-
The Kilo-Degree Survey (KiDS) has been used in several recent papers to infer
constraints on the amplitude of the matter power spectrum and matter density at
low redshift. Some of these analyses have claimed tension with the Planck
$\Lambda \mathrm{CDM}$ cosmology at the $\sim 2-3\sigma$ level, perhaps
indicative of new physics. However, Planck is consistent with other low
redshift probes of the matter power spectrum such as redshift space distortions
and the combined galaxy-mass and galaxy-galaxy power spectra. Here we perform
consistency tests of the KiDS data, finding internal tensions for various cuts
of the data at $\sim 2.2 - 3.5\sigma$ significance. Until these internal
tensions are understood, we argue that it is premature to claim evidence for
new physics from KiDS. We review the consistency between KiDS and other weak
lensing measurements of $S_8$, highlighting the importance of intrinsic
alignments for precision cosmology.
-
We derive constraints on feedback by active galactic nuclei (AGN) by setting
limits on their thermal Sunyaev-Zel'dovich (SZ) imprint on the cosmic microwave
background (CMB). The amplitude of any SZ signature is small and degenerate
with the poorly known sub-mm spectral energy distribution of the AGN host
galaxy and other unresolved dusty sources along the line of sight. Here we
break this degeneracy by combining microwave and sub-mm data from Planck with
all-sky far-infrared maps from the AKARI satellite. We first test our
measurement pipeline using the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) redMaPPer
catalogue of galaxy clusters, finding a highly significant detection
($>$$20\sigma$) of the SZ effect together with correlated dust emission. We
then constrain the SZ signal associated with spectroscopically confirmed
quasi-stellar objects (QSOs) from SDSS data release 7 (DR7) and the Baryon
Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey (BOSS) DR12. We obtain a low-significance
($1.6\sigma$) hint of an SZ signal, pointing towards a mean thermal energy of
$\simeq 5 \times 10^{60}$ erg, lower than reported in some previous studies. A
comparison of our results with high-resolution hydrodynamical simulations
including AGN feedback suggests QSO host masses of $M_{200c} \sim 4 \times
10^{12}~h^{-1}M_\odot$, but with a large uncertainty. Our analysis provides no
conclusive evidence for an SZ signal specifically associated with AGN feedback.
-
We review the effect of the commonly-used Limber and flat-sky approximations
on the calculation of shear power spectra and correlation functions for galaxy
weak lensing. These approximations are accurate at small scales, but it has
been claimed recently that their impact on low multipoles could lead to an
increase in the amplitude of the mass fluctuations inferred from surveys such
as CFHTLenS, reducing the tension between galaxy weak lensing and the amplitude
determined by Planck from observations of the cosmic microwave background.
Here, we explore the impact of these approximations on cosmological parameters
derived from weak lensing surveys, using the CFHTLenS data as a test case. We
conclude that the use of small-angle approximations for cosmological parameter
estimation is negligible for current data, and does not contribute to the
tension between current weak lensing surveys and Planck.
-
We present new measurements of the power spectra of the cosmic infrared
background (CIB) anisotropies using the Planck 2015 full-mission HFI data at
353, 545, and 857 GHz over 20000 square degrees. We use techniques similar to
those applied for the cosmological analysis of Planck, subtracting dust
emission at the power spectrum level. Our analysis gives stable solutions for
the CIB power spectra with increasing sky coverage up to about 50% of the sky.
These spectra agree well with Hi cleaned spectra from Planck measured on much
smaller areas of sky with low Galactic dust emission. At 545 and 857 GHz our
CIB spectra agree well with those measured from Herschel data. We find that the
CIB spectra at l > 500 are well fitted by a power-law model for the clustered
CIB, with a shallow index {\gamma}^cib = 0.53\pm0.02. This is consistent with
the CIB results at 217 GHz from the cosmological parameter analysis of Planck.
We show that a linear combination of the 545 and 857 GHz Planck maps is
dominated by CIB fluctuations at multipoles l > 300.
