-
We present the activities of the "New Physics" working group for the "Physics
at TeV Colliders" workshop (Les Houches, France, 3--21 June, 2013). Our report
includes new computational tool developments, studies of the implications of
the Higgs boson discovery on new physics, important signatures for searches for
natural new physics at the LHC, new studies of flavour aspects of new physics,
and assessments of the interplay between direct dark matter searches and the
LHC.
-
We present the FP420 R&D project, which has been studying the key aspects of
the development and installation of a silicon tracker and fast-timing detectors
in the LHC tunnel at 420 m from the interaction points of the ATLAS and CMS
experiments. These detectors would measure precisely very forward protons in
conjunction with the corresponding central detectors as a means to study
Standard Model (SM) physics, and to search for and characterise New Physics
signals. This report includes a detailed description of the physics case for
the detector and, in particular, for the measurement of Central Exclusive
Production, pp --> p + phi + p, in which the outgoing protons remain intact and
the central system phi may be a single particle such as a SM or MSSM Higgs
boson. Other physics topics discussed are gamma-gamma and gamma-p interactions,
and diffractive processes. The report includes a detailed study of the trigger
strategy, acceptance, reconstruction efficiencies, and expected yields for a
particular p p --> p H p measurement with Higgs boson decay in the b-bbar mode.
The document also describes the detector acceptance as given by the LHC beam
optics between the interaction points and the FP420 location, the machine
backgrounds, the new proposed connection cryostat and the moving ("Hamburg")
beam-pipe at 420 m, and the radio-frequency impact of the design on the LHC.
The last part of the document is devoted to a description of the 3D silicon
sensors and associated tracking performances, the design of two fast-timing
detectors capable of accurate vertex reconstruction for background rejection at
high-luminosities, and the detector alignment and calibration strategy.
-
The simplest supersymmetric model that solves the mu problem and in which the
GUT-scale parameters need not be finely tuned in order to predict the correct
value of the Z boson mass at low scales is the Next-to-Minimal Supersymmetric
Standard Model (NMSSM). However, in order that fine tuning be absent, the
lightest CP-even Higgs boson h should have mass ~100 GeV and SM couplings to
gauge bosons and fermions. The only way that this can be consistent with LEP
limits is if h decays primarily via h->aa->4 tau or 4j but not 4b, where a is
the lighter of the two pseudo-scalar Higgses that are present in the NMSSM.
Interestingly, m_a < 2 m_b is natural in the NMSSM with m_a > 2 m_tau somewhat
preferred. Thus, h -> 4 tau becomes a key mode of interest. Meanwhile, all
other Higgs bosons of the NMSSM are typically quite heavy. Detection of any of
the NMSSM Higgs bosons at the LHC in this preferred scenario will be very
challenging using conventional channels. In this paper, we demonstrate that the
h -> aa -> 4 tau decay chain should be visible if the Higgs is produced in the
process pp -> p+h+p with the final state protons being measured using suitably
installed forward detectors. Moreover, we show that the mass of both the h and
the a can be determined on an event-by-event basis.
-
There are many possibilities for new physics beyond the Standard Model that
feature non-standard Higgs sectors. These may introduce new sources of CP
violation, and there may be mixing between multiple Higgs bosons or other new
scalar bosons. Alternatively, the Higgs may be a composite state, or there may
even be no Higgs at all. These non-standard Higgs scenarios have important
implications for collider physics as well as for cosmology, and understanding
their phenomenology is essential for a full comprehension of electroweak
symmetry breaking. This report discusses the most relevant theories which go
beyond the Standard Model and its minimal, CP-conserving supersymmetric
extension: two-Higgs-doublet models and minimal supersymmetric models with CP
violation, supersymmetric models with an extra singlet, models with extra gauge
groups or Higgs triplets, Little Higgs models, models in extra dimensions, and
models with technicolour or other new strong dynamics. For each of these
scenarios, this report presents an introduction to the phenomenology, followed
by contributions on more detailed theoretical aspects and studies of possible
experimental signatures at the LHC and other colliders.
