-
On the strength of a double Nobel prize winning experiment (Super)Kamiokande
and an extremely successful long baseline neutrino programme, the third
generation Water Cherenkov detector, Hyper-Kamiokande, is being developed by an
international collaboration as a leading worldwide experiment based in Japan.
The Hyper-Kamiokande detector will be hosted in the Tochibora mine, about 295
km away from the J-PARC proton accelerator research complex in Tokai, Japan.
The currently existing accelerator will be steadily upgraded to reach a MW beam
by the start of the experiment. A suite of near detectors will be vital to
constrain the beam for neutrino oscillation measurements. A new cavern will be
excavated at the Tochibora mine to host the detector. The experiment will be
the largest underground water Cherenkov detector in the world and will be
instrumented with new technology photosensors, faster and with higher quantum
efficiency than the ones in Super-Kamiokande. The science that will be
developed will be able to shape the future theoretical framework and
generations of experiments. Hyper-Kamiokande will be able to measure with the
highest precision the leptonic CP violation that could explain the baryon
asymmetry in the Universe. The experiment also has a demonstrated excellent
capability to search for proton decay, providing a significant improvement in
discovery sensitivity over current searches for the proton lifetime. The
atmospheric neutrinos will allow to determine the neutrino mass ordering and,
together with the beam, able to precisely test the three-flavour neutrino
oscillation paradigm and search for new phenomena. A strong astrophysical
programme will be carried out at the experiment that will also allow to measure
precisely solar neutrino oscillation.
-
Hyper-Kamiokande consists of two identical water-Cherenkov detectors of total
520~kt with the first one in Japan at 295~km from the J-PARC neutrino beam with
2.5$^{\textrm{o}}$ Off-Axis Angles (OAAs), and the second one possibly in Korea
in a later stage. Having the second detector in Korea would benefit almost all
areas of neutrino oscillation physics mainly due to longer baselines. There are
several candidate sites in Korea with baselines of 1,000$\sim$1,300~km and OAAs
of 1$^{\textrm{o}}$$\sim$3$^{\textrm{o}}$. We conducted sensitivity studies on
neutrino oscillation physics for a second detector, either in Japan (JD
$\times$ 2) or Korea (JD + KD) and compared the results with a single detector
in Japan. Leptonic CP violation sensitivity is improved especially when the CP
is non-maximally violated. The larger matter effect at Korean candidate sites
significantly enhances sensitivities to non-standard interactions of neutrinos
and mass ordering determination. Current studies indicate the best sensitivity
is obtained at Mt. Bisul (1,088~km baseline, $1.3^\circ$ OAA). Thanks to a
larger (1,000~m) overburden than the first detector site, clear improvements to
sensitivities for solar and supernova relic neutrino searches are expected.
-
A search for the exotic meson $X(5568)$ decaying into the $B^0_s \pi^{\pm}$
final state is performed using data corresponding to $9.6 \textrm{fb}^{-1}$
from $p{\bar p}$ collisions at $\sqrt{s} = 1960$ GeV recorded by the Collider
Detector at Fermilab. No evidence for this state is found and an upper limit of
6.7\% at the 95\% confidence level is set on the fraction of $B^0_s$ produced
through the $X(5568) \rightarrow B^0_s \, \pi^{\pm}$ process.
-
In line with its terms of reference the ICFA Neutrino Panel has developed a
roadmapfor the international, accelerator-based neutrino programme. A "roadmap
discussion document" was presented in May 2016 taking into account the
peer-group-consultation described in the Panel's initial report. The "roadmap
discussion document" was used to solicit feedback from the neutrino
community---and more broadly, the particle- and astroparticle-physics
communities---and the various stakeholders in the programme. The roadmap, the
conclusions and recommendations presented in this document take into account
the comments received following the publication of the roadmap discussion
document.
With its roadmap the Panel documents the approved objectives and milestones
of the experiments that are presently in operation or under construction.
Approval, construction and exploitation milestones are presented for
experiments that are being considered for approval. The timetable proposed by
the proponents is presented for experiments that are not yet being considered
formally for approval. Based on this information, the evolution of the
precision with which the critical parameters governinger the neutrino are known
has been evaluated. Branch or decision points have been identified based on the
anticipated evolution in precision. The branch or decision points have in turn
been used to identify desirable timelines for the neutrino-nucleus cross
section and hadro-production measurements that are required to maximise the
integrated scientific output of the programme. The branch points have also been
used to identify the timeline for the R&D required to take the programme beyond
the horizon of the next generation of experiments. The theory and phenomenology
programme, including nuclear theory, required to ensure that maximum benefit is
derived from the experimental programme is also discussed.