-
Statistical isotropy is often assumed in cosmology and should be tested
rigorously against observational data. We construct simple quadratic estimators
to reconstruct asymmetry in the primordial power spectrum from CMB temperature
and polarization data and verify their accuracy using simulations with
quadrupole power asymmetry. We show that the Planck mission, with its millions
of signal-dominated modes of the temperature anisotropy, should be able to
constrain the amplitude of any spherical multipole of a scale-invariant
quadrupole asymmetry at the $0.01$ level ($2\sigma$). Almost independent
constraints can be obtained from polarization at the $0.03$ level after four
full-sky surveys, providing an important consistency test. If the amplitude of
the asymmetry is large enough, constraining its scale-dependence should become
possible. In scale-free quadrupole models with $1\%$ asymmetry, consistent with
the current limits from WMAP temperature data (after correction for beam
asymmetries), Planck should constrain the spectral index $q$ of power-law
departures from asymmetry to $\Delta q = 0.3$. Finally, we show how to
constrain models with axisymmetry in the same framework. For scale-free
quadrupole models, Planck should constrain the direction of the asymmetry to a
$1\sigma$ accuracy of about $2$ degrees using one year of temperature data.
-
I reanalyse the Riess et al. (2011, hereafter R11) Cepheid data using the
revised geometric maser distance to NGC 4258 of Humphreys et al. (2013). I
explore different outlier rejection criteria designed to give a reduced
chi-squared of unity and compare the results with the R11 rejection algorithm,
which produces a reduced chi-squared that is substantially less than unity and,
in some cases, to underestimates of the errors on parameters. I show that there
are sub-luminous low metallicity Cepheids in the R11 sample that skew the
global fits of the period-luminosity relation. This has a small but
non-negligible impact on the global fits using NGC 4258 as a distance scale
anchor, but adds a poorly constrained source of systematic error when using the
Large Magellanic Cloud (LMC) as an anchor. I also show that the small Milky Way
(MW) Cepheid sample with accurate parallax measurements leads to a distance to
NGC 4258 that is in tension with the maser distance. I conclude that H0 based
on the NGC 4258 maser distance is H0 = 70.6 +/- 3.3 km/s/Mpc compatible within
1 sigma with the recent determination from Planck for the base six-parameter
LCDM cosmology. If the H-band period-luminosity relation is assumed to be
independent of metallicity and the three distance anchors are combined, I find
H0 = 72.5 +/- 2.5 km/s/Mpc, which differs by 1.9 sigma from the Planck value.
The differences between the Planck results and these estimates of H0 are not
large enough to provide compelling evidence for new physics at this stage.
-
The Arcminute Microkelvin Imager (AMI) is a telescope specifically designed
for high sensitivity measurements of low-surface-brightness features at
cm-wavelength and has unique, important capabilities. It consists of two
interferometer arrays operating over 13.5-18 GHz that image structures on
scales of 0.5-10 arcmin with very low systematics. The Small Array (AMI-SA; ten
3.7-m antennas) couples very well to Sunyaev-Zel'dovich features from galaxy
clusters and to many Galactic features. The Large Array (AMI-LA; eight 13-m
antennas) has a collecting area ten times that of the AMI-SA and longer
baselines, crucially allowing the removal of the effects of confusing radio
point sources from regions of low surface-brightness, extended emission.
Moreover AMI provides fast, deep object surveying and allows monitoring of
large numbers of objects. In this White Paper we review the new science - both
Galactic and extragalactic - already achieved with AMI and outline the
prospects for much more.
-
We develop a model for the power spectrum of unresolved clusters of galaxies
arising from the thermal Sunyaev-Zeldovich (tSZ) effect. The model is based on
a'universal' gas pressure profile constrained by X-ray observations and
includes a parameter to describe departures from self-similar evolution. The
model is consistent with recent Planck observations of the tSZ effect for X-ray
clusters with redshifts z<1 and reproduces the low amplitude for the tSZ
inferred from recent ground based observations. By adjusting two free
parameters, we are able to reproduce the tSZ power spectra from recent
numerical simulations to an accuracy that is well within theoretical
uncertainties. Our model provides a simple, empirically motivated tSZ template
that may be useful for the analysis of new experiments such as Planck.
