• ### Minimax Rates for Estimating the Dimension of a Manifold(1605.01011)

Feb. 16, 2019 math.ST, stat.TH, cs.CG
Many algorithms in machine learning and computational geometry require, as input, the intrinsic dimension of the manifold that supports the probability distribution of the data. This parameter is rarely known and therefore has to be estimated. We characterize the statistical difficulty of this problem by deriving upper and lower bounds on the minimax rate for estimating the dimension. First, we consider the problem of testing the hypothesis that the support of the data-generating probability distribution is a well-behaved manifold of intrinsic dimension $d_1$ versus the alternative that it is of dimension $d_2$, with $d_{1}<d_{2}$. With an i.i.d. sample of size $n$, we provide an upper bound on the probability of choosing the wrong dimension of $O\left( n^{-\left(d_{2}/d_{1}-1-\epsilon\right)n} \right)$, where $\epsilon$ is an arbitrarily small positive number. The proof is based on bounding the length of the traveling salesman path through the data points. We also demonstrate a lower bound of $\Omega \left( n^{-(2d_{2}-2d_{1}+\epsilon)n} \right)$, by applying Le Cam's lemma with a specific set of $d_{1}$-dimensional probability distributions. We then extend these results to get minimax rates for estimating the dimension of well-behaved manifolds. We obtain an upper bound of order $O \left( n^{-(\frac{1}{m-1}-\epsilon)n} \right)$ and a lower bound of order $\Omega \left( n^{-(2+\epsilon)n} \right)$, where $m$ is the embedding dimension.
• ### Least Ambiguous Set-Valued Classifiers with Bounded Error Levels(1609.00451)

Dec. 22, 2018 stat.ME, cs.LG, stat.ML
In most classification tasks there are observations that are ambiguous and therefore difficult to correctly label. Set-valued classifiers output sets of plausible labels rather than a single label, thereby giving a more appropriate and informative treatment to the labeling of ambiguous instances. We introduce a framework for multiclass set-valued classification, where the classifiers guarantee user-defined levels of coverage or confidence (the probability that the true label is contained in the set) while minimizing the ambiguity (the expected size of the output). We first derive oracle classifiers assuming the true distribution to be known. We show that the oracle classifiers are obtained from level sets of the functions that define the conditional probability of each class. Then we develop estimators with good asymptotic and finite sample properties. The proposed estimators build on existing single-label classifiers. The optimal classifier can sometimes output the empty set, but we provide two solutions to fix this issue that are suitable for various practical needs.
• ### Analysis of a Mode Clustering Diagram(1805.04187)

May 10, 2018 stat.ME
Mode-based clustering methods define clusters to be the basins of attraction of the modes of a density estimate. The most common version is mean shift clus- tering which uses a gradient ascent algorithm to find the basins. Rodriguez and Laio (2014) introduced a new method that is faster and simpler than mean shift clustering. Furthermore, they define a clustering diagram that provides a sim- ple, two-dimensional summary of the mode clustering information. We study the statistical properties of this diagram and we propose some improvements and extensions. In particular, we show a connection between the diagram and robust linear regression.
• ### Bootstrapping and Sample Splitting For High-Dimensional, Assumption-Free Inference(1611.05401)

April 2, 2018 math.ST, stat.TH
Several new methods have been proposed for performing valid inference after model selection. An older method is sampling splitting: use part of the data for model selection and part for inference. In this paper we revisit sample splitting combined with the bootstrap (or the Normal approximation). We show that this leads to a simple, assumption-free approach to inference and we establish results on the accuracy of the method. In fact, we find new bounds on the accuracy of the bootstrap and the Normal approximation for general nonlinear parameters with increasing dimension which we then use to assess the accuracy of regression inference. We show that an alternative, called the image bootstrap, has higher coverage accuracy at the cost of more computation. We define new parameters that measure variable importance and that can be inferred with greater accuracy than the usual regression coefficients. There is a inference-prediction tradeoff: splitting increases the accuracy and robustness of inference but can decrease the accuracy of the predictions.
• ### Robust Multivariate Nonparametric Tests via Projection-Pursuit(1803.00715)