-
A measurement of the inclusive production cross section of isolated prompt
photons in proton-antiproton collisions at center-of-mass energy
$\sqrt{s}$=1.96TeV is presented. The results are obtained using the full Run II
data sample collected with the Collider Detector at the Fermilab Tevatron,
which corresponds to an integrated luminosity of 9.5fb$^{-1}$. The cross
section is measured as a function of photon transverse energy, $E_T^{\gamma}$,
in the range 30$ < E_T^{\gamma} <$500GeV and in the pseudorapidity region
$|\eta^{\gamma}|<$1.0. The results are compared with predictions from
parton-shower Monte Carlo models at leading order in quantum chromodynamics
(QCD) and from next-to-leading order perturbative QCD calculations. The latter
show good agreement with the measured cross section.
-
We report on a measurement of the $D^{+}$-meson production cross section as a
function of transverse momentum ($p_T$) in proton-antiproton ($p\bar{p}$)
collisions at 1.96 TeV center-of-mass energy, using the full data set collected
by the Collider Detector at Fermilab in Tevatron Run II and corresponding to 10
fb$^{-1}$ of integrated luminosity. We use $D^{+} \to K^-\pi^+\pi^+$ decays
fully reconstructed in the central rapidity region $|y|<1$ with transverse
momentum down to 1.5 GeV/$c$, a range previously unexplored in $p\bar{p}$
collisions. Inelastic $p\bar{p}$-scattering events are selected online using
minimally-biasing requirements followed by an optimized offline selection. The
$K^-\pi^+\pi^+$ mass distribution is used to identify the $D^+$ signal, and the
$D^+$ transverse impact-parameter distribution is used to separate prompt
production, occurring directly in the hard scattering process, from secondary
production from $b$-hadron decays. We obtain a prompt $D^+$ signal of 2950
candidates corresponding to a total cross section $\sigma(D^+, 1.5 < p_T <
14.5~\mbox{GeV/}c, |y|<1) = 71.9 \pm 6.8 (\mbox{stat}) \pm 9.3
(\mbox{syst})~\mu$b. While the measured cross sections are consistent with
theoretical estimates in each $p_T$ bin, the shape of the observed $p_T$
spectrum is softer than the expectation from quantum chromodynamics. The
results are unique in $p\bar{p}$ collisions and can improve the shape and
uncertainties of future predictions.
-
We present an in-situ method of measuring the relative attenuation length of
gadolinium-loaded liquid scintillator in the RENO detectors using radioactive
source calibration data without requiring any PMT performance model. We
observed the degradation of the attenuation length of the gadolinium-loaded
liquid scintillator in the RENO detectors by ~50% over a period of about 4
years.
-
We present a measurement of the total {\it WW} and {\it WZ} production cross
sections in $p\bar{p}$ collision at $\sqrt{s}=1.96$ TeV, in a final state
consistent with leptonic $W$ boson decay and jets originating from heavy-flavor
quarks from either a $W$ or a $Z$ boson decay. This analysis uses the full data
set collected with the CDF II detector during Run II of the Tevatron collider,
corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 9.4 fb$^{-1}$. An analysis of the
dijet mass spectrum provides $3.7\sigma$ evidence of the summed production
processes of either {\it WW} or {\it WZ} bosons with a measured total cross
section of $\sigma_{WW+WZ} = 13.7\pm 3.9$~pb. Independent measurements of the
{\it WW} and {\it WZ} production cross sections are allowed by the different
heavy-flavor decay-patterns of the $W$ and $Z$ bosons and by the analysis of
secondary-decay vertices reconstructed within heavy-flavor jets. The
productions of {\it WW} and of {\it WZ} dibosons are independently seen with
significances of $2.9\sigma$ and $2.1\sigma$, respectively, with total cross
sections of $\sigma_{WW}= 9.4\pm 4.2$~pb and
$\sigma_{WZ}=3.7^{+2.5}_{-2.2}$~pb. The measurements are consistent with
standard-model predictions.