-
We study reconstruction of the lensing potential power spectrum from CMB
temperature data, with an eye to the Planck experiment. We work with the
optimal quadratic estimator of Okamoto and Hu, which we characterize thoroughly
in application to reconstruction of the lensing power spectrum. We find that at
multipoles L<250 our current understanding of this estimator is biased at the
15% level by beyond-gradient terms in the Taylor expansion of lensing effects.
We present the full lensed trispectrum to fourth order in the lensing potential
to explain this effect. We show that the low-L bias, as well as a previously
known bias at high-L, is relevant to the determination of cosmology and must be
corrected for in order to avoid significant parameter errors. We also
investigate the covariance of the reconstructed power, finding broad
correlations of ~0.1%. Finally, we discuss several small improvements which may
be made to the optimal estimator to mitigate these problems.
-
A large sub-mm survey with Herschel will enable many exciting science
opportunities, especially in an era of wide-field optical and radio surveys and
high resolution cosmic microwave background experiments. The Herschel-SPIRE
Legacy Survey (HSLS), will lead to imaging data over 4000 sq. degrees at 250,
350, and 500 micron. Major Goals of HSLS are: (a) produce a catalog of 2.5 to 3
million galaxies down to 26, 27 and 33 mJy (50% completeness; 5 sigma confusion
noise) at 250, 350 and 500 micron, respectively, in the southern hemisphere
(3000 sq. degrees) and in an equatorial strip (1000 sq. degrees), areas which
have extensive multi-wavelength coverage and are easily accessible from ALMA.
Two thirds of the of the sources are expected to be at z > 1, one third at z >
2 and about a 1000 at z > 5. (b) Remove point source confusion in secondary
anisotropy studies with Planck and ground-based CMB data. (c) Find at least
1200 strongly lensed bright sub-mm sources leading to a 2% test of general
relativity. (d) Identify 200 proto-cluster regions at z of 2 and perform an
unbiased study of the environmental dependence of star formation. (e) Perform
an unbiased survey for star formation and dust at high Galactic latitude and
make a census of debris disks and dust around AGB stars and white dwarfs.
-
It has been argued recently by Copi etal (2009) that the lack of large
angular correlations of the CMB temperature field provides strong evidence
against the standard, statistically isotropic, inflationary LambdaCDM
cosmology. We compare various estimators of the temperature correlation
function showing how they depend on assumptions of statistical isotropy and how
they perform on the WMAP 5 year ILC maps with and without a sky cut. We show
that the low multipole harmonics that determine the large-scale features of the
temperature correlation function can be reconstructed accurately, independent
of any assumptions concerning statistical isotropy, from the data that lie
outside the sky cuts. The temperature correlation functions computed from our
reconstructions are in good agreement with those computed from the whole sky. A
Bayesian analysis of the large-scale correlations is presented which shows that
the data cannot exclude the standard LambdaCDM model. We discuss the
differences between our conclusions and those of Copi et al.
-
The Planck satellite has a nominal mission lifetime of 14 months allowing two
complete surveys of the sky. Here we investigate the potential of an extended
Planck mission of four sky surveys to constrain primordial B-mode anisotropies
in the presence of dominant Galactic polarized foreground emission. An extended
Planck mission is capable of powerful constraints on primordial B-modes at low
multipoles, which cannot be probed by ground based or sub-orbital experiments.
A tensor-scalar ratio of r=0.05 can be detected at a high significance level by
an extended Planck mission and it should be possible to set a 95% upper limit
on r of 0.03 if the tensor-scalar ratio is vanishingly small. Furthermore,
extending the Planck mission to four sky surveys offers better control of
polarized Galactic dust emission, since the 217 GHz frequency band can be used
as an effective dust template in addition to the 353 GHz channel.