-
Physics at the Large Hadron Collider (LHC) and the International e+e- Linear
Collider (ILC) will be complementary in many respects, as has been demonstrated
at previous generations of hadron and lepton colliders. This report addresses
the possible interplay between the LHC and ILC in testing the Standard Model
and in discovering and determining the origin of new physics. Mutual benefits
for the physics programme at both machines can occur both at the level of a
combined interpretation of Hadron Collider and Linear Collider data and at the
level of combined analyses of the data, where results obtained at one machine
can directly influence the way analyses are carried out at the other machine.
Topics under study comprise the physics of weak and strong electroweak symmetry
breaking, supersymmetric models, new gauge theories, models with extra
dimensions, and electroweak and QCD precision physics. The status of the work
that has been carried out within the LHC / LC Study Group so far is summarised
in this report. Possible topics for future studies are outlined.
-
Assuming flat universal extra dimensions, we demonstrate that for a light
Higgs boson the process $pp\to W^*W^* +X \to Higgs,graviscalars +X \to
invisible+X$ will be observable at the $5 \sigma$ level at the LHC for the
portion of the Higgs-graviscalar mixing ($\xi$) and effective Planck mass
($M_D$) parameter space where channels relying on visible Higgs decays fail to
achieve a $5 \sigma$ signal. Further, we show that even for very modest values
of $\xi$ the invisible decay signal probes to higher $M_D$ than does the
($\xi$-independent) jets/$\gam$ + missing energy signal from graviton
radiation. We also discuss various effects, such as Higgs decay to two
graviscalars, that could become important when $m_h/M_D$ is of order 1.
-
We derive the Lagrangian and Feynman rules up to bilinear scalar fields for
the mixed Higgs-radion eigenstates interacting with Standard Model particles
confined to a 3-brane in Randall-Sundrum warped geometry. We use the results to
compute precision electroweak observables and compare theory predictions with
experiment. We characterize the interesting regions of parameter space that
simultaneously enable a very heavy Higgs mass and a very heavy radion mass,
both masses being well above the putative Higgs boson mass limit in the
Standard Model derived from the constraints of precision electroweak
observables. For parameters consistent with the precision constraints the Higgs
boson physical eigenstate is typically detectable, but its properties may be
difficult to study at the Large Hadron Collider. In contrast, masses and
couplings are allowed for the physical radion eigenstate that make it
unobservable at the LHC. A Linear Collider will significantly improve our
ability to study the Higgs eigenstate, and will typically allow detection of
the radion eigenstate if it is within the machine's kinematical reach.
-
We derive the effective potential for the Standard Model Higgs-boson sector
interacting with Kaluza-Klein excitations of the graviton ($h_\mu^{\nu n}$) and
the radion ($\phi$) and show that {\it only} the Standard Model vacuum solution
of $\partial V(h)/\partial h =0$ (h is the Higgs field) is allowed. We then
consider the consequences of the curvature-scalar mixing xi R \Hhat^\dagger
\Hhat$ (where $\Hhat$ is a Higgs doublet field on the visible brane), which
causes the physical mass eigenstates h and $\phi$ to be mixtures of the
original Higgs and radion fields. First, we discuss the theoretical constraints
on the allowed parameter space. Next, we give precise procedures for computing
the h and $\phi$ couplings given the {\it physical} eigenstate masses, mh and
$\mphi$, xi and the new physics scales of the model. We show that LEP/LEP2 data
implies that not both the h and $\phi$ can be light. In the allowed region of
parameter space, we examine numerically the couplings and branching ratios of
the h and $\phi$ for several cases with $\mh=120\gev$ and $\mphi\leq 300\gev$.
The resulting prospects for detection of the h and $\phi$ at the LHC, a future
LC and a $\gam\gam$ collider are reviewed. For moderate $|\xi|$, both the
anomalous $h\to gg$ coupling and (when $\mh>2\mphi$) the non-standard decay
channel $h \to \phi\phi$ can substantially impact h discovery. Presence of the
latter is a direct signature for non-zero xi. We find that $BR(h \to \phi\phi)$
as large as $30 \div 40 %$ is possible when $|\xi|$ is large. Conversely, if
$\mphi>2\mh$ then $BR(\phi\to hh)$ is generally large. The feasibility of
experimentally measuring the anomalous gg and $\gam\gam$ couplings of the h and
$\phi$ is examined.
