
Recent studies establish that the cuprate pseudogap phase is susceptible at
low temperatures to forming not only a $d$symmetry superconducting (SC) state,
but also a $d$symmetry form factor (dFF) density wave (DW) state. The
concurrent emergence of such distinct and unusual states from the pseudogap
motivates theories that they are "intertwined" i.e derived from a quantum
composite of dissimilar brokensymmetry orders. Some composite order theories
predict that the balance between the different components can be altered, for
example at superconducting vortex cores. Here, we introduce sublattice
phaseresolved electronic structure imaging as a function of magnetic field and
find robust dFF DW states induced at each vortex. They are predominantly
unidirectional and cooriented (nematic), exhibiting strong spatialphase
coherence. At each vortex we also detect the fieldinduced conversion of the SC
to DW components and demonstrate that this occurs at precisely the eight
momentumspace locations predicted in many composite order theories. These data
provided direct microscopic evidence for the existence of composite order in
the cuprates, and new indications of how the DW state becomes longrange
ordered in high magnetic fields.

We analyze the interplay between a dwave uniform superconducting and a
pairdensitywave (PDW) order parameter in the neighborhood of a vortex. We
develop a phenomenological nonlinear sigmamodel, solve the saddle point
equation for the order parameter configuration, and compute the resulting local
density of states in the vortex halo. The intertwining of the two
superconducting orders leads to a charge density modulation with the same
periodicity as the PDW, which is twice the period of the chargedensitywave
that arises as a secondharmonic of the PDW itself. We discuss key features of
the charge density modulation that can be directly compared with recent results
from scanning tunneling microscopy and speculate on the role PDW order may play
in the global phase diagram of the holedoped cuprates.

When very high magnetic fields suppress the superconductivity in underdoped
cuprates, an exceptional new electronic phase appears. It supports remarkable
and unexplained quantum oscillations and exhibits an unidentified density wave
(DW) state. Although generally referred to as a "charge" density wave (CDW)
because of the observed charge density modulations, theory indicates that this
could actually be the far more elusive electronpair density wave state (PDW).
To search for evidence of a fieldinduced PDW in cuprates, we visualize the
modulations in the density of electronic states $N(\bf{r})$ within the halo
surrounding Bi$_2$Sr$_2$CaCu$_2$O$_8$ vortex cores. This reveals multiple
signatures of a fieldinduced PDW, including two sets of $N(\bf{r})$
modulations occurring at wavevectors $\bf{Q}_P$ and $2\bf{Q}_P$, both having
predominantly $s$symmetry form factors, the amplitude of the latter decaying
twice as rapidly as the former, along with induced energygap modulations at
$\bf{Q}_P$ . Such a microscopic phenomenology is in detailed agreement with
theory for a fieldinduced primary PDW that generates secondary CDWs within the
vortex halo. These data indicate that the fundamental state generated by
increasing magnetic fields from the underdoped cuprate superconducting phase is
actually a PDW with approximately eight CuO$_2$ unitcell periodicity ($\lambda
= 8a_0$) and predominantly $d$symmetry form factor.

There has been growing speculation that a pair density wave state is a key
component of the phenomenology of the pseudogap phase in the cuprates.
Recently, direct evidence for such a state has emerged from an analysis of
scanning tunneling microscopy data in halos around the vortex cores. By
extrapolation, these vortex halos would then overlap at a magnetic field scale
where quantum oscillations have been observed. Here, we show that a biaxial
pair density wave state gives a unique description of the quantum oscillation
data, bolstering the case that the pseudogap phase in the cuprates may be a
pair density wave state.

Theories based upon strong real space (rspace) electron electron
interactions have long predicted that unidirectional charge density modulations
(CDM) with four unit cell (4$a_0$) periodicity should occur in the hole doped
cuprate Mott insulator (MI). Experimentally, however, increasing the hole
density p is reported to cause the conventionally defined wavevector $Q_A$ of
the CDM to evolve continuously as if driven primarily by momentum space
(kspace) effects. Here we introduce phase resolved electronic structure
visualization for determination of the cuprate CDM wavevector. Remarkably, this
new technique reveals a virtually doping independent locking of the local CDM
wavevector at $Q_0=2\pi/4a_0$ throughout the underdoped phase diagram of the
canonical cuprate $Bi_2Sr_2CaCu_2O_8$. These observations have significant
fundamental consequences because they are orthogonal to a kspace (Fermi
surface) based picture of the cuprate CDM but are consistent with strong
coupling rspace based theories. Our findings imply that it is the latter that
provide the intrinsic organizational principle for the cuprate CDM state.

