation. The aim of this
work is to derive new bounds on the relevant combinations of Rparity violating
couplings and to compare them with previous results in the literature. For
heavy supersymmetric spectra the limits are improved by several orders of
magnitude. For completeness, also constraints coming from flavor violating
$Z^0$decays and treelevel decay channels $l \to l_i l_j l_k$ are presented
for a set of benchmark points.

We present the activities of the "New Physics" working group for the "Physics
at TeV Colliders" workshop (Les Houches, France, 30 May17 June, 2011). Our
report includes new agreements on formats for interfaces between computational
tools, new tool developments, important signatures for searches at the LHC,
recommendations for presentation of LHC search results, as well as additional
phenomenological studies.

Leftright symmetric extensions of the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model
can explain neutrino data and have potentially interesting phenomenology beyond
that found in minimal SUSY seesaw models. Here we study a SUSY model in which
the leftright symmetry is broken by triplets at a high scale, but
significantly below the GUT scale. Sparticle spectra in this model differ from
the usual constrained MSSM expectations and these changes affect the relic
abundance of the lightest neutralino. We discuss changes for the standard stau
(and stop) coannihilation, the Higgs funnel and the focus point regions. The
model has potentially large lepton flavour violation in both, left and right,
scalar leptons and thus allows, in principle, also for flavoured
coannihilation. We also discuss lepton flavour signals due to violating decays
of the second lightest neutralino at the LHC, which can be as large as 20
fb$^{1}$ at $\sqrt{s}=14$ TeV.

We describe recent extensions of the program SPheno including flavour
aspects, CPphases, Rparity violation and low energy observables. In case of
flavour mixing all masses of supersymmetric particles are calculated including
the complete flavour structure and all possible CPphases at the 1loop level.
We give details on implemented seesaw models, low energy observables and the
corresponding extension of the SUSY Les Houches Accord. Moreover, we comment on
the possiblities to include MSSM extensions in SPheno.

We study a supersymmetric version of the seesaw mechanism typeIII. The model
consists of the MSSM particle content plus three copies of 24 superfields. The
fermionic part of the SU(2) triplet contained in the 24 is responsible for the
typeIII seesaw, which is used to explain the observed neutrino masses and
mixings. Complete copies of 24 are introduced to maintain gauge coupling
unification. These additional states change the beta functions of the gauge
couplings above the seesaw scale. Using mSUGRA boundary conditions we calculate
the resulting supersymmetric mass spectra at the electroweak scale using full
2loop renormalization group equations. We show that the resulting spectrum can
be quite different compared to the usual mSUGRA spectrum. We discuss how this
might be used to obtain information on the seesaw scale from mass measurements.
Constraints on the model space due to limits on lepton flavour violating decays
are discussed. The main constraints come from the bounds on the decay mu to e
and gamma but there are also regions where the decay tau to mu and gamma gives
stronger constraints. We also calculate the regions allowed by the dark matter
constraint. For the sake of completeness, we compare our results with those for
the supersymmetric seesaw typeII and, to some extent, with typeI.

We study the phenomenology of a supersymmetric leftright model, assuming
minimal supergravity boundary conditions. Both leftright and (BL) symmetries
are broken at an energy scale close to, but significantly below the GUT scale.
Neutrino data is explained via a seesaw mechanism. We calculate the RGEs for
superpotential and soft parameters complete at 2loop order. At low energies
lepton flavour violation (LFV) and small, but potentially measurable mass
splittings in the charged scalar lepton sector appear, due to the RGE running.
Different from the supersymmetric 'pure seesaw' models, both, LFV and slepton
mass splittings, occur not only in the left but also in the right slepton
sector. Especially, ratios of LFV slepton decays, such as Br(${\tilde\tau}_R
\to \mu \chi^0_1$)/Br(${\tilde\tau}_L \to \mu \chi^0_1$) are sensitive to the
ratio of (BL) and leftright symmetry breaking scales. Also the model predicts
a polarization asymmetry of the outgoing positrons in the decay $\mu^+ \to e^+
\gamma$, A ~ [0,1], which differs from the pure seesaw 'prediction' A=1$.
Observation of any of these signals allows to distinguish this model from any
of the three standard, pure (mSugra) seesaw setups.

We reconsider the dark matter problem in supersymmetric models with gauge
mediated supersymmetry breaking, with and without Rparity breaking. In these
classes of models, a light gravitino forms the dark matter.Consistency with the
experimental data, in particular the dark matter abundance and the smallscale
power spectrum, requires additional entropy production after the decoupling of
the gravitino from the thermal bath. We demonstrate that the usual mechanism
via messenger number violating interactions does not work in models where the
messenger belongs to SU (5) representations. This is mainly a consequence of
two facts: (i) there are at least two different types of lightest messenger
particles and (ii) the lightest messenger particle with SU (2) quantum numbers
decays dominantly into vector bosons once messenger number is broken, a feature
which has been overlooked so far. In case of SO(10) messenger multiplets we
find scenarios which work if the SM gauge singlet component is rather light.