March 2, 2018 math.ST, stat.TH, stat.ME
In this work, we generalize the Cram\'er-von Mises statistic via projection pursuit to obtain robust tests for the multivariate two-sample problem. The proposed tests are consistent against all fixed alternatives, robust to heavy-tailed data and minimax rate optimal. Our test statistics are completely free of tuning parameters and are computationally efficient even in high dimensions. When the dimension tends to infinity, the proposed test is shown to have identical power to that of the existing high-dimensional mean tests under certain location models. As a by-product of our approach, we introduce a new metric called the angular distance which can be thought of as a robust alternative to the Euclidean distance. Using the angular distance, we connect the proposed to the reproducing kernel Hilbert space approach. In addition to the Cram\'er-von Mises statistic, we show that the projection pursuit technique can be used to define robust, multivariate tests in many other problems.
• ### Estimating the Reach of a Manifold(1705.04565)

April 8, 2019 math.DG, math.ST, stat.TH
Various problems in manifold estimation make use of a quantity called the reach, denoted by $\tau\_M$, which is a measure of the regularity of the manifold. This paper is the first investigation into the problem of how to estimate the reach. First, we study the geometry of the reach through an approximation perspective. We derive new geometric results on the reach for submanifolds without boundary. An estimator $\hat{\tau}$ of $\tau\_{M}$ is proposed in a framework where tangent spaces are known, and bounds assessing its efficiency are derived. In the case of i.i.d. random point cloud $\mathbb{X}\_{n}$, $\hat{\tau}(\mathbb{X}\_{n})$ is showed to achieve uniform expected loss bounds over a $\mathcal{C}^3$-like model. Finally, we obtain upper and lower bounds on the minimax rate for estimating the reach.
• ### Uniform Asymptotic Inference and the Bootstrap After Model Selection(1506.06266)

Aug. 9, 2017 math.ST, stat.TH
Recently, Tibshirani et al. (2016) proposed a method for making inferences about parameters defined by model selection, in a typical regression setting with normally distributed errors. Here, we study the large sample properties of this method, without assuming normality. We prove that the test statistic of Tibshirani et al. (2016) is asymptotically valid, as the number of samples n grows and the dimension d of the regression problem stays fixed. Our asymptotic result holds uniformly over a wide class of nonnormal error distributions. We also propose an efficient bootstrap version of this test that is provably (asymptotically) conservative, and in practice, often delivers shorter intervals than those from the original normality-based approach. Finally, we prove that the test statistic of Tibshirani et al. (2016) does not enjoy uniform validity in a high-dimensional setting, when the dimension d is allowed grow.
• ### Hypothesis Testing For Densities and High-Dimensional Multinomials: Sharp Local Minimax Rates(1706.10003)

June 30, 2017 cs.IT, math.IT, math.ST, stat.TH, cs.LG, stat.ML
We consider the goodness-of-fit testing problem of distinguishing whether the data are drawn from a specified distribution, versus a composite alternative separated from the null in the total variation metric. In the discrete case, we consider goodness-of-fit testing when the null distribution has a possibly growing or unbounded number of categories. In the continuous case, we consider testing a Lipschitz density, with possibly unbounded support, in the low-smoothness regime where the Lipschitz parameter is not assumed to be constant. In contrast to existing results, we show that the minimax rate and critical testing radius in these settings depend strongly, and in a precise way, on the null distribution being tested and this motivates the study of the (local) minimax rate as a function of the null distribution. For multinomials the local minimax rate was recently studied in the work of Valiant and Valiant. We re-visit and extend their results and develop two modifications to the chi-squared test whose performance we characterize. For testing Lipschitz densities, we show that the usual binning tests are inadequate in the low-smoothness regime and we design a spatially adaptive partitioning scheme that forms the basis for our locally minimax optimal tests. Furthermore, we provide the first local minimax lower bounds for this problem which yield a sharp characterization of the dependence of the critical radius on the null hypothesis being tested. In the low-smoothness regime we also provide adaptive tests, that adapt to the unknown smoothness parameter. We illustrate our results with a variety of simulations that demonstrate the practical utility of our proposed tests.
• ### Statistical Inference using the Morse-Smale Complex(1506.08826)