The quantum condensate of Cooperpairs forming a superconductor was
originally conceived to be translationally invariant. In theory, however, pairs
can exist with finite momentum $Q$ and thereby generate states with spatially
modulating Cooperpair density. While never observed directly in any
superconductor, such a state has been created in ultracold $^{6}$Li gas. It is
now widely hypothesized that the cuprate pseudogap phase contains such a 'pair
density wave' (PDW) state. Here we use nanometer resolution scanned Josephson
tunneling microscopy (SJTM) to image Cooperpair tunneling from a $d$wave
superconducting STM tip to the condensate of
Bi$_{2}$Sr$_{2}$CaCu$_{2}$O$_{8+x}$. Condensate visualization capabilities are
demonstrated directly using the Cooperpair density variations surrounding Zn
impurity atoms and at the Bi$_{2}$Sr$_{2}$CaCu$_{2}$O$_{8+x}$
crystalsupermodulation. Then, by using Fourier analysis of SJTM images, we
discover the direct signature of a Cooperpair density modulation at
wavevectors $Q_{p} \approx (0.25,0)2\pi / a_{0}$;$(0,0.25)2\pi / a_{0}$ in
Bi$_{2}$Sr$_{2}$CaCu$_{2}$O$_{8+x}$. The amplitude of these modulations is ~5%
of the homogenous condensate density and their form factor exhibits primarily
$s$/$s'$symmetry. This phenomenology is expected within GinzburgLandau theory
when a charge density wave with $d$symmetry form factor and wave vector
$Q_{c}=Q_{p}$ coexists with a homogeneous $d$symmetry superconductor ; it is
also encompassed by several contemporary microscopic theories for the pseudogap
phase.

We demonstrate that the electronic bandstructure extracted from
quasiparticle interference spectroscopy [Nat. Phys. 9, 468 (2013)] and the
theoretically computed form of the superconducting gaps [Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci.
111, 11663 (2014)] can be used to understand the $dI/dV$ lineshape measured in
the normal and superconducting state of CeCoIn$_5$ [Nat. Phys. 9, 474 92103)].
In particular, the $dI/dV$ lineshape, and the spatial structure of
defectinduced impurity states, reflects the existence of multiple
superconducting gaps of $d_{x^2y^2}$symmetry. These results strongly support
a recently proposed microscopic origin of the unconventional superconducting
state.

Extensive research into high temperature superconducting cuprates is now
focused upon identifying the relationship between the classic 'pseudogap'
phenomenon$^{1,2}$ and the more recently investigated density wave
state$^{313}$. This state always exhibits wave vector $Q$ parallel to the
planar CuOCu bonds$^{413}$ along with a predominantly $d$symmetry form
factor$^{1417}$ (dFFDW). Finding its microscopic mechanism has now become a
key objective$^{1830}$ of this field. To accomplish this, one must identify
the momentumspace ($k$space) states contributing to the dFFDW spectral
weight, determine their particlehole phase relationship about the Fermi
energy, establish whether they exhibit a characteristic energy gap, and
understand the evolution of all these phenomena throughout the phase diagram.
Here we use energyresolved sublattice visualization$^{14}$ of electronic
structure and show that the characteristic energy of the dFFDW modulations is
actually the 'pseudogap' energy $\Delta_{1}$. Moreover, we demonstrate that the
dFFDW modulations at $E=\Delta_{1}$ (filled states) occur with relative phase
$\pi$ compared to those at $E=\Delta_{1}$ (empty states). Finally, we show that
the dFFDW $Q$ corresponds directly to scattering between the 'hot frontier'
regions of $k$space beyond which Bogoliubov quasiparticles cease to
exist$^{31,32,33}$. These data demonstrate that the dFFDW state is consistent
with particlehole interactions focused at the pseudogap energy scale and
between the four pairs of 'hot frontier' regions in $k$space where the
pseudogap opens.

Maximizing the sustainable supercurrent density, Jc, is crucial to high
current applications of superconductivity and, to achieve this, preventing
dissipative motion of quantized vortices is key. Irradiation of superconductors
with highenergy heavy ions can be used to create nanoscale defects that act as
deep pinning potentials for vortices. This approach holds unique promise for
high current applications of ironbased superconductors because Jc
amplification persists to much higher radiation doses than in cuprate
superconductors without significantly altering the superconducting critical
temperature. However, for these compounds virtually nothing is known about the
atomic scale interplay of the crystal damage from the highenergy ions, the
superconducting order parameter, and the vortex pinning processes. Here, we
visualize the atomicscale effects of irradiating FeSexTe1x with 249 MeV Au
ions and find two distinct effects: compact nanometersized regions of crystal
disruption or 'columnar defects', plus a higher density of single atomicsite
'point' defects probably from secondary scattering. We show directly that the
superconducting order is virtually annihilated within the former while
suppressed by the latter. Simultaneous atomicallyresolved images of the
columnar crystal defects, the superconductivity, and the vortex configurations,
then reveal how a mixed pinning landscape is created, with the strongest
pinning occurring at metalliccore columnar defects and secondary pinning at
clusters of pointlike defects, followed by collective pinning at higher fields.

