-
We report a new Fast Radio Burst (FRB) discovered in real-time as part of the
UTMOST project at the Molonglo Observatory Synthesis Radio Telescope (MOST).
FRB170827 is the first detected with our low-latency ($< 24$ s),
machine-learning-based FRB detection system. The FRB discovery was accompanied
by the capture of voltage data at the native time and frequency resolution of
the observing system, enabling coherent dedispersion and detailed off-line
analysis, which have unveiled fine temporal and frequency structure. The
dispersion measure (DM) of 176.80 $\pm$ 0.04 pc cm$^{-3}$, is the lowest of the
FRB population. The Milky Way contribution along the line of sight is $\sim$ 40
pc cm$^{-3}$, leaving an excess DM of $\sim$ 145 pc cm$^{-3}$. The FRB has a
fluence $>$ 20 $\pm$ 7 Jy ms, and is narrow, with a width of $\sim$ 400 $\mu$s
at 10$\%$ of its maximum amplitude. However, the burst shows three temporal
components, the narrowest of which is $\sim$ 30 $\mu$s, and a scattering
timescale of $4.1 \pm 2.7$ $\mu$s. The FRB shows spectral modulations on
frequency scales of 1.5 MHz and 0.1 MHz. Both are prominent in the dynamic
spectrum, which shows a very bright region of emission between 841 and 843 MHz,
and weaker, patchy emission across the entire band. We show the fine spectral
structure could arise in the FRB host galaxy, or its immediate vicinity.
-
PSR J0922+0638 (B0919+06) shows unexplained anomalous variations in the
on-pulse phase, where the pulse appears to episodically move to an earlier
longitude for a few tens of rotations before reverting to the usual phase for
approximately several hundred to more than a thousand rotations. These events,
where the pulse moves in phase by up to 5$^{\circ}$, have been previously
detected in observations from $\sim$300 to 2000 MHz. We present simultaneous
observations from the Effelsberg 100-m radio telescope at 1350 MHz and the
Bornim (Potsdam) station of the LOw Frequency ARray at 150 MHz. Our
observations present the first evidence for an absence of the anomalous
phase-shifting behaviour at 150 MHz. Instead, the observed intensity at the
usual pulse-phase typically decreases, often showing a pseudo-nulling feature
corresponding to the times when phase shifts are observed at 1350 MHz. The
presence of weak emission at the usual pulse-phase supports the theory that
these shifts may result from processes similar to the 'profile-absorption'
expected to operate for PSR J0814+7429 (B0809+74). A possible mechanism for
this could be intrinsic variations of the emission within the pulsar's beam
combined with absorption by expanding shells of electrons in the line of sight.
-
Symmetries play an important role in modern theories of gravity. The strong
equivalence principle (SEP) constitutes a collection of gravitational
symmetries which are all implemented by general relativity. Alternative
theories, however, are generally expected to violate some aspects of SEP. We
test three aspects of SEP using observed change rates in the orbital period and
eccentricity of binary pulsar J1713+0747: 1. the gravitational constant's
constancy as part of locational invariance of gravitation; 2. the
post-Newtonian parameter $\hat{\alpha}_3$ in gravitational Lorentz invariance;
3. the universality of free fall (UFF) for strongly self-gravitating bodies.
Based on the pulsar timing result of the combined dataset from the North
American Nanohertz Gravitational Observatory (NANOGrav) and the European Pulsar
Timing Array (EPTA), we find $\dot{G}/G = (-0.1 \pm 0.9) \times 10^{-12}\,{\rm
yr}^{-1}$, which is weaker than Solar system limits, but applies for strongly
self-gravitating objects. Furthermore, we obtain the constraints $|\Delta|<
0.002$ for the UFF test and $-3\times10^{-20} < \hat{\alpha}_3 <
4\times10^{-20}$ at 95% confidence. These are the first direct UFF and
$\hat{\alpha}_3$ tests based on pulsar binaries, and they overcome various
limitations of previous tests.