April 4, 2017 math.ST, stat.TH, stat.ME, stat.ML
The Morse-Smale complex of a function $f$ decomposes the sample space into cells where $f$ is increasing or decreasing. When applied to nonparametric density estimation and regression, it provides a way to represent, visualize, and compare multivariate functions. In this paper, we present some statistical results on estimating Morse-Smale complexes. This allows us to derive new results for two existing methods: mode clustering and Morse-Smale regression. We also develop two new methods based on the Morse-Smale complex: a visualization technique for multivariate functions and a two-sample, multivariate hypothesis test.
• ### Distribution-Free Predictive Inference For Regression(1604.04173)

March 8, 2017 math.ST, stat.TH, stat.ME, stat.ML
We develop a general framework for distribution-free predictive inference in regression, using conformal inference. The proposed methodology allows for the construction of a prediction band for the response variable using any estimator of the regression function. The resulting prediction band preserves the consistency properties of the original estimator under standard assumptions, while guaranteeing finite-sample marginal coverage even when these assumptions do not hold. We analyze and compare, both empirically and theoretically, the two major variants of our conformal framework: full conformal inference and split conformal inference, along with a related jackknife method. These methods offer different tradeoffs between statistical accuracy (length of resulting prediction intervals) and computational efficiency. As extensions, we develop a method for constructing valid in-sample prediction intervals called {\it rank-one-out} conformal inference, which has essentially the same computational efficiency as split conformal inference. We also describe an extension of our procedures for producing prediction bands with locally varying length, in order to adapt to heteroskedascity in the data. Finally, we propose a model-free notion of variable importance, called {\it leave-one-covariate-out} or LOCO inference. Accompanying this paper is an R package {\tt conformalInference} that implements all of the proposals we have introduced. In the spirit of reproducibility, all of our empirical results can also be easily (re)generated using this package.
• ### Statistical Inference for Cluster Trees(1605.06416)

Feb. 12, 2017 math.ST, stat.TH, stat.ME, stat.ML
A cluster tree provides a highly-interpretable summary of a density function by representing the hierarchy of its high-density clusters. It is estimated using the empirical tree, which is the cluster tree constructed from a density estimator. This paper addresses the basic question of quantifying our uncertainty by assessing the statistical significance of topological features of an empirical cluster tree. We first study a variety of metrics that can be used to compare different trees, analyze their properties and assess their suitability for inference. We then propose methods to construct and summarize confidence sets for the unknown true cluster tree. We introduce a partial ordering on cluster trees which we use to prune some of the statistically insignificant features of the empirical tree, yielding interpretable and parsimonious cluster trees. Finally, we illustrate the proposed methods on a variety of synthetic examples and furthermore demonstrate their utility in the analysis of a Graft-versus-Host Disease (GvHD) data set.
• ### Detecting Effects of Filaments on Galaxy Properties in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey III(1509.06376)

Jan. 12, 2017 stat.AP, astro-ph.CO, astro-ph.GA
We study the effects of filaments on galaxy properties in the Sloan Digital Sky Survey (SDSS) Data Release 12 using filaments from the `Cosmic Web Reconstruction' catalogue (Chen et al. 2016), a publicly available filament catalogue for SDSS. Since filaments are tracers of medium-to-high density regions, we expect that galaxy properties associated with the environment are dependent on the distance to the nearest filament. Our analysis demonstrates that a red galaxy or a high-mass galaxy tend to reside closer to filaments than a blue or low-mass galaxy. After adjusting the effect from stellar mass, on average, early-forming galaxies or large galaxies have a shorter distance to filaments than late-forming galaxies or small galaxies. For the Main galaxy sample (MGS), all signals are very significant ($>6\sigma$). For the LOWZ and CMASS sample, the stellar mass and size are significant ($>2 \sigma$). The filament effects we observe persist until $z = 0.7$ (the edge of the CMASS sample). Comparing our results to those using the galaxy distances from redMaPPer galaxy clusters as a reference, we find a similar result between filaments and clusters. Moreover, we find that the effect of clusters on the stellar mass of nearby galaxies depends on the galaxy's filamentary environment. Our findings illustrate the strong correlation of galaxy properties with proximity to density ridges, strongly supporting the claim that density ridges are good tracers of filaments.
• ### Topological Data Analysis(1609.08227)