-
We use a model of polarized Galactic emission developed by the the Planck
collaboration to assess the impact of foregrounds on B-mode detection at low
multipoles. Our main interest is to applications of noisy polarization data and
in particular to assessing the feasibility of B-mode detection by Planck. This
limits the complexity of foreground subtraction techniques that can be applied
to the data. We analyze internal linear combination techniques and show that
the offset caused by the dominant E-mode polarization pattern leads to a
fundamental limit of r approximately 0.1 for the tensor-scalar ratio even in
the absence of instrumental noise. We devise a simple, robust, template fitting
technique using multi-frequency polarization maps. We show that template
fitting using Planck data alone offers a feasible way of recovering primordial
B-modes from dominant foreground contamination, even in the presence of noise
on the data and templates. We implement and test a pixel-based scheme for
computing the likelihood function of cosmological parameters at low multipoles
that incorporates foreground subtraction of noisy data.
-
Many ambitious experiments have been proposed to constrain dark energy and
detect its evolution. At present, observational constraints are consistent with
a cosmological constant and there is no firm evidence for any evolution in the
dark energy equation of state w. In this paper, we pose the following question:
suppose that future dark energy surveys constrain w at low redshift to be
consistent with -1 to a percent level accuracy, what are the implications for
models of dynamical dark energy? We investigate this problem in a
model-independent way by following quintessence field trajectories in `energy'
phase-space. Attractor dynamics in this phase-space leads to two classes of
acceptable models: 1) models with flat potentials, i.e. an effective
cosmological constant, and 2) models with potentials that suddenly flatten with
a characteristic kink. The prospect of further constraining the second class of
models from distance measurements and fluctuation growth rates at low redshift
(z<3) seems poor. However, in some models of this second class, the dark energy
makes a significant contribution to the total energy density at high redshift.
Such models can be further constrained from observation of the cosmic microwave
background anisotropies and from primordial nucleosynthesis. It is possible,
therefore, to construct models in which the dark energy at high redshift causes
observable effects, even if future dark energy surveys constrain w at low
redshift to be consistent with -1 to high precision.
-
We present a dynamical analysis of the inflationary flow equations. Our
technique uses the Hubble `jerk' parameter as a discriminant of stability of
fixed points. The results of the analysis are used to explain qualitatively the
distribution of various observable parameters (e.g. the tensor-scalar ratio, r,
and scalar spectral index, n_s) seen in numerical solutions of the flow
equations using stochastic initial conditions. Finally, we give a physical
interpretation of the flow in phase-space in terms of slow-roll motion of the
inflaton.
-
This article is the written version of the closing talk presented at the
conference `A Century of Cosmology' held at San Servolo, Italy, in August 2007.
I focus on the prospects of constraining fundamental physics from cosmological
observations, using the search for gravitational waves from inflation and
constraints on the equation of state of dark energy as topical examples. I
argue that it is important to strike a balance between the importance of a
scientific discovery against the likelihood of making the discovery in the
first place. Astronomers should be wary of embarking on large observational
projects with narrow and speculative scientific goals. We should maintain a
diverse range of research programmes as we move into a second century of
cosmology. If we do so, discoveries that will reshape fundamental physics will
surely come.
-
In this paper we investigate how well Planck and Lyman-Alpha forest data will
be able to constrain the sum of the neutrino masses, and thus, in conjunction
with flavour oscillation experiments, be able to determine the absolute masses
of the neutrinos. It seems possible that Planck, together with a Lyman-Alpha
survey, will be able to put pressure on an inverted hierarchial model for the
neutrino masses. However, even for optimistic assumptions of the precision of
future Lyman-Alpha datasets, it will not be possible to confirm a minimal-mass
normal hierarchy.