-
At the Fermilab Tevatron proton-antiproton ($p\bar{p}$) collider, Drell-Yan
lepton pairs are produced in the process $p \bar{p} \rightarrow e^+e^- + X$
through an intermediate $\gamma^*/Z$ boson. The forward-backward asymmetry in
the polar-angle distribution of the $e^-$ as a function of the $e^+e^-$-pair
mass is used to obtain $\sin^2\theta^{\rm lept}_{\rm eff}$, the effective
leptonic determination of the electroweak-mixing parameter $\sin^2\theta_W$.
The measurement sample, recorded by the Collider Detector at Fermilab (CDF),
corresponds to 9.4~fb$^{-1}$ of integrated luminosity from $p\bar{p}$
collisions at a center-of-momentum energy of 1.96 TeV, and is the full CDF Run
II data set. The value of $\sin^2\theta^{\rm lept}_{\rm eff}$ is found to be
$0.23248 \pm 0.00053$. The combination with the previous CDF measurement based
on $\mu^+\mu^-$ pairs yields $\sin^2\theta^{\rm lept}_{\rm eff} = 0.23221 \pm
0.00046$. This result, when interpreted within the specified context of the
standard model assuming $\sin^2 \theta_W = 1 - M_W^2/M_Z^2$ and that the $W$-
and $Z$-boson masses are on-shell, yields $\sin^2\theta_W = 0.22400 \pm
0.00045$, or equivalently a $W$-boson mass of $80.328 \pm 0.024 \;{\rm
GeV}/c^2$.
-
We describe a measurement of the ratio of the cross sections times branching
fractions of the $B_c^+$ meson in the decay mode $B_c^+ \rightarrow J/\psi
\mu\nu$ to the $B^+$ meson in the decay mode $B^+ \rightarrow J/\psi K^+$ in
proton-antiproton collisions at center-of-mass energy $\sqrt{s}=1.96$ TeV. The
measurement is based on the complete CDF Run II data set, which comes from an
integrated luminosity of $8.7\,{\rm fb}^{-1}$. The ratio of the production
cross sections times branching fractions for $B_c^+$ and $B_c^+$ mesons with
momentum transverse to the beam greater than $6~\textrm{GeV}/c$ and rapidity
magnitude smaller than 0.6 is $0.211\pm
0.012~\mbox{(stat)}^{+0.021}_{-0.020}~\mbox{(syst)}$. Using the known $B^+
\rightarrow J/\psi K^+$ branching fraction, the known $B^+$ production cross
section, and a selection of the predicted $B_c^+ \rightarrow J/\psi \mu\nu$
branching fractions, the range for the total $B_c^+$ production cross section
is estimated.
-
A measurement of vector boson ($V$) production in conjunction with a
$D^{*}(2010)^+$ meson is presented. Using a data sample corresponding to $9.7\,
{\rm fb}^{-1}$ of ^Mproton-antiproton collisions at center-of-mass energy
$\sqrt{s}=1.96\rm~ TeV$ produced by the Fermilab Tevatron, we reconstruct
$V+D^{*+}$ samples with the CDF~II detector. The $D^{*+}$ is fully
reconstructed in the $D^{*}(2010)^+ \rightarrow D^{0}(\to K^-\pi^+)\pi^+$ decay
mode. This technique is sensitive to the associated production of vector boson
plus charm or bottom mesons. We measure the ratio of production cross sections
$\sigma(W+D^{*})/\sigma(W)$ = $[1.75\pm 0.13 {\rm (stat)}\pm 0.09 {\rm
(syst)}]\% $ and $\sigma(Z+D^{*})/\sigma(Z)$ = $[1.5\pm 0.4 {\rm (stat)} \pm
0.2 {\rm (syst)}]\% $ and perform a differential measurement of
$d\sigma(W+D^{*})/dp_T(D^{*})$. Event properties are utilized to determine the
fraction of $V+D^{*}(2010)^+$ events originating from different production
processes. The results are in agreement with the predictions obtained with the
{\sc pythia} program, limiting possible contribution from non-standard-model
physics processes.