Sept. 27, 2016 stat.ME
Topological Data Analysis (TDA) can broadly be described as a collection of data analysis methods that find structure in data. This includes: clustering, manifold estimation, nonlinear dimension reduction, mode estimation, ridge estimation and persistent homology. This paper reviews some of these methods.
• ### Density Level Sets: Asymptotics, Inference, and Visualization(1504.05438)

Sept. 5, 2016 math.ST, stat.TH, stat.ME
We derive asymptotic theory for the plug-in estimate for density level sets under Hausdoff loss. Based on the asymptotic theory, we propose two bootstrap confidence regions for level sets. The confidence regions can be used to perform tests for anomaly detection and clustering. We also introduce a technique to visualize high dimensional density level sets by combining mode clustering and multidimensional scaling.
• ### Results from the 2014 November 15th multi-chord stellar occultation by the TNO (229762) 2007 UK$_{126}$(1608.01030)

Aug. 2, 2016 astro-ph.EP
We present results derived from the first multi-chord stellar occultation by the trans-Neptunian object (229762) 2007 UK$_{126}$, observed on 2014 November 15. The event was observed by the Research and Education Collaborative Occultation Network (RECON) project and International Occultation Timing Association (IOTA) collaborators throughout the United States. Use of two different data analysis methods obtain a satisfactory fit to seven chords, yelding an elliptical fit to the chords with an equatorial radius of $R=338_{-10} ^{+15}$ km and equivalent radius of $R_{eq}=319_{-7} ^{+14}$ km. A circular fit also gives a radius of $R=324_{-23} ^{+30}$ km. Assuming that the object is a Maclaurin spheroid with indeterminate aspect angle, and using two published absolute magnitudes for the body, we derive possible ranges for geometric albedo between $p_{V}=0.159_{-0.013} ^{+0.007}$ and $p_{R}=0.189_{-0.015}^{+0.009}$, and for the body oblateness between $\epsilon=0.105_{-0.040} ^{+0.050}$ and $\epsilon=0.118_{-0.048} ^{+0.055}$. For a nominal rotational period of 11.05 h, an upper limit for density of $\rho=1740$ kg~m$^{-3}$ is estimated for the body.
• ### Finding Singular Features(1606.00265)

June 1, 2016 stat.ME, stat.ML
We present a method for finding high density, low-dimensional structures in noisy point clouds. These structures are sets with zero Lebesgue measure with respect to the $D$-dimensional ambient space and belong to a $d<D$ dimensional space. We call them "singular features." Hunting for singular features corresponds to finding unexpected or unknown structures hidden in point clouds belonging to $\R^D$. Our method outputs well defined sets of dimensions $d<D$. Unlike spectral clustering, the method works well in the presence of noise. We show how to find singular features by first finding ridges in the estimated density, followed by a filtering step based on the eigenvalues of the Hessian of the density.
• ### Nonparametric modal regression(1412.1716)

March 30, 2016 math.ST, stat.TH, stat.ME, stat.ML
Modal regression estimates the local modes of the distribution of $Y$ given $X=x$, instead of the mean, as in the usual regression sense, and can hence reveal important structure missed by usual regression methods. We study a simple nonparametric method for modal regression, based on a kernel density estimate (KDE) of the joint distribution of $Y$ and $X$. We derive asymptotic error bounds for this method, and propose techniques for constructing confidence sets and prediction sets. The latter is used to select the smoothing bandwidth of the underlying KDE. The idea behind modal regression is connected to many others, such as mixture regression and density ridge estimation, and we discuss these ties as well.
• ### Classification accuracy as a proxy for two sample testing(1602.02210)

