
On September 25, 2014 Murray GellMann was presented with the Helmholz Medal
of the Berlin Brandenburg Academy of Sciences and Humanities in a ceremony at
the Santa Fe Institute. The author, among others, was asked to speak for
fifteen minutes on Murray and his accomplishments. The following is an edited
transcription of the author's speaking text.

Feldbrugge, Lehners and Turok argue that large perturbations render the
noboundary proposal for the origin of the universe illdefined (PRL 119,
171301 (2017) and PRD 97, 023509 (2018)). We refute this claim by evaluating
the noboundary path integral exactly in a Bianchi IX minisuperspace with two
scale factors. In this model the noboundary proposal can be implemented by
requiring one scale factor to be zero initially together with a judiciously
chosen regularity condition on the momentum conjugate to the second scale
factor. Taking into account the nonlinear backreaction of the perturbations we
recover the predictions of the original semiclassical noboundary proposal. In
particular we find that large perturbations are strongly suppressed.

A brief remembrance of some aspects of the author's scientific interaction
with Stephen Hawking contributed to Physics Today's March 14, 2018 article in
which Stephen Hawking is remembered by his colleagues.

We sketch a quantum mechanical framework for the universe as a whole. Within
that framework we propose a program for describing the ultimate origin in
quantum cosmology of the quasiclassical domain of familiar experience and for
characterizing the process of measurement. Predictions in quantum mechanics are
made from probabilities for sets of alternative histories. Probabilities can be
assigned only to sets of histories that approximately decohere. Decoherence is
defined and the mechanism of decoherence is reviewed. Decoherence requires a
sufficiently coarsegrained description of alternative histories of the
universe. A quasiclassical domain consists of a branching set of alternative
decohering histories, described by a coarse graining that is maximally refined
consistent with decoherence, with individual branches that exhibit a high level
of classical correlation in time. A quasiclassical domain is emergent in the
universe as a consequence of the initial condition and the action function of
the elementary particles. It is an important question whether all the
quasiclassical domains are roughly equivalent or whether there are various
essentially inequivalent ones. A measurement is a correlation with variables in
a quasiclassical domain. An observer (or information gathering and utilizing
system) is a complex adaptive system that has evolved to exploit the relative
predictability of a quasiclassical domain. We suggest that resolution of many
of the problems of interpretation presented by quantum mechanics is to be
accomplished, not by further scrutiny of the subject as it applies to
reproducible laboratory situations, but rather by an examination of alternative
histories of the universe, stemming from its initial condition, and a study of
the problem of quasiclassical domains.

A quantum theory of the universe consists of a theory of its quantum dynamics
and a theory of its quantum state The theory predicts quantum multiverses in
the form of decoherent sets of alternative histories describing the evolution
of the universe's spacetime geometry and matter content. These consequences
follow: (a) The universe generally exhibits different quantum multiverses at
different levels and kinds of coarse graining. (b) Quantum multiverses are not
a choice or an assumption but are consequences of the theory or not. (c)
Quantum multiverses are generic for simple theories (d) Anthropic selection is
automatic because observers are physical systems within the universe not
somehow outside it. (e) Quantum multiverses can provide different mechanisms
for the variation constants in effective theories (like the cosmological
constant) enabling anthropic selection. (f) Different levels of coarse grained
multiverses provide different routes to calculation as a consequence of
decoherence. We support these conclusions by analyzing the quantum multiverses
of a variety of quantum cosmological models aimed at the prediction of
observable properties of our universe. In particular we show how the example of
a multiverse consisting of a vast classical spacetime containing many pocket
universes arises automatically as part of a quantum multiverse describing an
eternally inflating false vacuum that decays by the quantum nucleation of true
vacuum bubbles. In a FAQ we argue that the quantum multiverses of the universe
are scientific, real, testable, falsifiable, and similar to those in other
areas of science even if they are not directly observable on arbitrarily large
scales.