-
We measure the forward--backward asymmetry of the production of top quark and
antiquark pairs in proton-antiproton collisions at center-of-mass energy
$\sqrt{s} = 1.96~\mathrm{TeV}$ using the full data set collected by the
Collider Detector at Fermilab (CDF) in Tevatron Run II corresponding to an
integrated luminosity of $9.1~\rm{fb}^{-1}$. The asymmetry is characterized by
the rapidity difference between top quarks and antiquarks ($\Delta y$), and
measured in the final state with two charged leptons (electrons and muons). The
inclusive asymmetry, corrected to the entire phase space at parton level, is
measured to be $A_{\text{FB}}^{t\bar{t}} = 0.12 \pm 0.13$, consistent with the
expectations from the standard-model (SM) and previous CDF results in the final
state with a single charged lepton. The combination of the CDF measurements of
the inclusive $A_{\text{FB}}^{t\bar{t}}$ in both final states yields
$A_{\text{FB}}^{t\bar{t}}=0.160\pm0.045$, which is consistent with the SM
predictions. We also measure the differential asymmetry as a function of
$\Delta y$. A linear fit to $A_{\text{FB}}^{t\bar{t}}(|\Delta y|)$, assuming
zero asymmetry at $\Delta y=0$, yields a slope of $\alpha=0.14\pm0.15$,
consistent with the SM prediction and the previous CDF determination in the
final state with a single charged lepton. The combined slope of
$A_{\text{FB}}^{t\bar{t}}(|\Delta y|)$ in the two final states is
$\alpha=0.227\pm0.057$, which is $2.0\sigma$ larger than the SM prediction.
-
We report a measurement of the forward-backward asymmetry, $A_{FB}$, in
$b\bar{b}$ pairs produced in proton-antiproton collisions and identified by
muons from semileptonic $b$-hadron decays. The event sample was collected at a
center-of-mass energy of $\sqrt{s}=1.96$ TeV with the CDF II detector and
corresponds to 6.9 fb$^{-1}$ of integrated luminosity. We obtain an integrated
asymmetry of $A_{FB}(b\bar{b})=(1.2 \pm 0.7)$\% at the particle level for
$b$-quark pairs with invariant mass, $m_{b\bar{b}}$, down to $40$ GeV/$c^2$ and
measure the dependence of $A_{FB}(b\bar{b})$ on $m_{b\bar{b}}$. The results are
compatible with expectations from the standard model.
-
A search for a Higgs boson with suppressed couplings to fermions, $h_f$,
assumed to be the neutral, lower-mass partner of the Higgs boson discovered at
the Large Hadron Collider, is reported. Such a Higgs boson could exist in
extensions of the standard model with two Higgs doublets, and could be produced
via $p\bar{p} \to H^\pm h_f \to W^* h_f h_f \to 4\gamma + X$, where $H^\pm$ is
a charged Higgs boson. This analysis uses all events with at least three
photons in the final state from proton-antiproton collisions at a
center-of-mass energy of 1.96~TeV collected by the Collider Detector at
Fermilab, corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 9.2~${\rm fb}^{-1}$. No
evidence of a signal is observed in the data. Values of Higgs-boson masses
between 10 and 100 GeV/$c^2$ are excluded at 95\% Bayesian credibility.
-
We study charged particle production in proton-antiproton collisions at 300
GeV, 900 GeV, and 1.96 TeV. We use the direction of the charged particle with
the largest transverse momentum in each event to define three regions of
eta-phi space; toward, away, and transverse. The average number and the average
scalar pT sum of charged particles in the transverse region are sensitive to
the modeling of the underlying event. The transverse region is divided into a
MAX and MIN transverse region, which helps separate the hard component (initial
and final-state radiation) from the beam-beam remnant and multiple parton
interaction components of the scattering. The center-of-mass energy dependence
of the various components of the event are studied in detail. The data
presented here can be used to constrain and improve QCD Monte Carlo models,
resulting in more precise predictions at the LHC energies of 13 and 14 TeV.