May 24, 2019 cs.AI, math.ST, stat.TH, cs.LG, stat.ML
When data analysts train a classifier and check if its accuracy is significantly different from a half, they are implicitly performing a two-sample test. We investigate the statistical optimality of this indirect but flexible method in the high-dimensional setting of $d/n \to c \in (0,\infty)$. We provide a concrete answer for the case of distinguishing Gaussians with mean-difference $\delta$ and common (known or unknown) covariance $\Sigma$, by contrasting the indirect approach using variants of linear discriminant analysis (LDA) such as naive Bayes, with the direct approach using corresponding variants of Hotelling's test. Somewhat surprisingly, the indirect approach achieves the same power as the direct approach in terms of $n,d,\delta,\Sigma$, and is only worse by a constant factor, achieving an asymptotic relative efficiency of $1/\pi$ for the balanced sample case. Other results of independent interest are provided, such as minimax lower bounds, and optimality of Hotelling's test when $d=o(n)$. Simulation results validate our theory, and we present practical takeaway messages along with several open problems.
• ### Minimax Lower Bounds for Linear Independence Testing(1601.06259)

Jan. 23, 2016 cs.IT, math.IT, math.ST, stat.TH, cs.LG, stat.ML
Linear independence testing is a fundamental information-theoretic and statistical problem that can be posed as follows: given $n$ points $\{(X_i,Y_i)\}^n_{i=1}$ from a $p+q$ dimensional multivariate distribution where $X_i \in \mathbb{R}^p$ and $Y_i \in\mathbb{R}^q$, determine whether $a^T X$ and $b^T Y$ are uncorrelated for every $a \in \mathbb{R}^p, b\in \mathbb{R}^q$ or not. We give minimax lower bound for this problem (when $p+q,n \to \infty$, $(p+q)/n \leq \kappa < \infty$, without sparsity assumptions). In summary, our results imply that $n$ must be at least as large as $\sqrt {pq}/\|\Sigma_{XY}\|_F^2$ for any procedure (test) to have non-trivial power, where $\Sigma_{XY}$ is the cross-covariance matrix of $X,Y$. We also provide some evidence that the lower bound is tight, by connections to two-sample testing and regression in specific settings.
• ### A Comprehensive Approach to Mode Clustering(1406.1780)

Dec. 22, 2015 stat.ME, stat.ML
Mode clustering is a nonparametric method for clustering that defines clusters using the basins of attraction of a density estimator's modes. We provide several enhancements to mode clustering: (i) a soft variant of cluster assignment, (ii) a measure of connectivity between clusters, (iii) a technique for choosing the bandwidth, (iv) a method for denoising small clusters, and (v) an approach to visualizing the clusters. Combining all these enhancements gives us a complete procedure for clustering in multivariate problems. We also compare mode clustering to other clustering methods in several examples
• ### Asymptotic theory for density ridges(1406.5663)

Oct. 13, 2015 math.ST, stat.TH, stat.ME
The large sample theory of estimators for density modes is well understood. In this paper we consider density ridges, which are a higher-dimensional extension of modes. Modes correspond to zero-dimensional, local high-density regions in point clouds. Density ridges correspond to $s$-dimensional, local high-density regions in point clouds. We establish three main results. First we show that under appropriate regularity conditions, the local variation of the estimated ridge can be approximated by an empirical process. Second, we show that the distribution of the estimated ridge converges to a Gaussian process. Third, we establish that the bootstrap leads to valid confidence sets for density ridges.
• ### Statistical Analysis of Persistence Intensity Functions(1510.02502)

Oct. 8, 2015 stat.ME, stat.ML
Persistence diagrams are two-dimensional plots that summarize the topological features of functions and are an important part of topological data analysis. A problem that has received much attention is how deal with sets of persistence diagrams. How do we summarize them, average them or cluster them? One approach -- the persistence intensity function -- was introduced informally by Edelsbrunner, Ivanov, and Karasev (2012). Here we provide a modification and formalization of this approach. Using the persistence intensity function, we can visualize multiple diagrams, perform clustering and conduct two-sample tests.
• ### Cosmic Web Reconstruction through Density Ridges: Catalogue(1509.06443)