It is shown that the standard noboundary wave function has a natural
expression in terms of a Lorentzian path integral with its contour defined by
PicardLefschetz theory. The wave function is real, satisfies the
WheelerDeWitt equation and predicts an ensemble of asymptotically classical,
inflationary universes with nearlyGaussian fluctuations and with a smooth
semiclassical origin.

Einstein wrote memorably that `The eternally incomprehensible thing about the
world is its comprehensibility.' This paper argues that the universe must be
comprehensible at some level for information gathering and utilizing subsystems
such as human observers to evolve and function.

This essay considers a model quantum universe consisting of a very large box
containing a screen with two slits and an observer (us) that can pass though
the slits. We apply the modern quantum mechanics of closed systems to calculate
the probabilities for alternative histories of how we move through the universe
and what we see. After passing through the screen with the slits, the quantum
state of the universe is a superposition of classically distinguishable
histories. We are then living in a superposition. Some frequently asked
questions about such situations are answered using this model. The model's
relationship to more realistic quantum cosmologies is briefly discussed.

We present a formulation of the decoherent (or consistent) histories quantum
theory of closed systems starting with records of what histories happen.
Alternative routes to a formulation of quantum theory like this one can be
useful both for understanding quantum mechanics and for generalizing and
extending it to new realms of application and experimental test.

These are the author's lectures at the 1992 Les Houches Summer School,
"Gravitation and Quantizations". They develop a generalized sumoverhistories
quantum mechanics for quantum cosmology that does not require either a
preferred notion of time or a definition of measurement. The "postEverett"
quantum mechanics of closed systems is reviewed. Generalized quantum theories
are defined by three elements (1) the set of finegrained histories of the
closed system which are its most refined possible description, (2) the allowed
coarse grainings which are partitions of the finegrained histories into
classes, and (3) a decoherence functional which measures interference between
coarse grained histories. Probabilities are assigned to sets of alternative
coarsegrained histories that decohere as a consequence of the closed system's
dynamics and initial condition. Generalized sumover histories quantum theories
are constructed for nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, abelian gauge theories,
a single relativistic world line, and for general relativity. For relativity
the finegrained histories are fourmetrics and matter fields. Coarse grainings
are fourdimensional diffeomorphism invariant partitions of these. The
decoherence function is expressed in sumoverhistories form. The quantum
mechanics of spacetime is thus expressed in fully spacetime form. The
coarsegrainings are most general notion of alternative for quantum theory
expressible in spacetime terms. Hamiltonian quantum mechanics of matter fields
with its notion of unitarily evolving state on a spacelike surface is recovered
as an approximation to this generalized quantum mechanics appropriate for those
initial conditions and coarsegrainings such that spacetime geometry

Measurement is a fundamental notion in the usual approximate quantum
mechanics of measured subsystems. Probabilities are predicted for the outcomes
of measurements. State vectors evolve unitarily in between measurements and by
reduction of the state vector at measurements. Probabilities are computed by
summing the squares of amplitudes over alternatives which could have been
measured but weren't. Measurements are limited by uncertainty principles and by
other restrictions arising from the principles of quantum mechanics. This essay
examines the extent to which those features of the quantum mechanics of
measured subsystems that are explicitly tied to measurement situations are
incorporated or modified in the more general quantum mechanics of closed
systems in which measurement is not a fundamental notion. There, probabilities
are predicted for decohering sets of alternative time histories of the closed
system, whether or not they represent a measurement situation. Reduction of the
state vector is a necessary part of the description of such histories.
Uncertainty principles limit the possible alternatives at one time from which
histories may be constructed. Models of measurement situations are exhibited
within the quantum mechanics of the closed system containing both measured
subsystem and measuring apparatus. Limitations are derived on the existence of
records for the outcomes of measurements when the initial density matrix of the
closed system is highly impure. (Festschrift for Dieter Brill).