-
We investigate the accuracy of the slow-roll approximation for calculating
perturbation spectra generated during inflation. The Hamilton-Jacobi formalism
is used to evolve inflationary models with different histories. Models are
identified for which the scalar power spectra computed using the Stewart-Lyth
slow-roll approximation differ from exact numerical calculations using the
Mukhanov perturbation equation. We then revisit the problem of primordial black
holes generated by inflation. Hybrid-type inflationary models, in which the
inflaton is trapped in the minimum of a potential, can produce blue power
spectra and an observable abundance of primordial black holes. However, this
type of model can now be firmly excluded from observational constraints on the
scalar spectral index on cosmological scales. We argue that significant
primordial black hole formation in simple inflation models requires contrived
potentials in which there is a period of fast roll towards the end of
inflation. For this type of model, the Stewart-Lyth formalism breaks down.
Examples of such inflationary models and numerical computations of their scalar
fluctuation spectra are presented.
-
We describe high resolution Smoothed Particle Hydrodynamics (SPH) simulations
of three approximately $M_*$ field galaxies starting from \LCDM initial
conditions. The simulations are made intentionally simple, and include
photoionization, cooling of the intergalactic medium, and star formation but
not feedback from AGN or supernovae. All of the galaxies undergo an initial
burst of star formation at $z \approx 5$, accompanied by the formation of a
bubble of heated gas. Two out of three galaxies show early-type properties at
present whereas only one of them experienced a major merger. Heating from
shocks and -PdV work dominates over cooling so that for most of the gas the
temperature is an increasing function of time. By $z \approx 1$ a significant
fraction of the final stellar mass is in place and the spectral energy
distribution resembles those of observed massive red galaxies. The galaxies
have grown from $z=1 \to 0$ on average by 25% in mass and in size by gas poor
(dry) stellar mergers. By the present day, the simulated galaxies are old
($\approx 10 {\rm Gyrs}$), kinematically hot stellar systems surrounded by hot
gaseous haloes. Stars dominate the mass of the galaxies up to $\approx 4$
effective radii ($\approx 10$ kpc). Kinematic and most photometric properties
are in good agreement with those of observed elliptical galaxies. The galaxy
with a major merger develops a counter-rotating core. Our simulations show that
realistic intermediate mass giant elliptical galaxies with plausible formation
histories can be formed from \LCDM initial conditions even without requiring
recent major mergers or feedback from supernovae or AGN.
-
ESO and ESA agreed to establish a number of Working Groups to explore
possible synergies between these two major European astronomical institutions.
This Working Group's mandate was to concentrate on fundamental questions in
cosmology, and the scope for tackling these in Europe over the next ~15 years.
One major resulting recommendation concerns the provision of new generations of
imaging survey, where the image quality and near-IR sensitivity that can be
attained only in space are naturally matched by ground-based imaging and
spectroscopy to yield massive datasets with well-understood photometric
redshifts (photo-z's). Such information is essential for a range of new
cosmological tests using gravitational lensing, large-scale structure, clusters
of galaxies, and supernovae. Great scope in future cosmology also exists for
ELT studies of the intergalactic medium and space-based studies of the CMB and
gravitational waves; here the synergy is less direct, but these areas will
remain of the highest mutual interest to the agencies. All these recommended
facilities will produce vast datasets of general applicability, which will have
a tremendous impact on broad areas of astronomy.
-
We study the primordial gravitational wave background produced in models of
single field inflation. Using the inflationary flow approach, we investigate
the amplitude of gravitational wave spectrum in the frequency range 1 mHz - 1
Hz pertinent to future space-based laser interferometers. For models that
satisfy the current observational constraint on the tensor-to-scalar ratio,
r<0.36, we derive a strict upper bound of omega_{gw}<1.6 x 10^{-15},
independent of the form of the inflationary potential. Applying, in addition,
the observational constraints on the spectral index and its running, omega_{gw}
is expected to be considerably lower than this bound unless the shape of the
potential is finely tuned. We contrast our numerical results with those based
on simple power-law extrapolation of the tensor power spectrum from CMB scales.
In addition to single field inflation, we summarise a number of other possible
cosmological sources of primordial gravitational waves and assess what might be
learnt from direct detection experiments such as LISA, Big Bang Observer and
beyond.