-
We have observed a complex and continuous change in the integrated pulse
profile of PSR B2217+47, manifested as additional components trailing the main
peak. These transient components are detected over 6 years at $150$ MHz using
the LOw Frequency ARray (LOFAR), but they are not seen in contemporaneous
Lovell observations at $1.5$ GHz. We argue that propagation effects in the
ionized interstellar medium (IISM) are the most likely cause. The putative
structures in the IISM causing the profile variation are roughly half-way
between the pulsar and the Earth and have transverse radii $R \sim 30$ AU. We
consider different models for the structures. Under the assumption of spherical
symmetry, their implied average electron density is $\overline{n}_e \sim 100$
cm$^{-3}$. Since PSR B2217+47 is more than an order of magnitude brighter than
the average pulsar population visible to LOFAR, similar profile variations
would not have been identified in most pulsars, suggesting that subtle profile
variations in low-frequency profiles might be more common than we have observed
to date. Systematic studies of these variations at low frequencies can provide
a new tool to investigate the proprieties of the IISM and the limits to the
precision of pulsar timing.
-
Timing results for the black-widow pulsar J2051-0827 are presented, using a
21-year dataset from four European Pulsar Timing Array telescopes and the
Parkes radio telescope. This dataset, which is the longest published to date
for a black-widow system, allows for an improved analysis that addresses
previously unknown biases. While secular variations, as identified in previous
analyses, are recovered, short-term variations are detected for the first time.
Concurrently, a significant decrease of approx. 2.5x10-3 cm-3 pc in the
dispersion measure associated with PSR J2051-0827 is measured for the first
time and improvements are also made to estimates of the proper motion. Finally,
PSR J2051-0827 is shown to have entered a relatively stable state suggesting
the possibility of its eventual inclusion in pulsar timing arrays.
-
We present evidence for a small glitch in the spin evolution of the
millisecond pulsar J0613$-$0200, using the EPTA Data Release 1.0, combined with
Jodrell Bank analogue filterbank TOAs recorded with the Lovell telescope and
Effelsberg Pulsar Observing System TOAs. A spin frequency step of 0.82(3) nHz
and frequency derivative step of ${-1.6(39) \times 10^{-19}\,\text{Hz} \
\text{s}^{-1}}$ are measured at the epoch of MJD 50888(30). After PSR
B1821$-$24A, this is only the second glitch ever observed in a millisecond
pulsar, with a fractional size in frequency of ${\Delta \nu/\nu=2.5(1) \times
10^{-12}}$, which is several times smaller than the previous smallest glitch.
PSR J0613$-$0200 is used in gravitational wave searches with pulsar timing
arrays, and is to date only the second such pulsar to have experienced a glitch
in a combined 886 pulsar-years of observations. We find that accurately
modelling the glitch does not impact the timing precision for pulsar timing
array applications. We estimate that for the current set of millisecond pulsars
included in the International Pulsar Timing Array, there is a probability of
$\sim 50$% that another glitch will be observed in a timing array pulsar within
10 years.
-
We present first results from a LOFAR census of non-recycled pulsars. The
census includes almost all such pulsars known (194 sources) at declinations
${\rm Dec}> 8^\circ$ and Galactic latitudes $|{\rm Gb}| > 3^\circ$, regardless
of their expected flux densities and scattering times. Each pulsar was observed
for $\geq 20$ minutes in the contiguous frequency range of 110--188 MHz.
Full-Stokes data were recorded. We present the dispersion measures, flux
densities, and calibrated total intensity profiles for the 158 pulsars detected
in the sample. The median uncertainty in census dispersion measures ($1.5
\times 10^{-3}$ pc cm$^{-3}$) is ten times smaller, on average, than in the
ATNF pulsar catalogue. We combined census flux densities with those in the
literature and fitted the resulting broadband spectra with single or broken
power-law functions. For 48 census pulsars such fits are being published for
the first time. Typically, the choice between single and broken power-laws, as
well as the location of the spectral break, were highly influenced by the
spectral coverage of the available flux density measurements. In particular,
the inclusion of measurements below 100 MHz appears essential for investigating
the low-frequency turnover in the spectra for most of the census pulsars. For
several pulsars, we compared the spectral indices from different works and
found the typical spread of values to be within 0.5--1.5, suggesting a
prevailing underestimation of spectral index errors in the literature. The
census observations yielded some unexpected individual source results, as we
describe in the paper. Lastly, we will provide this unique sample of wide-band,
low-frequency pulse profiles via the European Pulsar Network Database.