To achieve and utilize the most exotic electronic phenomena predicted for the
surface states of 3D topological insulators (TI),it is necessary to open a
"Diracmass gap" in their spectrum by breaking timereversal symmetry. Use of
magnetic dopant atoms to generate a ferromagnetic state is the most widely used
approach. But it is unknown how the spatial arrangements of the magnetic dopant
atoms influence the Diracmass gap at the atomic scale or, conversely, whether
the ferromagnetic interactions between dopant atoms are influenced by the
topological surface states. Here we image the locations of the magnetic (Cr)
dopant atoms in the ferromagnetic TI
Cr$_{0.08}$(Bi$_{0.1}$Sb$_{0.9}$)$_{1.92}$Te$_3$. Simultaneous visualization of
the Diracmass gap $\Delta(r)$ reveals its intense disorder, which we
demonstrate directly is related to fluctuations in $n(r)$, the Cr atom areal
density in the termination layer. We find the relationship of surfacestate
Fermi wavevectors to the anisotropic structure of $\Delta(r)$ consistent with
predictions for surface ferromagnetism mediated by those states. Moreover,
despite the intense Diracmass disorder, the anticipated relationship
$\Delta(r)\propto n(r)$ is confirmed throughout, and exhibits an
electrondopant interaction energy $J^*$=145$meV\cdot nm^2$. These observations
reveal how magnetic dopant atoms actually generate the TI mass gap locally and
that, to achieve the novel physics expected of timereversalsymmetry breaking
TI materials, control of the resulting Diracmass gap disorder will be
essential.

The identity of the fundamental broken symmetry (if any) in the underdoped
cuprates is unresolved. However, evidence has been accumulating that this state
may be an unconventional density wave. Here we carry out sitespecific
measurements within each CuO$_2$ unitcell, segregating the results into three
separate electronic structure images containing only the Cu sites (Cu(r)) and
only the x/yaxis O sites (O$_x$(r) and O$_y$(r)). Phase resolved Fourier
analysis reveals directly that the modulations in the O$_x$(r) and O$_y$(r)
sublattice images consistently exhibit a relative phase of ${\pi}$. We confirm
this discovery on two highly distinct cuprate compounds, ruling out tunnel
matrixelement and materials specific systematics. These observations
demonstrate by direct sublattice phaseresolved visualization that the density
wave found in underdoped cuprates consists of modulations of the
intraunitcell states that exhibit a predominantly dsymmetry form factor.

Direct visualization of electronicstructure symmetry within each crystalline
unit cell is a new technique for complex electronic matter research. By
studying the Bragg peaks in Fourier transforms of electronic structure images,
and particularly by resolving both the real and imaginary components of the
Bragg amplitudes, distinct types of intraunit cell symmetry breaking can be
studied. However, establishing the precise symmetry point of each unit cell in
real space is crucial in defining the phase for such Braggpeak Fourier
analysis. Exemplary of this challenge is the high temperature superconductor
Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8+d for which the surface Bi atom locations are observable, while
it is the invisible Cu atoms that define the relevant CuO2 unitcell symmetry
point. Here we demonstrate, by imaging with picometer precision the electronic
impurity states at individual Zn atoms substituted at Cu sites, that the phase
established using the Bi lattice produces a ~2% (2pi) error relative to the
actual Cu lattice. Such a phase assignment error would not diminish reliability
in the determination of intraunitcell rotational symmetry breaking at the
CuO2 plane. Moreover, this type of impurity atom substitution at the relevant
symmetry site can be of general utility in phase determination for Braggpeak
Fourier analysis of intraunitcell symmetry.

We review the current state of efforts to use resonant soft xray scattering
(RSXS), which is an elastic, momentumresolved, valence band probe of strongly
correlated electron systems, to study stripelike phenomena in copperoxide
superconductors and related materials. We review the historical progress
including RSXS studies of Wigner crystallization in spin ladder materials,
stripe order in 214phase nickelates, 214phase cuprates, and other systems.
One of the major outstanding issues in RSXS concerns its relationship to more
established valence band probes, namely angleresolved photoemission (ARPES)
and scanning tunneling microscopy (STM). These techniques are widely understood
as measuring a oneelectron spectral function, yet a relationship between RSXS
and a spectral function has so far been unclear. Using physical arguments that
apply at the oxygen $K$ edge, we show that RSXS measures the square modulus of
an advanced version of the Green's function measured with STM. This indicates
that, despite being a momentum space probe, RSXS is more closely related to STM
than to ARPES techniques.
Finally, we close with some discussion of the most promising future
directions for RSXS. We will argue that the most promising area lies in high
magnetic field studies, particularly of edge states in strongly correlated
heterostructures, and the vortex state in superconducting cuprates, where RSXS
may clarify the anomalous periodicities observed in recent quantum oscillation
experiments.