Feynman's sumoverhistories formulation of quantum mechanics is reviewed as
an independent statement of quantum theory in spacetime form. It is different
from the usual Schr\"odingerHeisenberg formulation that utilizes states on
spacelike surfaces because it assigns probabilities to different sets of
alternatives. Sumoverhistories quantum mechanics can be generalized to deal
with spacetime alternatives that are not "at definite moments of time". An
example in field theory is the set of alternative ranges of values of a field
averaged over a spacetime region. An example in particle mechanics is the set
of the alternatives defined by whether a particle never crosses a fixed
spacetime region or crosses it at least once. The general notion of a set of
spacetime alternatives is a partition (coarsegraining) of the histories into
an exhaustive set of exclusive classes. With this generalization the
sumoverhistories formulation can be said to be in fully spacetime form with
dynamics represented by path integrals over spacetime histories and
alternatives defined as spacetime partitions of these histories. When
restricted to alternatives at definite moments of times this generalization is
equivalent to Schr\"odingerHeisenberg quantum mechanics. However, the quantum
mechanics of more general spacetime alternatives does not have an equivalent
Schr\"odingerHeisenberg formulation. We suggest that, in the quantum theory of
gravity, the general notion of "observable" is supplied by diffeomorphism
invariant partitions of spacetime metrics and matter field configurations. By
generalizing the usual alternatives so as to put quantum theory in fully
spacetime form we may be led to a covariant generalized quantum mechanics of
spacetime free from the problem of time.

The origin of the phenomenological deterministic laws that approximately
govern the quasiclassical domain of familiar experience is considered in the
context of the quantum mechanics of closed systems such as the universe as a
whole. We investigate the requirements for coarse grainings to yield decoherent
sets of histories that are quasiclassical, i.e. such that the individual
histories obey, with high probability, effective classical equations of motion
interrupted continually by small fluctuations and occasionally by large ones.
We discuss these requirements generally but study them specifically for coarse
grainings of the type that follows a distinguished subset of a complete set of
variables while ignoring the rest. More coarse graining is needed to achieve
decoherence than would be suggested by naive arguments based on the uncertainty
principle. Even coarser graining is required in the distinguished variables for
them to have the necessary inertia to approach classical predictability in the
presence of the noise consisting of the fluctuations that typical mechanisms of
decoherence produce. We describe the derivation of phenomenological equations
of motion explicitly for a particular class of models. Probabilities of the
correlations in time that define equations of motion are explicitly considered.
Fully nonlinear cases are studied. Methods are exhibited for finding the form
of the phenomenological equations of motion even when these are only distantly
related to those of the fundamental action. The demonstration of the connection
between quantummechanical causality and causalty in classical phenomenological
equations of motion is generalized. The connections among decoherence, noise,
dissipation, and the amount of coarse graining necessary to achieve classical
predictability are investigated quantitatively.

Three ideas are introduced that when brought together characterize the
realistic quasiclassical realms of our quantum universe as particular kinds of
sets of alternative coarsegrained histories defined by quasiclassical
variables: (1) Branch dependent adaptive coarse grainings that can be close to
maximally refined and can simplify calculation. (2) Narrative coarse grainings
that describe how features of the universe change over time and allow the
construction of an environment. (3) A notion of strong decoherence that
characterizes realistic mechanisms of decoherence.

Usual quantum mechanics requires a fixed, background, spacetime geometry and
its associated causal structure. A generalization of the usual theory may
therefore be needed at the Planck scale for quantum theories of gravity in
which spacetime geometry is a quantum variable. The elements of generalized
quantum theory are briefly reviewed and illustrated by generalizations of usual
quantum theory that incorporate spacetime alternatives, gauge degrees of
freedom, and histories that move forward and backward in time. A generalized
quantum framework for cosmological spacetime geometry is sketched. This theory
is in fully fourdimensional form and free from the need for a fixed causal
structure. Usual quantum mechanics is recovered as an approximation to this
more general framework that is appropriate in those situations where spacetime
geometry behaves classically.
(Talk given at the Workshop on Physics at the Planck Scale, Puri, India,
December1221, 1994. This talk is a precis of the author's 1992 Les Houches
Lectures: Spacetime Quantum Mechanics and the Quantum Mechanics of Spacetime,
grqc/9304006).