-
We report on the high-precision timing of 42 radio millisecond pulsars (MSPs)
observed by the European Pulsar Timing Array (EPTA). This EPTA Data Release 1.0
extends up to mid-2014 and baselines range from 7-18 years. It forms the basis
for the stochastic gravitational-wave background, anisotropic background, and
continuous-wave limits recently presented by the EPTA elsewhere. The Bayesian
timing analysis performed with TempoNest yields the detection of several new
parameters: seven parallaxes, nine proper motions and, in the case of six
binary pulsars, an apparent change of the semi-major axis. We find the NE2001
Galactic electron density model to be a better match to our parallax distances
(after correction from the Lutz-Kelker bias) than the M2 and M3 models by
Schnitzeler (2012). However, we measure an average uncertainty of 80\%
(fractional) for NE2001, three times larger than what is typically assumed in
the literature. We revisit the transverse velocity distribution for a set of 19
isolated and 57 binary MSPs and find no statistical difference between these
two populations. We detect Shapiro delay in the timing residuals of PSRs
J1600$-$3053 and J1918$-$0642, implying pulsar and companion masses
$m_p=1.22_{-0.35}^{+0.5} \text{M}_{\odot}$, $m_c = 0.21_{-0.04}^{+0.06}
\text{M}_{\odot }$ and $m_p=1.25_{-0.4}^{+0.6} \text{M}_{\odot}$, $m_c =
0.23_{-0.05}^{+0.07} \text{M}_{\odot }$, respectively. Finally, we use the
measurement of the orbital period derivative to set a stringent constraint on
the distance to PSRs J1012$+$5307 and J1909$-$3744, and set limits on the
longitude of ascending node through the search of the annual-orbital parallax
for PSRs J1600$-$3053 and J1909$-$3744.
-
We analyse the stochastic properties of the 49 pulsars that comprise the
first International Pulsar Timing Array (IPTA) data release. We use Bayesian
methodology, performing model selection to determine the optimal description of
the stochastic signals present in each pulsar. In addition to spin-noise and
dispersion-measure (DM) variations, these models can include timing noise
unique to a single observing system, or frequency band. We show the improved
radio-frequency coverage and presence of overlapping data from different
observing systems in the IPTA data set enables us to separate both system and
band-dependent effects with much greater efficacy than in the individual PTA
data sets. For example, we show that PSR J1643$-$1224 has, in addition to DM
variations, significant band-dependent noise that is coherent between PTAs
which we interpret as coming from time-variable scattering or refraction in the
ionised interstellar medium. Failing to model these different contributions
appropriately can dramatically alter the astrophysical interpretation of the
stochastic signals observed in the residuals. In some cases, the spectral
exponent of the spin noise signal can vary from 1.6 to 4 depending upon the
model, which has direct implications for the long-term sensitivity of the
pulsar to a stochastic gravitational-wave (GW) background. By using a more
appropriate model, however, we can greatly improve a pulsar's sensitivity to
GWs. For example, including system and band-dependent signals in the PSR
J0437$-$4715 data set improves the upper limit on a fiducial GW background by
$\sim 60\%$ compared to a model that includes DM variations and spin-noise
only.
-
The sensitivity of Pulsar Timing Arrays to gravitational waves depends on the
noise present in the individual pulsar timing data. Noise may be either
intrinsic or extrinsic to the pulsar. Intrinsic sources of noise will include
rotational instabilities, for example. Extrinsic sources of noise include
contributions from physical processes which are not sufficiently well modelled,
for example, dispersion and scattering effects, analysis errors and
instrumental instabilities. We present the results from a noise analysis for 42
millisecond pulsars (MSPs) observed with the European Pulsar Timing Array. For
characterising the low-frequency, stochastic and achromatic noise component, or
"timing noise", we employ two methods, based on Bayesian and frequentist
statistics. For 25 MSPs, we achieve statistically significant measurements of
their timing noise parameters and find that the two methods give consistent
results. For the remaining 17 MSPs, we place upper limits on the timing noise
amplitude at the 95% confidence level. We additionally place an upper limit on
the contribution to the pulsar noise budget from errors in the reference
terrestrial time standards (below 1%), and we find evidence for a noise
component which is present only in the data of one of the four used telescopes.
Finally, we estimate that the timing noise of individual pulsars reduces the
sensitivity of this data set to an isotropic, stochastic GW background by a
factor of >9.1 and by a factor of >2.3 for continuous GWs from resolvable,
inspiralling supermassive black-hole binaries with circular orbits.