-
We review the prospects for detecting tensor modes generated during inflation
by CMB polarization experiments and by searching for a stochastic gravitational
wave background with laser interferometers in space. We tackle the following
two questions: (i) what does inflation predict for the tensor fluctuations?
(ii) is it really worth building experiments that can cover only a small range
of tensor amplitudes?
-
The ROSAT-ESO Flux Limited X-ray (REFLEX) galaxy cluster survey and the 2dF
Galaxy Redshift Survey (2dFGRS) respectively comprise the largest, homogeneous
X-ray selected cluster catalogue and completed galaxy redshift survey. In this
work we combine these two outstanding datasets in order to study the effect of
the large-scale cluster environment, as traced by X-ray luminosity, on the
properties of the cluster member galaxies. We measure the LX-sigma relation
from the correlated dataset and find it to be consistent with recent results
found in the literature. Using a sample of 19 clusters with LX>=0.36*10^44 erg
s^-1 in the (0.1-2.4 keV) band, and 49 clusters with lower X-ray luminosity, we
find that the fraction of early spectral type (eta<=-1.4), passively-evolving
galaxies is significantly higher in the high-LX sample within R200. We extend
the investigation to include composite bJ cluster luminosity functions, and
find that the characteristic magnitude of the Schechter-function fit to the
early-type luminosity function is fainter for the high-LX sample compared to
the low-LX sample (Delta M*=0.58+/-0.14). This seems to be driven by a deficit
of such galaxies with M_bJ ~ -21. In contrast, we find no significant
differences between the luminosity functions of star-forming, late-type
galaxies. We believe these results are consistent with a scenario in which the
high-LX clusters are more dynamically evolved systems than the low-LX clusters.
-
We investigate the Lyth relationship between the tensor-scalar ratio, r, and
the variation of the inflaton field, Delta phi, over the course of inflation.
For inflationary models that produce at least 55 e-folds of inflation, there is
a correlation between r and Delta phi as anticipated by Lyth, but the scatter
around the relationship is huge. However, for inflationary models that satisfy
current observational constraints on the scalar spectral index and its first
derivative, the Lyth relationship is much tighter. In particular, any
inflationary model with r > 10^-3 must have Delta phi > m_pl. Large field
variations are therefore required if a tensor mode signal is to be detected in
any foreseeable cosmic microwave background (CMB) polarization experiment.
-
We select a sample of low-redshift (z ~ 0.1) E+A galaxies from the 2dF Galaxy
Redshift Survey (2dFGRS). The spectra of these objects are defined by strong
hydrogen Balmer absorption lines (H-delta, H-gamma, H-beta) combined with a
lack of [OII] 3727A emission, together implying a recently-truncated burst of
star formation. The E+A spectrum is thus a signpost to galaxies in the process
of evolution. We quantify the local environments, clustering properties and
luminosity function of the E+A galaxies. We find that the environments are
consistent with the ensemble of 2dFGRS galaxies: low-redshift E+A systems are
located predominantly in the field, existing as isolated objects or in poor
groups. However, the luminosity distribution of galaxies selected using three
Balmer absorption lines H-delta-gamma-beta appears more typical of ellipticals.
Indeed, morphologically these galaxies are preferentially spheroidal (E/S0)
systems. In a small but significant number we find evidence for recent major
mergers, such as tidal tails. We infer that major mergers are one important
formation mechanism for E+A galaxies, as suggested by previous studies. At low
redshift the merger probability is high in the field and low in clusters, thus
these recently-formed spheroidal systems do not follow the usual
morphology-density relation for ellipticals. Regarding the selection of E+A
galaxies: we find that basing the Balmer-line criterion solely on H-delta
absorption leads to a significant sub-population of disk systems with
detectable H-alpha emission. In these objects the [OII] emission is presumably
either obscured by dust or present with a low signal-to-noise ratio, whilst the
(H-gamma, H-beta) absorption features are subject to emission-filling.