-
We present a measurement of the $W$-boson-pair production cross section in
$p\bar{p}$ collisions at 1.96 TeV center-of-mass energy and the first
measurement of the differential cross section as a function of jet multiplicity
and leading-jet energy. The $W^{+}W^{-}$ cross section is measured in the final
state comprising two charged leptons and neutrinos, where either charged lepton
can be an electron or a muon. Using data collected by the CDF experiment
corresponding to $9.7~\rm{fb}^{-1}$ of integrated luminosity, a total of $3027$
collision events consistent with $W^{+}W^{-}$ production are observed with an
estimated background contribution of $1790\pm190$ events. The measured total
cross section is $\sigma(p\bar{p} \rightarrow W^{+}W^{-}) = 14.0 \pm
0.6~(\rm{stat})^{+1.2}_{-1.0}~(\rm{syst})\pm0.8~(\rm{lumi})$ pb, consistent
with the standard model prediction.
-
We present a measurement of the top-quark mass in events containing two
leptons (electrons or muons) with a large transverse momentum, two or more
energetic jets, and a transverse-momentum imbalance. We use the full
proton-antiproton collision data set collected by the CDF experiment during the
Fermilab Tevatron Run~II at center-of-mass energy $\sqrt{s} = 1.96$ TeV,
corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 9.1 fb$^{-1}$. A special
observable is exploited for an optimal reduction of the dominant systematic
uncertainty, associated with the knowledge of the absolute energy of the
hadronic jets. The distribution of this observable in the selected events is
compared to simulated distributions of ${t\bar{t}}$ dilepton signal and
background.We measure a value for the top-quark mass of $171.5\pm 1.9~{\rm
(stat)}\pm 2.5~{\rm (syst)}$ GeV/$c^2$.
-
We measure exclusive $\pi^+\pi^-$ production in proton-antiproton collisions
at center-of-mass energies $\sqrt{s}$ = 0.9 and 1.96 TeV in the Collider
Detector at Fermilab. We select events with two oppositely charged particles,
assumed to be pions, with pseudorapidity $|\eta| < 1.3$ and with no other
particles detected in $|\eta| < 5.9$. We require the $\pi^+\pi^-$ system to
have rapidity $|y|<$ 1.0. The production mechanism of these events is expected
to be dominated by double pomeron exchange, which constrains the quantum
numbers of the central state. The data are potentially valuable for isoscalar
meson spectroscopy and for understanding the pomeron in a region of transition
between nonperturbative and perturbative quantum chromodynamics. The data
extend up to dipion mass $M(\pi^+\pi^-)$ = 5000 MeV/$c^2$ and show resonance
structures attributed to $f_0$ and $f_2(1270)$ mesons. From the $\pi^+\pi^-$
and $K^+K^-$ spectra, we place upper limits on exclusive $\chi_{c0}(3415)$
production.
-
We measure the particle-level forward-backward production asymmetry in
$b\bar{b}$ pairs with masses $m(b\bar{b})$ larger than 150 GeV/$c^2$, using
events with hadronic jets and employing jet charge to distinguish $b$ from
$\bar{b}$. The measurement uses 9.5/fb of ppbar collisions at a center of mass
energy of 1.96 TeV recorded by the CDF II detector. The asymmetry as a function
of $m(b\bar{b})$ is consistent with zero, as well as with the predictions of
the standard model. The measurement disfavors a simple model including an
axigluon with a mass of 200 GeV/$c^2$ whereas a model containing a heavier 345
GeV/$c^2$ axigluon is not excluded.
-
A search for neutron-antineutron ($n-\bar{n}$) oscillation was undertaken in
Super-Kamiokande using the 1489 live-day or $2.45 \times 10^{34}$ neutron-year
exposure data. This process violates both baryon and baryon minus lepton
numbers by an absolute value of two units and is predicted by a large class of
hypothetical models where the seesaw mechanism is incorporated to explain the
observed tiny neutrino masses and the matter-antimatter asymmetry in the
Universe. No evidence for $n-\bar{n}$ oscillation was found, the lower limit of
the lifetime for neutrons bound in ${}^{16}$O, in an analysis that included all
of the significant sources of experimental uncertainties, was determined to be
$1.9 \times 10^{32}$~years at the 90\% confidence level. The corresponding
lower limit for the oscillation time of free neutrons was calculated to be $2.7
\times 10^8$~s using a theoretical value of the nuclear suppression factor of
$0.517 \times 10^{23}$~s$^{-1}$ and its uncertainty.