-
LOFAR offers the unique capability of observing pulsars across the 10-240 MHz
frequency range with a fractional bandwidth of roughly 50%. This spectral range
is well-suited for studying the frequency evolution of pulse profile morphology
caused by both intrinsic and extrinsic effects: such as changing emission
altitude in the pulsar magnetosphere or scatter broadening by the interstellar
medium, respectively. The magnitude of most of these effects increases rapidly
towards low frequencies. LOFAR can thus address a number of open questions
about the nature of radio pulsar emission and its propagation through the
interstellar medium. We present the average pulse profiles of 100 pulsars
observed in the two LOFAR frequency bands: High Band (120-167 MHz, 100
profiles) and Low Band (15-62 MHz, 26 profiles). We compare them with
Westerbork Synthesis Radio Telescope (WSRT) and Lovell Telescope observations
at higher frequencies (350 and1400 MHz) in order to study the profile
evolution. The profiles are aligned in absolute phase by folding with a new set
of timing solutions from the Lovell Telescope, which we present along with
precise dispersion measures obtained with LOFAR. We find that the profile
evolution with decreasing radio frequency does not follow a specific trend but,
depending on the geometry of the pulsar, new components can enter into, or be
hidden from, view. Nonetheless, in general our observations confirm the
widening of pulsar profiles at low frequencies, as expected from
radius-to-frequency mapping or birefringence theories. We offer this catalog of
low-frequency pulsar profiles in a user friendly way via the EPN Database of
Pulsar Profiles (http://www.epta.eu.org/epndb/).
-
We report the detection of 48 millisecond pulsars (MSPs) out of 75 observed
thus far using the LOFAR in the frequency range 110-188 MHz. We have also
detected three MSPs out of nine observed in the frequency range 38-77 MHz. This
is the largest sample of MSPs ever observed at these low frequencies, and half
of the detected MSPs were observed for the first time at frequencies below 200
MHz. We present the average pulse profiles of the detected MSPs, their
effective pulse widths, and flux densities and compare these with higher
observing frequencies. The flux-calibrated, multifrequency LOFAR pulse profiles
are publicly available via the EPN Database of Pulsar Profiles. We also present
average values of dispersion measures (DM) and discuss DM and profile
variations. About 35% of the MSPs show strong narrow profiles, another 25%
exhibit scattered profiles, and the rest are only weakly detected. A
qualitative comparison of LOFAR profiles with those at higher radio frequencies
shows constant separation between profile components. Similarly, the profile
widths are consistent with those observed at higher frequencies, unless
scattering dominates at the lowest frequencies. This is very different from
what is observed for normal pulsars and suggests a compact emission region in
the MSP magnetosphere. The amplitude ratio of the profile components, on the
other hand, can dramatically change towards low frequencies, often with the
trailing component becoming dominant. As previously demonstrated this can be
caused by aberration and retardation. This data set enables high-precision
studies of pulse profile evolution with frequency, dispersion, Faraday
rotation, and scattering in the interstellar medium. Characterising and
correcting these systematic effects may improve pulsar-timing precision at
higher observing frequencies, where pulsar timing array projects aim to
directly detect gravitational waves.
-
We present timing models for 20 millisecond pulsars in the Parkes Pulsar
Timing Array. The precision of the parameter measurements in these models has
been improved over earlier results by using longer data sets and modelling the
non-stationary noise. We describe a new noise modelling procedure and
demonstrate its effectiveness using simulated data. Our methodology includes
the addition of annual dispersion measure (DM) variations to the timing models
of some pulsars. We present the first significant parallax measurements for
PSRs J1024-0719, J1045-4509, J1600-3053, J1603-7202, and J1730-2304, as well as
the first significant measurements of some post-Keplerian orbital parameters in
six binary pulsars, caused by kinematic effects. Improved Shapiro delay
measurements have resulted in much improved pulsar mass measurements,
particularly for PSRs J0437-4715 and J1909-3744 with $M_p=1.44\pm0.07$
$M_\odot$ and $M_p=1.47\pm0.03$ $M_\odot$ respectively. The improved orbital
period-derivative measurement for PSR J0437-4715 results in a derived distance
measurement at the 0.16% level of precision, $D=156.79\pm0.25$ pc, one of the
most fractionally precise distance measurements of any star to date.