The evolution of the universe is determined by its quantum state. The wave
function of the universe obeys the constraints of general relativity and in
particular the WheelerDeWitt equation (WDWE). For nonzero \Lambda, we show
that solutions of the WDWE at large volume have two domains in which geometries
and fields are asymptotically real. In one the histories are Euclidean
asymptotically antide Sitter, in the other they are Lorentzian asymptotically
classical de Sitter. Further, the universal complex semiclassical asymptotic
structure of solutions of the WDWE implies that the leading order in \hbar
quantum probabilities for classical, asymptotically de Sitter histories can be
obtained from the action of asymptotically antide Sitter configurations. This
leads to a promising, universal connection between quantum cosmology and
holography.

We extend the holographic formulation of the semiclassical noboundary wave
function (NBWF) to models with Maxwell vector fields. It is shown that the
familiar saddle points of the NBWF have a representation in which a regular,
Euclidean asymptotic AdS geometry smoothly joins onto a Lorentzian
asymptotically de Sitter universe through a complex transition region. The tree
level probabilities of Lorentzian histories are fully specified by the action
of the AdS region of the saddle points. The scalar and vector matter profiles
in this region are complex from an AdS viewpoint, with universal asymptotic
phases. The dual description of the semiclassical NBWF thus involves complex
deformations of Euclidean CFTs.

The familiar textbook quantum mechanics of laboratory measurements
incorporates a quantum mechanical arrow of time  the direction in time in
which state vector reduction operates. This arrow is usually assumed to
coincide with the direction of the thermodynamic arrow of the quasiclassical
realm of everyday experience. But in the more general context of cosmology we
seek an explanation of all observed arrows, and the relations between them, in
terms of the conditions that specify our particular universe. This paper
investigates quantum mechanical and thermodynamic arrows in a timeneutral
formulation of quantum mechanics for a number of model cosmologies in fixed
background spacetimes. We find that a general universe may not have well
defined arrows of either kind. When arrows are emergent they need not point in
the same direction over the whole of spacetime. Rather they may be local,
pointing in different directions in different spacetime regions. Local arrows
can therefore be consistent with global time symmetry.

Wave functions specifying a quantum state of the universe must satisfy the
constraints of general relativity, in particular the WheelerDeWitt equation
(WDWE). We show for a wide class of models with nonzero cosmological constant
that solutions of the WDWE exhibit a universal semiclassical asymptotic
structure for large spatial volumes. A consequence of this asymptotic structure
is that a wave function in a gravitational theory with a negative cosmological
constant can predict an ensemble of asymptotically classical histories which
expand with a positive effective cosmological constant. This raises the
possibility that even fundamental theories with a negative cosmological
constant can be consistent with our lowenergy observations of a classical,
accelerating universe. We illustrate this general framework with the specific
example of the noboundary wave function in its holographic form. The
implications of these results for model building in string cosmology are
discussed.

Decoherent histories quantum theory is reformulated with the assumption that
there is one "real" finegrained history, specified in a preferred complete set
of sumoverhistories variables. This real history is described by embedding it
in an ensemble of comparable imagined finegrained histories, not unlike the
familiar ensemble of statistical mechanics. These histories are assigned
extended probabilities, which can sometimes be negative or greater than one. As
we will show, this construction implies that the real history is not completely
accessible to experimental or other observational discovery. However,
sufficiently and appropriately coarsegrained sets of alternative histories
have standard probabilities providing information about the real finegrained
history that can be compared with observation. We recover the probabilities of
decoherent histories quantum mechanics for sets of histories that are recorded
and therefore decohere. Quantum mechanics can be viewed as a classical
stochastic theory of histories with extended probabilities and a welldefined
notion of reality common to all decoherent sets of alternative coarsegrained
histories.

The most striking observable feature of our indeterministic quantum universe
is the wide range of time, place, and scale on which the deterministic laws of
classical physics hold to an excellent approximation. This essay describes how
this domain of classical predictability of every day experience emerges from a
quantum theory of the universe's state and dynamics.