-
We report on a search for charged massive resonances decaying to top ($t$)
and bottom ($b$) quarks in the full data set of proton-antiproton collisions at
center-of-mass energy of $\sqrt{s} = 1.96$ TeV collected by the CDF~II detector
at the Tevatron, corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 9.5 $fb^{-1}$. No
significant excess above the standard model (SM) background prediction is
observed. We set 95% Bayesian credibility mass-dependent upper limits on the
heavy charged particle production cross section times branching ratio to $t b$.
Using a SM extension with a $W^{\prime}$ and left-right-symmetric couplings as
a benchmark model, we constrain the $W^{\prime}$ mass and couplings in the 300
to 900 GeV/$c^2$ range. The limits presented here are the most stringent for a
charged resonance with mass in the range 300 -- 600 GeV/$c^2$ decaying to top
and bottom quarks.
-
We report a measurement of single top quark production in proton-antiproton
collisions at a center-of-mass energy of \sqrt{s} = 1.96 TeV using a data set
corresponding to 7.5 fb-1 of integrated luminosity collected by the Collider
Detector at Fermilab. We select events consistent with the single top quark
decay process t \to Wb \to l{\nu}b by requiring the presence of an electron or
muon, a large imbalance of transverse momentum indicating the presence of a
neutrino, and two or three jets including at least one originating from a
bottom quark. An artificial neural network is used to discriminate the signal
from backgrounds. We measure a single top quark production cross section of
3.04+0.57-0.53 pb and set a lower limit on the magnitude of the coupling
between the top quark and bottom quark |Vtb| > 0.78 at the 95% credibility
level.
-
The next generation of long-baseline experiments is being designed to make a
substantial step in the precision of measurements of neutrino-oscillation
probabilities. Two qualitatively different proposals, Hyper-K and LBNF, are
being considered for approval. This document outlines the complimentarity
between Hyper-K and LBNF.
-
We report a measurement of the indirect CP-violating asymmetries
($A_{\Gamma}$) between effective lifetimes of anticharm and charm mesons
reconstructed in $D^0\to K^+ K^-$ and $D^0\to \pi^+\pi^-$ decays. We use the
full data set of proton-antiproton collisions collected by the Collider
Detector at Fermilab experiment and corresponding to $9.7$~fb$^{-1}$ of
integrated luminosity. The strong-interaction decay $D^{*+}\to D^0\pi^+$ is
used to identify the meson at production as $D^0$ or $\overline{D}^0$. We
statistically subtract $D^0$ and $\overline{D}^0$ mesons originating from
$b$-hadron decays and measure the yield asymmetry between anticharm and charm
decays as a function of decay time. We measure $A_\Gamma (K^+K^-) = (-0.19 \pm
0.15 (stat) \pm 0.04 (syst))\%$ and $A_\Gamma (\pi^+\pi^-)= (-0.01 \pm 0.18
(stat) \pm 0.03 (syst))\%$. The results are consistent with the hypothesis of
CP symmetry and their combination yields $A_\Gamma = (-0.12 \pm 0.12)\%$.
-
We report final measurements of direct $\mathit{CP}$--violating asymmetries
in charmless decays of neutral bottom hadrons to pairs of charged hadrons with
the upgraded Collider Detector at the Fermilab Tevatron. Using the complete
$\sqrt{s}=1.96$ TeV proton-antiproton collisions data set, corresponding to 9.3
fb$^{-1}$ of integrated luminosity, we measure $\mathcal{A}(\Lambda^0_b
\rightarrow p\pi^{-}) = +0.06 \pm 0.07\mathrm{(stat)} \pm 0.03\mathrm{(syst)}$
and $\mathcal{A}(\Lambda^0_b \rightarrow pK^{-}) = -0.10 \pm
0.08\mathrm{(stat)} \pm 0.04\mathrm{(syst)}$, compatible with no asymmetry. In
addition we measure the $\mathit{CP}$--violating asymmetries in $B^0_s
\rightarrow K^{-}\pi^{+}$ and $B^0 \rightarrow K^{+}\pi^{-}$ decays to be
$\mathcal{A}(B^0_s \rightarrow K^{-}\pi^{+}) = +0.22 \pm 0.07\mathrm{stat)} \pm
0.02\mathrm{(syst)}$ and $\mathcal{A}(B^0 \rightarrow K^{+}\pi^{-}) = -0.083\pm
0.013 \mathrm{(stat)} \pm 0.004\mathrm{(syst)}$, respectively, which are
significantly different from zero and consistent with current world averages.