-
Gravitational waves are expected to be radiated by supermassive black hole
binaries formed during galaxy mergers. A stochastic superposition of
gravitational waves from all such binary systems will modulate the arrival
times of pulses from radio pulsars. Using observations of millisecond pulsars
obtained with the Parkes radio telescope, we constrain the characteristic
amplitude of this background, $A_{\rm c,yr}$, to be < $1.0\times10^{-15}$ with
95% confidence. This limit excludes predicted ranges for $A_{\rm c,yr}$ from
current models with 91-99.7% probability. We conclude that binary evolution is
either stalled or dramatically accelerated by galactic-center environments, and
that higher-cadence and shorter-wavelength observations would result in an
increased sensitivity to gravitational waves.
-
The paucity of observed supermassive black hole binaries (SMBHBs) may imply
that the gravitational wave background (GWB) from this population is
anisotropic, rendering existing analyses sub-optimal. We present the first
constraints on the angular distribution of a nanohertz stochastic GWB from
circular, inspiral-driven SMBHBs using the $2015$ European Pulsar Timing Array
data [Desvignes et al. (in prep.)]. Our analysis of the GWB in the $\sim 2 -
90$ nHz band shows consistency with isotropy, with the strain amplitude in
$l>0$ spherical harmonic multipoles $\lesssim 40\%$ of the monopole value. We
expect that these more general techniques will become standard tools to probe
the angular distribution of source populations.
-
We present the highest-quality polarisation profiles to date of 16
non-recycled pulsars and four millisecond pulsars, observed below 200 MHz with
the LOFAR high-band antennas. Based on the observed profiles, we perform an
initial investigation of expected observational effects resulting from the
propagation of polarised emission in the pulsar magnetosphere and the
interstellar medium.
The predictions of magnetospheric birefringence in pulsars have been tested
using spectra of the pulse width and fractional polarisation from
multifrequency data. The derived spectra offer only partial support for the
expected effects of birefringence on the polarisation properties, with only
about half of our sample being consistent with the model's predictions. It is
noted that for some pulsars these measurements are contaminated by the effects
of interstellar scattering. For a number of pulsars in our sample, we have
observed significant variations in the amount of Faraday rotation as a function
of pulse phase, which is possibly an artefact of scattering. These variations
are typically two orders of magnitude smaller than that observed at 1400 MHz by
Noutsos et al. (2009), for a different sample of southern pulsars. In this
paper we present a possible explanation for the difference in magnitude of this
effect between the two frequencies, based on scattering. Finally, we have
estimated the magnetospheric emission heights of low-frequency radiation from
four pulsars, based on the phase lags between the flux-density and the PA
profiles, and the theoretical framework of Blaskiewicz, Cordes & Wasserman
(1991). These estimates yielded heights of a few hundred km; at least for PSR
B1133+16, this is consistent with emission heights derived based on
radius-to-frequency mapping, but is up to a few times larger than the recent
upper limit based on pulsar timing.
-
We present results of an all-sky search in the Parkes Pulsar Timing Array
(PPTA) Data Release 1 data set for continuous gravitational waves (GWs) in the
frequency range from $5\times 10^{-9}$ to $2\times 10^{-7}$ Hz. Such signals
could be produced by individual supermassive binary black hole systems in the
early stage of coalescence. We phase up the pulsar timing array data set to
form, for each position on the sky, two data streams that correspond to the two
GW polarizations and then carry out an optimal search for GW signals on these
data streams. Since no statistically significant GWs were detected, we place
upper limits on the intrinsic GW strain amplitude $h_0$ for a range of GW
frequencies. For example, at $10^{-8}$ Hz our analysis has excluded with $95\%$
confidence the presence of signals with $h_0\geqslant 1.7\times 10^{-14}$. Our
new limits are about a factor of four more stringent than those of Yardley et
al. (2010) based on an earlier PPTA data set and a factor of two better than
those reported in the recent Arzoumanian et al. (2014) paper. We also present
PPTA directional sensitivity curves and find that for the most sensitive region
on the sky, the current data set is sensitive to GWs from circular supermassive
binary black holes with chirp masses of $10^{9} M_{\odot}$ out to a luminosity
distance of about 100 Mpc. Finally, we set an upper limit of $4 \times 10^{-3}
{\rm{Mpc}}^{-3} {\rm{Gyr}}^{-1}$ at $95\%$ confidence on the coalescence rate
of nearby ($z \lesssim 0.1$) supermassive binary black holes in circular orbits
with chirp masses of $10^{10}M_{\odot}$.