The quantum mechanics of closed systems such as the universe is formulated
using an extension of familiar probability theory that incorporates negative
probabilities. Probabilities must be positive for sets of alternative histories
that are the basis of fair settleable bets. However, in quantum mechanics there
are sets of alternative histories that can be described but which cannot be the
basis for fair settleable bets. Members of such sets can be assigned extended
probabilities that are sometimes negative. A prescription for extended
probabilities is introduced that assigns extended probabilities to all
histories that can be described, fine grained or coarse grained, members of
decoherent sets or not. All probability sum rules are satisfied exactly. Sets
of histories that are recorded to sufficient precision are the basis of
settleable bets. This formulation is compared with the decoherent (consistent)
histories formulation of quantum theory. Prospects are discussed for using this
formulation to provide testable alternatives to quantum theory or further
generalizations of it.

We consider the noboundary proposal for homogeneous isotropic closed
universes with a cosmological constant and a scalar field with a quadratic
potential. In the semiclassical limit, it predicts classical behavior at late
times if the initial scalar field is more than a certain minimum. If the
classical late time histories are extended back, they may be singular or bounce
at a finite radius. The noboundary proposal provides a probability measure on
the classical solutions which selects inflationary histories but is heavily
biased towards small amounts of inflation. This would not be compatible with
observations. However we argue that the probability for a homogeneous universe
should be multiplied by exp(3N) where N is the number of efoldings of slow
roll inflation to obtain the probability for what we observe in our past light
cone. This volume weighting is similar to that in eternal inflation. In a
landscape potential, it would predict that the universe would have a large
amount of inflation and that it would start in an approximately de Sitter state
near a saddlepoint of the potential. The universe would then have always been
in the semiclassical regime.

We analyze the origin of the quasiclassical realm from the noboundary
proposal for the universe's quantum state in a class of minisuperspace models.
The models assume homogeneous, isotropic, closed spacetime geometries, a single
scalar field moving in a quadratic potential, and a fundamental cosmological
constant. The allowed classical histories and their probabilities are
calculated to leading semiclassical order. We find that for the most realistic
range of parameters analyzed a minimum amount of scalar field is required, if
there is any at all, in order for the universe to behave classically at late
times. If the classical late time histories are extended back, they may be
singular or bounce at a finite radius. The ensemble of classical histories is
time symmetric although individual histories are generally not. The noboundary
proposal selects inflationary histories, but the measure on the classical
solutions it provides is heavily biased towards small amounts of inflation.
However, the probability for a large number of efoldings is enhanced by the
volume factor needed to obtain the probability for what we observe in our past
light cone, given our present age. Our results emphasize that it is the quantum
state of the universe that determines whether or not it exhibits a
quasiclassical realm and what histories are possible or probable within that
realm.

In this universe, governed fundamentally by quantum mechanical laws,
characterized by indeterminism and distributed probabilities, classical
deterministic laws are applicable over a wide range of time, place, and scale.
We review the origin of these laws in the context of the quantum mechanics of
closed systems, most generally, the universe as a whole. There probabilities
are predicted for members of decoherent sets of alternative histories of the
universe, ie ones for which the interference between pairs in the set is
negligible as measured by a decoherence functional. An expansion of the
decoherence functional in the separation between histories allows the form of
the deterministic equations of motion to be derived for suitable coarse
grainings of a class of nonrelativistic systems, including ones with general
nonlinear interactions. More coarse graining is needed to achieve classical
predictability than naive arguments based on the uncertainty principle would
suggest. Coarse graining is needed for decoherence, and coarse graining beyond
that for the inertia necessary to resist the noise that mechanisms of
decoherence produce. Sets of histories governed largely by deterministic laws
constitute the quasiclassical realm of everyday experience which is an emergent
feature of the closed system's initial condition and Hamiltonian. We analyse
the sensitivity of the existence of a quasiclassical realm to the particular
form of the initial condition. We find that almost any initial condition will
exhibit a quasiclassical realm of some sort, but only a small fraction of the
total number of possible initial states could reproduce the everyday
quasiclassical realm of our universe. (Talk given at the Lanczos Centenary
Conference, North Carolina State University, December 15, 1993.)