-
The prospects for a precise exploration of the properties of a single or many
observed Higgs bosons at future accelerators are summarized, with particular
emphasis on the abilities of a Linear Collider (LC). Some implications of these
measurements for discerning new physics beyond the Standard Model (SM) are also
discussed.
-
It is widely stated that the ratio of neutral Higgs field vacuum expectation
values, $\tanb$, is one of the most difficult parameters to determine in either
the Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (MSSM) or a general type-II Two-Higgs
Doublet Model (2HDM). Assuming an energy and integrated luminosity of
$\rts=500\gev$ and $\call=2000\fbi$, we show that a very accurate determination
of $\tanb$ will often be possible using Higgs production rates and/or Higgs
decays. Based on a TESLA simulation, and assuming no other light Higgs bosons
and $100\leq m_A \leq 200\gev$, we find that the rate for the process $\epem\to
b\anti b A \to b\anti b b\anti b$ provides an excellent determination of
$\tanb$ at high $\tanb$. In the MSSM Higgs sector, the rate for $\epem\to
b\anti b A+ b\anti b H \to b\anti b b\anti b$ ($\epem\to HA \to b\anti b b\anti
b$) provides a good determination of $\tanb$ at high (low) $\tanb$,
respectively, at moderate $m_A$ values. We also show that direct measurement of
the average total width of the $H$ and $A$ in $\epem\to HA \to b\anti b b\anti
b$ events provides an excellent determination of $\tanb$ at large $\tanb$.
-
We outline the unique role of a muon collider as a Higgs factory for Higgs
boson resonance production in the $s$-channel. Physics examples include: the
precision measurements of the Higgs mass and total width, and the resulting
ability to discriminate between the SM-like Higgs bosons of different models
such as between a light SM Higgs boson and the light Higgs boson of the MSSM;
the determination of the spin and coupling via the $h\to \tautau$ decay mode;
differentiation of two nearly degenerate heavy Higgs bosons by an energy scan;
and the ability to explore a general extended Higgs sector, possibly with
CP-violating couplings. The muon collider Higgs factory could perform
measurements that would be highly complementary to Higgs studies at the LHC and
LC; it would be likely to play a very crucial role in fully understanding the
Higgs sector.
-
The TESLA Technical Design Report Part III: Physics at an e+e- Linear
Collider
-
We consider a CP-conserving two-Higgs-doublet type II model with a light
scalar or pseudoscalar neutral Higgs boson ($\h=\hl$ or $\h=\ha$) that has no
$ZZ/WW$ coupling and, thus, cannot be detected in $\epem\to Z\h$
(Higgs-strahlung) or $\nu\anti\nu \h$ (via $WW$ fusion). Despite sum rules
which ensure that the light $\h$ must have significant $t\anti t$ or $b\anti b$
coupling, for a wedge of moderate $\tanb$, that becomes increasingly large as
$\mh$ increases, the $\h$ can also escape discovery in both $b\anti b \h$ and
$t\anti t \h$ production at a $\rts=500-800\gev$ $\epem$ collider (for expected
luminosities). If the other Higgs bosons happen to be too heavy to be produced,
then no Higgs boson would be detected. We demonstrate that, despite such high
masses for the other Higgs bosons, only the low-$\tanb$ portion of the
no-discovery wedges in $[\mh,\tanb]$ parameter space can be excluded due to
failure to fit precision electroweak observables. In the $\tanb\gsim 1$ regions
of the no-discovery wedges, we find that the 2HDM fit to precision electroweak
observables has small $\Delta\chi^2$ relative to the best minimal one-doublet
SM fit.
-
Already in the simplest two-Higgs-doublet model with CP violation in the
Higgs sector, the $3\times3$ mixing matrix for the neutral Higgs bosons can
substantially modify their couplings, thereby endangering the ``classical''
Higgs search strategies. However, there are sum rules relating Yukawa and
Higgs-Z couplings which ensure that the ZZ, $b\anti b$ and $t\anti t$ couplings
of a given neutral 2HDM Higgs boson cannot all be simultaneously suppressed.