-
We have conducted two pilot surveys for radio pulsars and fast transients
with the Low-Frequency Array (LOFAR) around 140 MHz and here report on the
first low-frequency fast-radio burst limit and the discovery of two new
pulsars. The first survey, the LOFAR Pilot Pulsar Survey (LPPS), observed a
large fraction of the northern sky, ~1.4 x 10^4 sq. deg, with 1-hr dwell times.
Each observation covered ~75 sq. deg using 7 independent fields formed by
incoherently summing the high-band antenna fields. The second pilot survey, the
LOFAR Tied-Array Survey (LOTAS), spanned ~600 sq. deg, with roughly a 5-fold
increase in sensitivity compared with LPPS. Using a coherent sum of the 6 LOFAR
"Superterp" stations, we formed 19 tied-array beams, together covering 4 sq.
deg per pointing. From LPPS we derive a limit on the occurrence, at 142 MHz, of
dispersed radio bursts of < 150 /day/sky, for bursts brighter than S > 107 Jy
for the narrowest searched burst duration of 0.66 ms. In LPPS, we re-detected
65 previously known pulsars. LOTAS discovered two pulsars, the first with LOFAR
or any digital aperture array. LOTAS also re-detected 27 previously known
pulsars. These pilot studies show that LOFAR can efficiently carry out all-sky
surveys for pulsars and fast transients, and they set the stage for further
surveying efforts using LOFAR and the planned low-frequency component of the
Square Kilometer Array.
-
High-sensitivity radio-frequency observations of millisecond pulsars usually
show stochastic, broadband, pulse-shape variations intrinsic to the pulsar
emission process. These variations induce jitter noise in pulsar timing
observations; understanding the properties of this noise is of particular
importance for the effort to detect gravitational waves with pulsar timing
arrays. We assess the short-term profile and timing stability of 22 millisecond
pulsars that are part of the Parkes Pulsar Timing Array sample by examining
intra-observation arrival time variability and single-pulse phenomenology. In 7
of the 22 pulsars, in the band centred at approximately 1400MHz, we find that
the brightest observations are limited by intrinsic jitter. We find consistent
results, either detections or upper limits, for jitter noise in other frequency
bands. PSR J1909-3744 shows the lowest levels of jitter noise, which we
estimate to contribute $\sim$10 ns root mean square error to the arrival times
for hour-duration observations. Larger levels of jitter noise are found in
pulsars with wider pulses and distributions of pulse intensities. The jitter
noise in PSR J0437-4715 decorrelates over a bandwidth of $\sim$2 GHz. We show
that the uncertainties associated with timing pulsar models can be improved by
including physically motivated jitter uncertainties. Pulse-shape variations
will limit the timing precision at future, more sensitive, telescopes; it is
imperative to account for this noise when designing instrumentation and timing
campaigns for these facilities.
-
Single pulses from radio pulsars contain a wealth of information about
emission and propagation in the magnetosphere and insight into their timing
properties. It was recently demonstrated that single-pulse emission is
responsible for limiting the timing stability of the brightest of millisecond
pulsars. We report on an analysis of more than a million single-pulses from PSR
J0437-4715 and present various statistical properties such as the
signal-to-noise ratio (S/N) distribution, timing and polarimetry of average
profiles integrated from subpulses with chosen S/N cut-offs, modulation
properties of the emission, phase-resolved statistics of the S/N, and two
dimensional spherical histograms of the polarization vector orientation. The
last of these indicates the presence of orthogonally polarised modes (OPMs).
Combined with the dependence of the polarisation fraction on the S/N and
polarimetry of the brightest pulses, the existence of OPMs constrains pulsar
emission mechanisms and models for the plasma physics in the magnetosphere.
-
The formation and growth processes of supermassive black holes (SMBHs) are
not well constrained. SMBH population models, however, provide specific
predictions for the properties of the gravitational-wave background (GWB) from
binary SMBHs in merging galaxies throughout the Universe. Using observations
from the Parkes Pulsar Timing Array, we constrain the fractional GWB energy
density with 95% confidence to be ${\Omega}_{GW}(H_0/73 {\rm km} {\rm s}^{-1}
{\rm Mpc}^{-1})^2 < 1.3 \times 10^{-9}$ at a frequency of 2.8 nHz, which is
approximately a factor of six more stringent than previous limits. We compare
our limit to models of the SMBH population and find inconsistencies at
confidence levels between 46% and 91%. For example, the standard galaxy
formation model implemented in the Millennium simulations is inconsistent with
our limit with 50% probability.