From a purely operational standpoint, the existence of microbes that can grow
under extreme conditions, or "extremophiles", leads to the question of how the
molecules making up these microbes can maintain both their structure and
function. While microbes that live under extremes of temperature have been
heavily studied, those that live under extremes of pressure have been
neglected, in part due to the difficulty of collecting samples and performing
experiments under the ambient conditions of the microbe. However, thermodynamic
arguments imply that the effects of pressure might lead to different organismal
solutions than from the effects of temperature. Observationally, some of these
solutions might be in the condensed matter properties of the intracellular
milieu in addition to genetic modifications of the macromolecules or repair
mechanisms for the macromolecules. Here, the effects of pressure on enzymes,
which are proteins essential for the growth and reproduction of an organism,
and some adaptations against these effects are reviewed and amplified by the
results from molecular dynamics simulations. The aim is to provide biological
background for soft matter studies of these systems under pressure.
This Comment points out a number of errors in the recent paper by Zarechnaya,
Dubrovinskaia, Dubrovinsky, et al. (Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 185501 (2009)).
Results and conclusions presented by Zarechnaya et al. (2009) are either
incorrect or have been presented before.
We present a unified view of orientational ordering in phases I, II, and III
of solid hydrogen. Phases II and III are orientationally ordered, while the
ordering objects in phase II are angular momenta of rotating molecules, and in
phase III the molecules themselves. This concept provides quantitative
explanation of the vibron softening, libron and roton spectra, and increase of
the IR vibron oscillator strength in phase III. The temperature dependence of
the effective charge parallels the frequency shifts of the IR and Raman
vibrons. All three quantities are linear in the order parameter.