This result implies that any single Higgs boson will be detectable at an e^+e^-
collider if the Z+Higgs, $b\anti b+$Higgs {\it and} $t\anti t+$Higgs production
channels are all kinematically accessible {\it and} if the integrated
luminosity is sufficient. We explore, as a function of Higgs mass, the
luminosity required to guarantee Higgs boson detection, and find that for
moderate $\tan\beta$ values the needed luminosity is unlikely to be available
for all possible mixing scenarios. The additional difficulties for the case
when the two-doublet Higgs sector is extended by adding one more singlet are
summarized. Implications of the sum rules for Higgs discovery at the Tevatron
and LHC are briefly discussed.
-
We review the possibilities that the Kaluza-Klein excitations of graviton
states induce electroweak symmetry breaking and that electroweak symmetry
breaking could have a large impact on KK phenomenology.
-
We study the use of polarization asymmetries at a muon collider to determine
the CP-even and CP-odd couplings of a Higgs boson to $\mu^+mu^-$. We determine
achievable accuracy as a function of beam polarization and luminosity. The
appropriate techniques for dealing with the polarization precession are
outlined. Strategies especially appropriate for a two-Higgs-doublet model
(including the MSSM) are given. Our general conclusion is that polarization
will be very useful, especially if the proton source is such that full
luminosity in the storage ring can be retained even after imposing cuts on the
originally accepted muons necessary for $P\gsim 0.4$ for each beam.
-
The open light gluino window allows non-trivial higher twist gluino
contributions to the proton wave function. Using a two-component model
originally developed for charm hadroproduction, higher twist intrinsic gluino
contributions to final state R-hadron formation are shown to enhance leading
twist production in the forward $x_{F}$ region. We calculate R-hadron
production at $p_{\rm{lab}}=800$ GeV in pp, pBe, and pCu interactions with
light gluino masses of 1.2, 1.5, 3.5, and 5.0 GeV.
-
We explore the possibility that the Kaluza-Klein graviton states induce
electroweak symmetry breaking. We also demonstrate that electroweak symmetry
breaking could have a large impact on KK phenomenology.
-
For an attractive class of dynamical symmetry breaking (technicolor) models,
the lightest neutral pseudo-Nambu-Goldstone boson ($\pzero$) contains only
down-type techniquarks and charged technileptons. We discuss the prospects for
discovering and studying the $\pzero$ of such models at the Tevatron and the
LHC and at future $\epem$ and $\mupmum$ colliders. Depending upon the number of
technicolors, $\ntc$, discovery of the $\pzero$ at the Tevatron and the LHC in
the $gg\to\pzero\to\gam\gam$ mode could be possible over a wide range of mass.
For $\ntc=4$, discovery of the $\pzero$ at an $\epem$ collider via the reaction
$\epem\to\gam \pzero$ should be possible as long as $\mpzero$ is not near
$\mz$. In the $\gam\gam$ collider mode of operation at an $\epem$ collider, the
$\gam\gam\to\pzero\to b\anti b$ signal should be very robust if $\ntc=4$. For
the minimal $\ntc=1$ case, detection of the $\pzero$ at the Tevatron and in
$\epem$ collisions will be very difficult, and the precision of measurements at
the LHC and the $\gam\gam$ collider decline markedly. A $\mupmum$ collider
yields a $\pzero$ production rate that does not depend markedly upon $\ntc$. At
a $\mupmum$ collider discovery of the $\pzero$ as an $s$-channel resonance
should prove possible via scanning, even if it has not already been detected
elsewhere. Once $\mpzero$ is precisely known, operation of the $\mupmum$
collider as a $\pzero$ factory will allow precision measurements of enough
observables to determine the number of technicolors of the theory and (up to a
discrete set of ambiguities) the fundamental parameters of the low-energy
effective Lagrangian describing the Yukawa couplings of the $\pzero$.
