Magnetic properties of the spin-3/2 Heisenberg system Cr2BP3O12 are investigated by magnetic susceptibility chi(T) measurements, electron spin resonance, neutron diffraction, and density functional theory (DFT) calculations, as well as classical and quantum Monte Carlo (MC) simulations. The broad maximum of chi(T) at 85K and the antiferromagnetic Weiss temperature of 139 K indicate low-dimensional magnetic behavior. Below TN = 28 K, Cr2BP3O12 is antiferromagnetically ordered with the k = 0 propagation vector and an ordered moment of 2.5 muB/Cr. DFT calculations, including DFT+U and hybrid functionals, yield a microscopic model of spin chains with alternating nearest-neighbor couplings J1 and J1' . The chains are coupled by two inequivalent interchain exchanges of similar strength (~1-2 K), but different sign (antiferromagnetic and ferromagnetic). The resulting spin lattice is quasi-one-dimensional and not frustrated. Quantum MC simulations show excellent agreement with the experimental data for the parameters J1 ~= 50 K and J1'/J1 ~= 0.5. Therefore, Cr2BP3O12 is close to the gapless critical point (J1'/J1 = 0.41) of the spin-3/2 bond-alternating Heisenberg chain. The applicability limits of the classical approximation are addressed by quantum and classical MC simulations. Implications for a wide range of low-dimensional S = 3/2 materials are discussed.