Sept. 22, 2015 stat.AP, astro-ph.CO
We construct a catalogue for filaments using a novel approach called SCMS (subspace constrained mean shift; Ozertem & Erdogmus 2011; Chen et al. 2015). SCMS is a gradient-based method that detects filaments through density ridges (smooth curves tracing high-density regions). A great advantage of SCMS is its uncertainty measure, which allows an evaluation of the errors for the detected filaments. To detect filaments, we use data from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey, which consist of three galaxy samples: the NYU main galaxy sample (MGS), the LOWZ sample and the CMASS sample. Each of the three dataset covers different redshift regions so that the combined sample allows detection of filaments up to z = 0.7. Our filament catalogue consists of a sequence of two-dimensional filament maps at different redshifts that provide several useful statistics on the evolution cosmic web. To construct the maps, we select spectroscopically confirmed galaxies within 0.050 < z < 0.700 and partition them into 130 bins. For each bin, we ignore the redshift, treating the galaxy observations as a 2-D data and detect filaments using SCMS. The filament catalogue consists of 130 individual 2-D filament maps, and each map comprises points on the detected filaments that describe the filamentary structures at a particular redshift. We also apply our filament catalogue to investigate galaxy luminosity and its relation with distance to filament. Using a volume-limited sample, we find strong evidence (6.1$\sigma$ - 12.3$\sigma$) that galaxies close to filaments are generally brighter than those at significant distance from filaments.
• ### Cosmic Web Reconstruction through Density Ridges: Method and Algorithm(1501.05303)

Aug. 28, 2015 stat.AP, astro-ph.CO
The detection and characterization of filamentary structures in the cosmic web allows cosmologists to constrain parameters that dictates the evolution of the Universe. While many filament estimators have been proposed, they generally lack estimates of uncertainty, reducing their inferential power. In this paper, we demonstrate how one may apply the Subspace Constrained Mean Shift (SCMS) algorithm (Ozertem and Erdogmus (2011); Genovese et al. (2012)) to uncover filamentary structure in galaxy data. The SCMS algorithm is a gradient ascent method that models filaments as density ridges, one-dimensional smooth curves that trace high-density regions within the point cloud. We also demonstrate how augmenting the SCMS algorithm with bootstrap-based methods of uncertainty estimation allows one to place uncertainty bands around putative filaments. We apply the SCMS method to datasets sampled from the P3M N-body simulation, with galaxy number densities consistent with SDSS and WFIRST-AFTA and to LOWZ and CMASS data from the Baryon Oscillation Spectroscopic Survey (BOSS). To further assess the efficacy of SCMS, we compare the relative locations of BOSS filaments with galaxy clusters in the redMaPPer catalog, and find that redMaPPer clusters are significantly closer (with p-values $< 10^{-9}$) to SCMS-detected filaments than to randomly selected galaxies.
• ### Investigating Galaxy-Filament Alignments in Hydrodynamic Simulations using Density Ridges(1508.04149)

Aug. 17, 2015 stat.AP, astro-ph.CO
In this paper, we study the filamentary structures and the galaxy alignment along filaments at redshift $z=0.06$ in the MassiveBlack-II simulation, a state-of-the-art, high-resolution hydrodynamical cosmological simulation which includes stellar and AGN feedback in a volume of (100 Mpc$/h$)$^3$. The filaments are constructed using the subspace constrained mean shift (SCMS; Ozertem & Erdogmus (2011) and Chen et al. (2015a)). First, we show that reconstructed filaments using galaxies and reconstructed filaments using dark matter particles are similar to each other; over $50\%$ of the points on the galaxy filaments have a corresponding point on the dark matter filaments within distance $0.13$ Mpc$/h$ (and vice versa) and this distance is even smaller at high-density regions. Second, we observe the alignment of the major principal axis of a galaxy with respect to the orientation of its nearest filament and detect a $2.5$ Mpc$/h$ critical radius for filament's influence on the alignment when the subhalo mass of this galaxy is between $10^9M_\odot/h$ and $10^{12}M_\odot/h$. Moreover, we find the alignment signal to increase significantly with the subhalo mass. Third, when a galaxy is close to filaments (less than $0.25$ Mpc$/h$), the galaxy alignment toward the nearest galaxy group depends on the galaxy subhalo mass. Finally, we find that galaxies close to filaments or groups tend to be rounder than those away from filaments or groups.