-
For some choices of soft SUSY-breaking parameters, the LSP is a stable
neutralino $\cnone$, the NLSP is a chargino $\cpmone$ almost degenerate in mass
with the LSP ($\dmchi\equiv\mcpmone-\mcnone\sim \mpi-$few GeV), and all other
sparticles are relatively heavy. In this case, detection of sparticles in the
usual, mSUGRA-motivated signals will be difficult, since the decay products in
$\cpmone\to\cnone...$ will be very soft, and alternative signals must be
considered. Here, we study the viability of signatures at the Tevatron based on
highly-ionizing charged tracks, disappearing charged tracks, large impact
parameters, missing transverse energy and a jet or a photon, and determine the
mass reach of such signatures assuming that only the $\cpmone$ and $\cnone$ are
light. We also consider the jet+$\etmiss$ and $\gamma+\etmiss$ signatures
assuming that the gluino is also light with $\mgl\sim \mcpmone$. We find that
the mass reach is critically dependent upon $\dmchi$ and $\mgl-\mcpmone$. If
$\dmchi$ is sufficiently big that $c\tau(\cpmone)\lsim$few cm and $\mgl$ is
large, there is a significant possibility that the limits on $\mcpmone$ based
on LEP2 data cannot be extended at the Tevatron. If $c\tau(\cpmone)>$few cm,
relatively background-free signals exist that will give a clear signal of
$\cpmone$ production (for some range of $\mcpmone$) even if $\mgl$ is very
large.
-
The procedures for studying a single narrow s-channel resonance or nearly
degenerate resonances at a lepton collider, especially a muon collider, are
discussed. In particular, we examine four methods for determining the
parameters of a narrow s-channel resonance: scanning the resonance, measuring
the convoluted cross section, measuring the Breit-Wigner area, and sitting on
the resonance while varying the beam energy resolution. This latter procedure
is new and appears to be potentially very powerful. Our focus is on computing
the errors in resonance parameters resulting from uncertainty in the beam
energy spread. Means for minimizing these errors are discussed. The discussion
is applied to the examples of a light SM-Higgs, of the lightest pseudogoldstone
boson of strong electroweak breaking, and of the two spin-1 resonances of the
Degenerate BESS model (assuming that the beam energy spread is less than their
mass splitting). We also examine the most effective procedures for nearly
degenerate resonances, and apply these to the case of Degenerate BESS
resonances with mass splitting of order the beam energy spread.
-
We explore an alternative to the usual procedure of scanning for determining
the properties of a narrow $s$-channel resonance. By varying the beam energy
resolution while sitting on the resonance peak, the width and branching ratios
of the resonance can be determined. The statistical accuracy achieved is
superior to that of the usual scan procedure in the case of a light SM-like
Higgs boson with $\mh>130\gev$ or for the lightest pseudogoldstone boson of a
strong electroweak breaking model if $\mpzero>150\gev$.
-
We correct our treatment of decays of the lightest chargino to final states
containing the lightest neutralino in the case where the chargino and
neutralino masses differ by less than 1 GeV. A brief summary of the
phenomenological implications is given.
-
We investigate the phenomenology of an orbifold string model in which
supersymmetry breaking is dominated by the overall `size' modulus field and all
matter fields are in the untwisted sector. The possibly close degeneracy of the
lightest neutralino and chargino and the possibly small splitting between the
gluino and chargino/LSP mass imply that discovery of supersymmetry at future
colliders could be more challenging than anticipated. Specialized search
strategies and particular detector features could play an important role. For
preferred model parameter choices, the phenomenology of dark matter in the
universe is significantly modified.
-
We explore the techniques, cross sections and expected signal significance
for detecting invisible and almost invisible particles at LEP2 and the NLC by
means of a hard photon tag. Examples from supersymmetry include the lightest
chargino and second lightest neutralino when their masses are nearly the same
as that of the lightest neutralino (the LSP), and invisibly decaying
sneutrinos. The importance of particular features of the detectors is
discussed, instrumentation for vetoing a fast e^+ or e^- in the beam hole being
especially crucial.